Re: [marxmail] Iran attack on Israel: A Hypothesis

2024-04-14 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
Hello Michael: Many thanks for your views that you just put. Makes sense to me. Very helpful notes re China's trade with Haifa - I had not been aware of that. Do you have any references please? No worries if not, I will find it. Be well, Hari PS: CanadianBr.C 1100 am news says right now: (i) 'Isr

Re: [marxmail] Where is the United Front, Can you direct us ?

2024-11-08 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
Good evening Sartesian. No not fossilised, but maybe scotomic-blind spot viewpoint... I am not quite sure yet So: Not at all disagreeing that " the soviets were the most highly developed form of a  united front organization." That accent is surely then, falling upon these words: "the most hi

Re: [marxmail] Contemporary Western Marxism and "crisis of leadership" theory

2024-11-11 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
Douglas: Good choice in my view - given his thoughts-practice on anti-fascism. But he was an engrained Leninist - would you agree or not? I don't agree with those who have appropriated him as a fashionable icon for an anti-party thought he did not hold. I only say this in relation Marvyn's core 

Re: [marxmail] Contemporary Western Marxism and "crisis of leadership" theory

2024-11-11 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
Good am Marv: I had not realised that you had thought this was so central at the moment in your concerns. To be honest for my own part, I was more concerned at the moment, to digest the elections and considering its immediate, medium and long term. FWIW - I'll re-look at this, since it was origin

Re: [marxmail] Contemporary Western Marxism and "crisis of leadership" theory

2024-11-11 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
Good am Marv: The prior short exchange has drawn much dumping on Leninism by some, arguing how it became irrelevant (supposedly) in "free democratic" societies. I don't propose to try to tackle any of that. But 2 things that you note, I'll pick up on. I am not at all sure that we (that is you an

Re: [marxmail] Who benefits from inflation?

2024-11-12 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
Many Thx Jim! Same query to you as I put to Michale M. Namely about the boundaries between 'lending' and 'borrowing' having become possibly eroded over the 'fiscalisation' (?is that a word?) of the imperialist economies. Again - many thx for considering, H -=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=- Groups.io Link

Re: [marxmail] Who benefits from inflation?

2024-11-12 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
Thx Michael. So borrowers get cheap money. Isn't much of the financing nowadays done by non-banking firms? And isn't the boundary between 'lenders' and 'borrowers' rather less well demarcated nowadays than in the 1980s pre the petrodollar huge influx of 'hot money'? Thx for any thoughts. H -=-=

Re: [marxmail] Who benefits from inflation?

2024-11-13 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
Thanks Charlie. Perhaps to clarify, i) As to Michael, and Jim - I confirm I agree that inflation is a tool by which to squeeze further the working class; and that  it 'cheapens' money thus affecting relatively buyers and sellers of money. ii) Petrodollars came in merely as my temporal marker of t

Re: [marxmail] Woody Guthrie, Deporte (Plane wreck at Los Gatos) 1948

2024-11-13 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
Thank you. H -=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=- Groups.io Links: You receive all messages sent to this group. View/Reply Online (#33574): https://groups.io/g/marxmail/message/33574 Mute This Topic: https://groups.io/mt/109561147/21656 -=-=- POSTING RULES & NOTES #1 YOU MUST clip all extraneous text when rep

Re: [marxmail] "It's the economy, stupid!" Why Harris and the Dems lost

2024-11-10 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
Thanks, then maybe I misunderstood him. -=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=- Groups.io Links: You receive all messages sent to this group. View/Reply Online (#33460): https://groups.io/g/marxmail/message/33460 Mute This Topic: https://groups.io/mt/109469442/21656 -=-=- POSTING RULES & NOTES #1 YOU MUST clip a

Re: [marxmail] "It's the economy, stupid!" Why Harris and the Dems lost

2024-11-09 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
Hello Mike: It was in the link as provided by Charles Keener on Nov 8 at Message # 33421: in a longish article by/or at - something called 'Raven'. Namely: It is here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i7iGPm0vloA At about 1 hour 5 minutes is the bit that startled me from Hudson. Be well, H -=-=

Re: [marxmail] "It's the economy, stupid!" Why Harris and the Dems lost

2024-11-09 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
Mike: I should be way clearer. "Interesting" was not quite clear enough! He seemed to say that corporate financing was the way a 'third party' would come about...! It is not the way perhaps, that many Marxists would think it might come about. Now no doubt, as the DP loses "credibility" (even furt

[marxmail] For those in New York, an interesting potentially anti-war opera

2024-11-12 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
This is a very interesting review in WSWS of what promises to be a 'good modern opera' - for an old fashionista that is almost a contradiction in terms. Interesting that the WSWS praises its anti-war theme but the NYT review (also attached) cautions that it is:  " a little pat to describe “Ground

