Re: Seeking a Champion for Hamilton and/or Burr to apply for the Apache Incubator Program

Hi All, Thank you for your patience. Here are the two proposal drafts: - Hamilton - Burr

Re: Seeking a Champion for Hamilton and/or Burr to apply for the Apache Incubator Program

Awesome thanks PJ! Please if you have reactions, questions, or general thoughts, I'm all ears! Thanks in advance! On Tue, Mar 18, 2025 at 2:31 AM PJ Fanning wrote: > Hi everyone, > I've copied the 2 docs to cwiki. > * https://cwiki.apache.org/confluence/display/INCUBATOR/HamiltonProposal > * ht

Re: Seeking a Champion for Hamilton and/or Burr to apply for the Apache Incubator Program

Hi everyone, I've copied the 2 docs to cwiki. * https://cwiki.apache.org/confluence/display/INCUBATOR/HamiltonProposal * https://cwiki.apache.org/confluence/display/INCUBATOR/BurrProposal Feel free to edit the proposals. Stefan - if you want to suggest any changes, email me and I can make the chan

Re: Seeking a Champion for Hamilton and/or Burr to apply for the Apache Incubator Program

Hey sorry, this is on me. I'm splitting it into two proposals. ETA for it to be ready is next week. Thanks 🙏 On Fri, Mar 14, 2025, 5:54 AM Kevin Ratnasekera wrote: > Hi, > > Are we good to start discussion thread on incubator proposal? > > Regards > Kevin > > On Wed, Feb 19, 2025 at 1:40 AM Stef

Re: Seeking a Champion for Hamilton and/or Burr to apply for the Apache Incubator Program

Hi, Are we good to start discussion thread on incubator proposal? Regards Kevin On Wed, Feb 19, 2025 at 1:40 AM Stefan Krawczyk wrote: > @Ayush and @PJ could I propose a 15 minute call to chat about your comments > please? I think a higher bandwidth medium will save us some back and forth > o

Re: Seeking a Champion for Hamilton and/or Burr to apply for the Apache Incubator Program

@Ayush and @PJ could I propose a 15 minute call to chat about your comments please? I think a higher bandwidth medium will save us some back and forth on the topic. If so, please email me directly with your schedules and I'll coordinate a time - else will put comments in the doc. Thanks in advance

Re: Seeking a Champion for Hamilton and/or Burr to apply for the Apache Incubator Program

Hi Everyone, Apologies for the delay here (🤷‍♂️ *life *🤷‍♂️). @PJ, Ayush, and Kevin - thank you for the offer of mentoring. I have shared this raw draft google doc with you that lays out the proposa

Re: Seeking a Champion for Hamilton and/or Burr to apply for the Apache Incubator Program

Hi Stefan. For people who agree to join the PPMC for Hamilton/Burr, they will need to sign ASF iCLAs anyway. So I don't think they'll need to agree to relicense as well. It's the people who don't agree to join the PPMC that we will have to look into asking to still sign the ASF iCLA or if that i

Re: Seeking a Champion for Hamilton and/or Burr to apply for the Apache Incubator Program

Great, thank you. I believe my *more immediate* tasks then are: 1. Identify core committers outside of DAGWorks Inc. and get ICLAs. 2. Get them to agree to a relicense. Could it be as simple as getting them to write something like the following? > *Acknowledgment Statement* > > I, [Your Full Nam

Re: Seeking a Champion for Hamilton and/or Burr to apply for the Apache Incubator Program

Hi, > Don’t you mean SGA (and not CCLA)? We would also require an SGA. DAGWorks may want to submit a CCLA, but you are correct in that we don’t require one. Kind Regards, Justin

Re: Seeking a Champion for Hamilton and/or Burr to apply for the Apache Incubator Program

> On Jan 3, 2025, at 2:13 PM, Justin Mclean wrote: > > Hi, > >> 2. Question, does the whole repository need the same license? e.g. >> including documentation and examples? > > It would be preferable to re-license as many files as possible to the Apache > license, but ASF projects can includ

Re: Seeking a Champion for Hamilton and/or Burr to apply for the Apache Incubator Program

Hi, > 2. Question, does the whole repository need the same license? e.g. > including documentation and examples? It would be preferable to re-license as many files as possible to the Apache license, but ASF projects can include 3rd party code under a compatible license like BSD. > 4. Segmentin

Re: Seeking a Champion for Hamilton and/or Burr to apply for the Apache Incubator Program

Great thanks. Two items: CLA and number of committees. CLA Understanding that these are legal questions and you might not have all the answers - I will take any responses with a grain of salt and do my own diligence. 1. I don't see an issue with the switch since patent stuff isn't an issue today

Re: Seeking a Champion for Hamilton and/or Burr to apply for the Apache Incubator Program

There might be a relicensing guide somewhere but in practice, I think people avoid giving general guidance on legal issues because there might be cases where the advice is problematic. I'm not working today so will find it hard to search around for docs online. One article that I did find. It ment

Re: Seeking a Champion for Hamilton and/or Burr to apply for the Apache Incubator Program

Thank you Kevin, Aysh, and PJ! It sounds like I should focus on getting CLAs first? I assumed with BSD-3 I wouldn't need them... Is there a guide somewhere for that? E.g. what language to use? What doesn't require a CLA? What happens if I can't get a hold of someone? etc. Regarding two committee

Re: Seeking a Champion for Hamilton and/or Burr to apply for the Apache Incubator Program

HI Stefan, I can even volunteer as a mentor for the projects during Incubation. -Ayush On Fri, 3 Jan 2025 at 02:18, Kevin Ratnasekera wrote: > > Hi Stefan, > > These projects look interesting. I am interested in voluteering as a mentor > incubator process. > > Regards > Kevin > > On Fri, Jan 3,

Re: Seeking a Champion for Hamilton and/or Burr to apply for the Apache Incubator Program

Hi Stefan, These projects look interesting. I am interested in voluteering as a mentor incubator process. Regards Kevin On Fri, Jan 3, 2025 at 2:04 AM PJ Fanning wrote: > Hi Stefan, > > It looks like both