Re: [marxmail] Comments on the Lebanon ceasefire and broader context

2024-11-29 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
Michael K: Thank you for this synopsis. I have a query about your final paragraph. I think I saw Illan Pappe say something similar, but I cannot recall where that was. You write: "The worst defeat for Palestine since 1948 is not the "end of Palestine." Palestinian people still live and so will fi

Re: [marxmail] (Fwd) Confusion at National Endowment for 'Democracy' event Re: (Fwd) Tutu Foundation exits NED conference stage left

2024-11-27 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
So having dropped 'charges' over the last weeks, levelled at me first regarding Syria; then being a pro-Putinite; Duane now accuses me that I " help spread the Nazi trope 3 days after the invasion ". This is the 'method' of picking out quotes completely out of context. It is nothing more than t

Re: [marxmail] (Fwd) Confusion at National Endowment for 'Democracy' event Re: (Fwd) Tutu Foundation exits NED conference stage left

2024-11-27 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
Hello Michael: You have accurately gauged my overall views. Thanks for assessing them on the basis of full reading rather than excavating for the fool's gold of highly selected quotes. Mind - I would have expected nothing less of you. The problem I have seen - on this list before now - is that

Re: [marxmail] "It's the economy, stupid!" Why Harris and the Dems lost

2024-11-09 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
Very interesting to hear Michael Hudson's notions of the way a third party would come about, by the corporate oligarchy. Round about 1h3 5 mins. Most of it is a fairly long rant by both Woolf & Hudson. Most of it OK but nothing revalatory. But this snippet was an interesting turn - the Hudson th

[marxmail] Interesting review of 'a condensed short guide to Marx's Capital'

2024-11-14 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
This was posted onto Shane Hopkinson's e-accompanying list - which goes with his group-reading of Marx's works. The review was written by a member of that group - Bill Jefferies. I think I might invest in the book, anything to help a body get thru' and understand KM's 'Capital''s volumes! https:

[marxmail] Te Pāti Māori and vote on Principles of the Treaty of Waitangi Bill,

2024-11-15 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
I think there are cmdes from NZ here including John Edmundson. What good sources are there on the "Te Pāti Māori" party? What is the Marxist take on them? Obviously prompted by recent news as in this current article at NYT. https://www.nytimes.com/2024/11/15/world/asia/new-zealand-parliament-maori

[marxmail] Obituary of a prominent Canadian Lawyer

2024-11-15 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
"Mr. Sinclair, whose Anishinaabe name was Mazina Giizhik, championed Indigenous peoples’ rights as the first Indigenous person to become a judge in his home province of Manitoba, and later, when he was appointed to Canada’s Senate. But it was his work as the lead commissioner of the Truth and Re

Re: [marxmail] Alexander Bogdanov: Immortality Day

2024-11-16 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
"However incompatibilities in the blood of Bogdanov and the student which could not have been foreseen at the time" By the Red Cross dating of cross-match procedures for blood, that I had sent before, this is not a correct statement. H -=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=- Groups.io Links: You receive al

Re: [marxmail] Alexander Bogdanov: Immortality Day

2024-11-15 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
I had not appreciated that Bogdanov had died of an exchange transfusion in an un-matched recipient-donor situation. at least I think it was likely to have been un-matched, the review you cite Jim does not make that clear. It says merely: "Bogdanov was a prominent Bolshevik and a pioneer in blood

Re: [marxmail] (Fwd) Confusion at National Endowment for 'Democracy' event Re: (Fwd) Tutu Foundation exits NED conference stage left

2024-11-24 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
Hello Patrick: I confess I was a little puzzled at who/what exactly the "NED" is, that these e-blasts were targeting. So the case seems to be that the NED and 'WMD' are pro-US fronts that operate not only in South Africa - but world wide. One of the articles above states: " The modus operandi i

[marxmail] Virtual meeting of potential interest Wednesday

2024-12-02 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
*No Work for Genocide: Striking for Palestine* *Wednesday 4 December 2024, 4pm UK time/6pm Palestine time* This is an online event. To attend via Zoom, please register here ( https://kcl.us19.list-manage.com/track/click?u=a22f9a8becc8fd1716d102231&id=3c50a76d0c&e=783caad09b ) More than a year i

[marxmail] Brief book Comment

2024-12-02 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
As we move into December, no doubt the proliferation of "Messiah" concerts will grow. "Every Valley" by Charles King; New York 2024;  is a quick read - and documents how closely enmeshed both Handel and his world were with slavery. Lest we forget. Worth a quick flip. Get it from your library, no

[marxmail] Another post-mortem

2024-12-01 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
https://mlrg.online/politics/hovering-on-the-brink-of-fascism-what-happened-in-the-november-5th-2024-usa-elections/ (1) I doubt anything new to the list members here. -> " The main report is focused upon two main aims and one as yet unanswered question. First, this short report tries to analyse w

[marxmail] Back to Khalid Bakdash

2024-12-02 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
David W: Previously I had said I was not sure where i had written on Bakdash. I have now had some time to dig it up. And of course, the new events in Syria helped jog bits of my memory: (1) In this early piece I had dealt with him in relation to Khruschev: http://ml-review.ca/aml/AllianceIssues/A

[marxmail] Unique challenge to Peer review - What could an editor do with such a challenge?

2024-11-16 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
What would an editor do one wonders, with this threat? "He (Kennedy) said he would steer the nearly $48 billion annual budget of the National Institutes of Health away from drug development and toward studies that would explain high rates of chronic disease. He also said he would seek to prosecu

Re: [marxmail] Georgi Dimitroff

2024-11-14 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
Just to add to Alan's & my earlier notes: The MIA has a lot of his stuff. https://www.marxists.org/reference/archive/dimitrov/index.htm -=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=- Groups.io Links: You receive all messages sent to this group. View/Reply Online (#33587): https://groups.io/g/marxmail/message/33587 Mute

Re: [marxmail] Georgi Dimitroff

2024-11-14 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
1) Recent more academic stuff that incorporates more recent work from the archives: I have been using 'The Diary of Dimitrov" - or Dimitrov's Diary'  published by Yale Archives communism; 2008 as a source. It is to some libraries, available in an e-form. I still have not got to completing this '

Re: [marxmail] Te Pāti Māori and vote on Principles of the Treaty of Waitangi Bill,

2024-11-16 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
Many thanks John for that quick run-down. Very helpful indeed. I also enjoyed the way the 'haka' clearly discombobulated the Speaker of the House! I always thought the Maori responses to their oppression were so apparently much more forthright than the aboriginal and the Canadian indigenous ones

Re: [marxmail] (Fwd) Confusion at National Endowment for 'Democracy' event Re: (Fwd) Tutu Foundation exits NED conference stage left

2024-11-25 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
Ah Dear me Duane... Always on the hunt for the bloody, treacherous "Stalinist" in the wood pile - are you not? Usually that seems be me... Ten marks for effort (on a scale of 0-100), but goodness - 0 for accuracy. Do you just hit on words randomly? Have you heard of google? Or perhaps, if like me

Re: [marxmail] Trump and tariffs

2024-11-25 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
Hello Michael: But was not the repeal of the Corn Laws a little complicated by the internal strife of the ruling classes of Britain. That is to say the up-coming industrialists wanted cheap corn and the landed aristocracy holding onto power - did not? Marx wrote quite a bit about that, but i hav

Re: [marxmail] South Korea: After President Yoon’s failed self-coup

2024-12-05 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
A further report about the weeks long background preparations, largely un-noticed: https://jacobin.com/2024/12/yoon-suk-yeol-korea-coup I believe we might need more details on two aspects perhaps, to fully understand what happened. Namely re the relationship to the pro-Japanese moves of the Yoon

Re: [marxmail] The Party is Always Right The Untold Story of Gerry Healy and British Trotskyism

2024-12-04 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
Hello Ira: Thanks - Very interesting review by David North of Beatty ( David North, ""Biography as demonology: Aidan Beatty’s The Party is Always Right: The Untold Story of Gerry Healy and British Trotskyism"; 17 September 2024 ). I was just a bit too young in London when Trevor Griffiths was wr

Re: [marxmail] The Party is Always Right The Untold Story of Gerry Healy and British Trotskyism

2024-12-04 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
Was not so much a 'like' as a 'thanks' David. But a quick comment: If they are indeed that small, it does speak to an extraordinary output - sometimes at a high level I think. But just maintaining such a consistent 'daily news' service-output is hard. H -=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=- Groups.io Links:

Re: [marxmail] Brief book Comment

2024-12-03 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
Hi Charlie: Actually I was honestly a bit surprised as to just how many comments the little 'brief book comment' seemed to have spurred. I found the conversations intriguing and interesting, with many strands. I try to address a couple of your comments here. Truly - it was only meant to be simp

Re: [marxmail] Why classical music in Vienna and New York on William Kentridge's ogh to believe in a better world about Lenin and Trotsky could be a sign of an abrupt turn to the left in the Imperiali

2024-12-07 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
Thank you Antony Brain & Wm Quimby. Can you deconstruct what Kentridge is driving at there? I confess that I am conflicted about him. Undoubtedly a tremendously talented artist. In this following youtube - he explores the myths of the Sibyl and Perseus around fate and 'fates'. Now admittedly, in

Re: [marxmail] The Party is Always Right The Untold Story of Gerry Healy and British Trotskyism

2024-12-07 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
Thank you Paul. Re: " It’s certainly true that if the CIA ever succeeds in eliminating the WRP leadership, casting directors everywhere will be in trouble. . . The WRP’s main star, Gerry Healy, has not himself trodden the boards of the legitimate stage, but his gifts as actor, producer and direc

Re: [marxmail] Syria’s Rebels Close on Damascus

2024-12-07 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
Charles Lister in Der Spiegel (-> https://www.spiegel.de/ausland/syrien-news-milizenfuehrer-verspricht-sicherheit-fuer-alawiten-der-tag-zum-nachlesen-a-9c83f23e-a470-4c15-8e0c-ffb0548bf151 ) via google-translate: " Syria expert on the situation Charles Lister, Syria expert from the Middle East In

Re: [marxmail] Trotskyism as the flip side of Stalinism

2024-12-28 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
Hello Gojo: I hesitate quite frankly - to engage. Because I sincerely do not think that on this matter there is likely to be anything but, as Mao put it "an antagonistic contradiction:. [I very rarely feel inspired to cite a phrase by Mao, but in this case it as a phrase pithily sums up what I t

Re: [marxmail] SPLIT IN THE RULING CLASS?

2024-12-28 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
Hello Michael: I also agree with your about Heather Cox-R. I see her mails every day, and while at times they are a bit 'twee and somewhat supine to the Democrats, I think they are usually worth reading. Her views on this divide are widely held it seems - including of course John R. Last week th

Re: [marxmail] Trotskyism as the flip side of Stalinism

2024-12-28 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
Forgive me - I got your name wrong Gojko - unintentional. Cheers Hari -=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=- Groups.io Links: You receive all messages sent to this group. View/Reply Online (#34295): https://groups.io/g/marxmail/message/34295 Mute This Topic: https://groups.io/mt/110224367/21656 -=-=- POSTING RU

[marxmail] Any views from Canadian comrades on Trudeau's fate and its effects??

2025-01-07 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
I would be interested if cmdes had any views that either contradict or supplement the below? It comes from the WSWS; and I believe it is a reasonable picture of events. Any thoughts from North of the USA border? https://www.wsws.org/en/articles/2025/01/07/lpti-j07.html?pk_campaign=wsws-newslette

Re: [marxmail] Britains Rape Gangs Coming Under Scrutiny

2025-01-06 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
Hi Mark & Sartesian: I agree it is not worth keeping the thread going. I do perhaps - as a closure - add: 1) I checked with a social workers in the N.East who I had worked with for many years and she said this: "I’m not sure that Starmer is the issue here. The various child abuse scandals raised

[marxmail] ". . . how extensively Israeli spies had penetrated Hezbollah. . . "

2024-12-29 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
" Right up until he was assassinated, Hassan Nasrallah did not believe that Israel would kill him. As he hunkered inside a Hezbollah fortress 40 feet underground on Sept. 27, his aides urged him to go to a safer location. Mr. Nasrallah brushed it off, according to intelligence collected by Israe

[marxmail] More on Syrian Liberation from Assad

2024-12-27 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
"Unequivocally, the final fall of the Assad hereditary and fascist regime is a great step forward to be celebrated by and for the Syrian people. . . The current situation in Syria also marks a broader key moment, the withdrawal of Russia from the center of the Middle East. In a swinging geopoliti

Re: [marxmail] Trotskyism as the flip side of Stalinism

2024-12-28 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
Thanks Peter: In the takeovers of various factories threatened with closures (See Italy: https://www.theleftberlin.com/insorgiamo-we-rise-up/ and  Argentina comes to mind https://upsidedownworld.org/archives/argentina/argentine-factory-in-the-hands-of-the-workers-fasinpat-a-step-closer-to-perman

Re: [marxmail] Trotskyism as the flip side of Stalinism

2024-12-28 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
Hah! Am I then 'hoist on my own petard?' says Mark - eh?! Most likely as always, yes. . . But complex. . . Interesting question in many ways. If I bore you, you will no doubt move to the next message. . but there are a few layers here! 1) The derivation of the term - one meant to enshrine whites

Re: [marxmail] Trotskyism as the flip side of Stalinism

2024-12-29 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
Interesting view Tom. However I do not know what to make of it. Is it to be interpreted that there is an evolution of views? that all labels are meaningless? that there is no political dividing lines between these labels. . . or. . .? Which was the original sin, or the original gulp? H -=-=-=-=-=

Re: [marxmail] Big THANX to Les Schaffer and the Comrade Moderators

2024-12-24 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
Good am in particular to Tom, Jim and Dennis: Obviously the sparse postings by those discernibly female, is a concern. (We have not even touched on the issue of other diversities). In any case, I do have three simple points: i) Separation of *content* matter and *tone of debate* seems important t

Re: [marxmail] Can Trump institute fascism?

2024-12-24 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
Good am Mark. Thanks. Does anyone know where the data is for that pay-scale disparity? I realise other issues may be more important than merely a potentially 'veiled' open listing of wages. But I am thinking back to Marv Gandall's comment that this question of a trade union bureaucracy is not as

Re: [marxmail] Big THANX to Les Schaffer and the Comrade Moderators

2024-12-24 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
Thank you Karen. Any practical suggestions to offer to rectify what is happening? If you can offer some that would be great. If not - quite understand. Hari -=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=- Groups.io Links: You receive all messages sent to this group. View/Reply Online (#34245): https://groups.io/g/marxm

Re: [marxmail] what we are witnessing in Syria today is a huge defeat

2024-12-30 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
Good afternoon Michael: Thx for appending the prior note you had written on Tariq Ali - which makes sense to me - no problems. Again, I have no interest in defending Ali at all - he is pretty virulently anti-my people, meaning what I call ML-ists.  I have followed his career over decades since t

Re: [marxmail] Trotskyism as the flip side of Stalinism

2024-12-30 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
Hello Tom: OK - that does help me locate far more what you are talking to. In fact you have - I believe anyway - talked of this before. But I will openly confess, it always struck me as being so 'academic' - that it was a deterrent to my trying to understand it properly. And yes, perhaps I simpl

Re: [marxmail] what we are witnessing in Syria today is a huge defeat

2024-12-30 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
Good am John. Surely you are mis-reading Tariq Ali? I mean is he not forecasting what will happen with the USA and Israel now more overtly than before, controlling the Middle East? Perhaps you understand that I have no brief for Tariq Ali. But on this he is surely correct? H -=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=

Re: [marxmail] Trotskyism as the flip side of Stalinism

2024-12-29 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
Hey Tom: So, trying to understand what the fundamental 'gulp' or foundation of the 'path dependency' was. On the first 'candidate' - I guess one would have to read the book to get the 'drift'. But it seems that you are not referring to the famous 'Preface' outlining some key notions of histori

Re: [marxmail] Trotskyism as the flip side of Stalinism

2024-12-28 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
Gojko: Being from former Yugoslavia, I would submit - is not the gold standard to enable a critique of what you call Stalinism. I do not believe we will come to terms on this. I am not a Maoist, so my own terms of reference do not align with Charlie. However he is correct on this matter in my vi

Re: [marxmail] what we are witnessing in Syria today is a huge defeat

2024-12-31 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
Hello Sartesian: Thanks for that data point. Honestly I was more focused on the second part of that sentence - "Syria will now become a shared American–Turkish colony". I think that remains very likely the case, although the word 'colony' is not fitting the bill so much as perhaps neo-colony. W

Re: [marxmail] Parliamentary battles spark anti-fascist demonstrations on the street in Germany

2025-01-31 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
Correction to "only the AfD and Sarah Wagenknecht's BSW followed him with 7 votes BSW 'yes' and 3 absent. " The diagram is transparent enough though. The "FDP' with a pretty discredited Lindner also followed Merz. H -=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=- Groups.io Links: You receive all messages sent to this

Re: [marxmail] Trump the realtor's proposal to renovict and gentrify Gaza

2025-02-05 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
Thanks Marv for posting this. As time goes on it is certainly obvious that those here who were arguing that the Gaza Ceasefire represented some sort of a "victory" for Gazans-Palestinians were over-optimistic (to say the very least). But also as time goes on, the more does all the Trumpian extra

Re: [marxmail] palestinian/Arab community leaders against Trump

2025-02-06 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
Not only is 'effectiveness' a problem. Speed of counter-response or should I say 'slowness' - is also. Longer it 'sets' the more unable to easily to remove. H -=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=- Groups.io Links: You receive all messages sent to this group. View/Reply Online (#35025): https://groups.io/g/ma

Re: [marxmail] The brilliant "Marxist" geniuses

2025-02-06 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
I do not know if this following remark fits onto the title of the strand exactly. On the other hand it is sparked by comments under this title. The remark could be considered as a 'philosophical' comment, or perhaps more as a form of a lament. At this stage as the USA state structure is being '

Re: [marxmail] The brilliant "Marxist" geniuses

2025-02-07 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
Sartesian - a perfectly reasonable and apt query. I have been thinking, and I continue (presumably like many here) to do so. I will try to frame it shortly. H -=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=- Groups.io Links: You receive all messages sent to this group. View/Reply Online (#35047): https://groups.io/g/mar

[marxmail] German 'Firewalls' and other contortions

2025-02-07 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
A piece that tries to show where the Federal Elections due to take place end-Feb are leading to. The “Metamorphoses’ of Would be CDU Chancellor Friederich Merz and the 2025 German Federal Elections": at MLRG.online -> https://mlrg.online/current-events/the-metamorphoses-of-would-be-cdu-chancello

Re: [marxmail] More Medical Updates on Gaza in Lancet-Part 2

2025-02-01 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
Sorry - I shall be quiet for a bit to make up! It all hinged on the same paper with letters and author-rebuttals, that was the reasons. I apologise for density overload. H -=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=- Groups.io Links: You receive all messages sent to this group. View/Reply Online (#34942): https://g

Re: [marxmail] Martin Wolf as a mirror of neoliberal distress

2025-02-02 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
I had not heard of this tense before - I would have described it as purely 'passive' - and try to follow George Orwell's writing advice to avoid it (yes indeed that right winger George Orwell wrote very well about how to write well). But the formulation here does ring perfectly truly: "Wolf uses

[marxmail] "Over-reach" - and "muzzle velocity"...?

2025-02-02 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
I know a lot of people depressed right now watching what is going on in North Americas. Given my age, many are pensioners who are actually simply worried about their pensions. Of those up North in Canada, several I know are simply worried about the tariffs and a recession and groceries. There is

Re: [marxmail] Parliamentary battles spark anti-fascist demonstrations on the street in Germany

2025-01-31 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
Hello Mark: No I don't have an x account. However the article from 'Arbeiter Zukunft' (https://www.arbeit-zukunft.de/2024/12/24/magdeburg-rechter-afd-sympathisant-ermordet-5-menschen/ ) shows the image of a machinegun that the deranged person had on that account. H -=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=- Grou

Re: [marxmail] Declaration: An Internationalist Position on the Fall of Assad and the Crisis in Syria

2024-12-18 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
Good evening David. So you enumerated I think - three Internationals following Trotsky. But then yu say also there are a "Lot more" than 5. So how many are there in fact? I know this is not a 'train-spotting' list (I quickly left that list as it got just far too 'encyclopaedist' and somewhat ove

Re: [marxmail] The collapse of the Assad regime: An interview on Syria with Gilbert Achcar

2024-12-18 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
Thank you Chris. I think this nuanced and balanced view is more sensible than a hailing of the HTS as an unqualified "revolution". But one that *also* celebrates the freeing of the Syrian people from the Assadite herediatry fascist stranglehold. FWIW The situation seems to me, as being akin to

[marxmail] Musk urges Germany to vote AfD

2024-12-20 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
By Felix Keßler, Torsten Kleinz and Kim Staudt December 20, 2024, 4:38 p.m at: https://www.spiegel.de/politik/deutschland/elon-musk-empfiehlt-wahl-der-afd-wie-elon-musk-den-bundestagswahlkampf-aufmischt-a-da4c4140-a65e-4a9c-8686-3b30f9dea852 Headline via Go-Translate: " Musk's recommendation to vo

[marxmail] The Avignon 'Amazons' bolster and support Madame Gisele Pelicot

2024-12-19 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
I thought the tactics of pasting up words from the trial to publicise the actual testimony, a good way of reminding the population of Avignon (and France) of the realities. At: https://www.nytimes.com/2024/12/20/world/europe/avignon-france-pelicot-trial.html?unlocked_article_code=1.i04.MDpm.2EdC

Re: [marxmail] Declaration: An Internationalist Position on the Fall of Assad and the Crisis in Syria

2024-12-19 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
Thanks David. Perhaps your characterisation of why the reasons the ML parties split as being the "same" as the reason the Trotsky parties split may not be quite right is this: The reasons (apart from the supervening personality ones, which were not to be minimised and numerous) were : Khruschevi

Re: [marxmail] Declaration: An Internationalist Position on the Fall of Assad and the Crisis in Syria

2024-12-19 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
Hi Mark. Thanks for this primer on AI. Their usage in information sciences have rocketed. As one example, medical peer review journals now allow 'blind' authors to use chat-Bot-AI. But they are supposed to declare this. I have no idea how that can be policed actually. In any case is there a 'sta

[marxmail] Nan Goldin opens Exhibition at the National Galerie Berlin with an excoriating speech

2024-11-23 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
https://www.spiegel.de/politik/deutschland/gaza-krieg-und-kunst-nan-goldin-ausstellung-sorgt-fuer-eklat-in-der-neuen-nat ( https://www.spiegel.de/politik/deutschland/gaza-krieg-und-kunst-nan-goldin-ausstellung-sorgt-fuer-eklat-in-der-neuen-nationalgalerie-a-73d24821-76c3-40e5-9057-1a0bd3327ae6?sa

Re: [marxmail] South Korea: The Failed Coup Attempt of Yoon Suk Yeol

2024-12-06 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
Ooops  message here: hari kumar 7:33pm   #33927 - is a repeat of earlier link. H -=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=- Groups.io Links: You receive all messages sent to this group. View/Reply Online (#33928): https://groups.io/g/marxmail/message/33928 Mute This Topic: https://groups.io/mt/109917761/21656 -=-=-

Re: [marxmail] South Korea: The Failed Coup Attempt of Yoon Suk Yeol

2024-12-06 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
Final twiddle on this, following the name: -> Labor & the Long Road to Reunification in Korea (w/ Ju-Hyun Park); August 30, 2023 "In These TImes"; at-> https://inthesetimes.com/episodes/working-pod-korea-reunification-2 -=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=- Groups.io Links: You receive all messages sent to th

Re: [marxmail] South Korea: The Failed Coup Attempt of Yoon Suk Yeol

2024-12-06 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
Sorry - but this is also a very interesting quote from the same piece: "The opposition in the streets was coming from the organized labor movement which even went as far as to release a joint statement with the Organization of Trade Unions in the DPRK or North Korea itself. So this was a united s

Re: [marxmail] South Korea: The Failed Coup Attempt of Yoon Suk Yeol

2024-12-06 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
I made a bit if time to look around, and does not address your query - but I did find some very interesting (to me anyway) background information. A rather long article consisting of an interview with a US based Korean activist in "These Times": "South Korea Declared War on Unions. Workers Are F

Re: [marxmail] Martial Law in South Korea

2024-12-03 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
Does it not seem so? Already withdrawn - right? -=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=- Groups.io Links: You receive all messages sent to this group. View/Reply Online (#33871): https://groups.io/g/marxmail/message/33871 Mute This Topic: https://groups.io/mt/109906971/21656 -=-=- POSTING RULES & NOTES #1 YOU MUS

[marxmail] Meanwhile - Europe's Little King and the Locomotive Driver go off rail

2024-12-05 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
While all the drama in South Korea goes on, at the other side of the world matters are also heating up. - The Guardian has a good breakout of how coalitions might look in France after the 'little king's' man got fired in parliament yesterday  ( https://www.theguardian.com/world/2024/dec/05/who-

Re: [marxmail] The rotten-ness of this society amplified by social media - a small 'trivial' peek at it

2024-12-23 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
whoops: "This in the service of a couple of exploitative and misogynist rich actor/director clients (whose names I definitely was completely aware of)." should be : ". . (whose names I definitely was completely UNaware of)." -=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=- Groups.io Links: You receive all messages sent

[marxmail] The rotten-ness of this society amplified by social media - a small 'trivial' peek at it

2024-12-23 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
There are so many countless stories of the utter decadence, viciousness and awfulness of current society, that rightly - we on the list focus mainly on the 'high politics'. After all - Gaza is pretty impossible to top in terms of its "utter decadence, viciousness and awfulness". And frankly Marx

Re: [marxmail] Defining genocide: how a rift over Gaza sparked a crisis among scholars

2024-12-21 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
Sort of tell us what even progressive scholars - isolated from any working class movement - can do. Namely nothing. But the article does seem to falter on not even discussing Finkelstein's careful dissection of 'the Holocaust industry'. Perhaps one should charitably assume it takes an understand

Re: [marxmail] Are layers of the Anarchists moving towards Trotsky's transitional method despite having this author having the worse aspects of Anaracism!

2024-12-21 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
Thank you John. I certainly agree with your thrust and your overall analysis. . . for WIW my opinion is! However - I hope that you will not mind a single question/comment to you - You characterise yourself as an anarchist , though a qualified one, being a Marxist-Anarchist or as you put it an 'a

Re: [marxmail] Britains Rape Gangs Coming Under Scrutiny

2025-01-09 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
Absolutely no one here has tried to "bury this story". I believe this thread is closed as it seems no one has given any further adequate positions to supplement those of a fairly long lasting thread. I'd suggest any closing remarks - or substantively new data-remarks - simply be made and then t

Re: [marxmail] War of redivision

2025-01-21 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
Les & Anthony - To add: Today in Adam Tooze a reference from the FT (which I do not have access to): https://adamtooze.substack.com/p/decomposing-economic-surprise-when?utm_campaign=email-half-post&r=17xgfq&utm_source=substack&utm_medium=email"; -> "Threats only work, if you actually have leverage

[marxmail] A new age of US imperialism

2025-01-26 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
[Sorry Mark: I am very clearly hyper-ventilating, and I will get a paper bag out next in order to re-breathe into it - Thus no more emails from me today . . .  However, this report from the FT I saw now is part of a pattern, and seems to me quite linked to Gazan moves - I feel]. FT 26 January,

[marxmail] Talk of victory for Hamas - and indeed for Palestine - should surely stop finally

2025-01-26 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
Obviously the Palestinians (and we) need to watch carefully how all this unfolds. But under-estimating both USA and Israeli policy intents to re-make the map are traps for the Left. Even more so of course for the Palestinians and Left on the ground. If the left really wishes to, and (of course i

[marxmail] Fast pulling of NHS to further privatization in UK

2025-01-26 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
Not sure if anyone here is interested in this overall topic. Which perhaps is really about the continued slide of the UK towards Nigel Farage-ist near-to- fascism . . . and not so much the NHS itself, although that is alone pretty interesting and worrying for me anyway. However. . . Starmer (PM

Re: [marxmail] A new age of US imperialism

2025-01-27 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
I would sincerely caution against thinking that the Pentagon and USA power has been 'weakened' by the appointment of Trumpite figure-head. Do you really think the power of the armed forces has been cancelled by Hegseth? Perhaps the Pentagon spine has been stiffened to act against home-USA constit

[marxmail] Break throughs in Fusion - or not - A query

2025-01-28 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
" In 2017 scientists at EAST broke the 100 seconds barrier for a steady-state H-mode plasma and then in 2023 achieved a 403 seconds, a world record at the time. On Monday, EAST officials announced that they had almost tripled that time, delivering H-mode operation for 1066 seconds. Be intereste

Re: [marxmail] Every Day in the birth of babies in the USA

2025-01-28 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
Sorry I got the title partly wrong - but that is what the tile really means i think! -=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=- Groups.io Links: You receive all messages sent to this group. View/Reply Online (#34904): https://groups.io/g/marxmail/message/34904 Mute This Topic: https://groups.io/mt/110872068/21656

Re: [marxmail] Professor Loren Graham, R.I.P.

2025-01-25 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
Sorry that one-liner was for Sartesian. Also - it sort of struck me Sartesian: That perhaps you sometimes over-react to the term 'reductionism' from exactly this sort of vantage point. I do not know if this is accurate, and you may disagree. However I recall an instance where you objected stron

Re: [marxmail] Professor Loren Graham, R.I.P.

2025-01-25 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
I agree with each of those sentences. H -=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=- Groups.io Links: You receive all messages sent to this group. View/Reply Online (#34830): https://groups.io/g/marxmail/message/34830 Mute This Topic: https://groups.io/mt/110792212/21656 -=-=- POSTING RULES & NOTES #1 YOU MUST clip a

Re: [marxmail] Professor Loren Graham, R.I.P.

2025-01-25 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
Good am Jim: Thanks for the notice. Sincere condolences to Prof Graham's family, FWIW. I was on that zoom conference you note. He was somewhat surprised by my interventions - he was not expecting I think to find a person conversant (to some degree) with the new science of epigenetics there. I w

Re: [marxmail] union leaders prove medical science wrong

2025-01-25 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
I spot our old tradition from William Morris and John Ball. A good updating John - I wish it were true. . . Maybe it will become so. (-> https://www.marxists.org/archive/morris/works/1886/johnball/johnball.htm at MIA) -=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=- Groups.io Links: You receive all messages sent to this

Re: [marxmail] Public Debate: What is the Class Character of China?

2025-01-14 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
Lieber Michael: I am sorry to miss this, but I left Berlin after the Luxemburg weekend, and for work had to be back in Canada until the spring. I commend you and the others for having such a debate. I think personally it is one of the key issues as we move into a period of even more heightened

Re: [marxmail] Public Debate: What is the Class Character of China?

2025-01-14 Thread hari kumar via groups.io
Hello Michael: I think it is reasonable to offer a correction here. As far as I am aware the MLPD is certainly not an upholder of the Hoxha tradition. They are certainly quite large, and they are very clearly Maoist. -> https://www.mlpd.de/english/program-of-the-marxist-leninist-party.pdf As far

  1   2   >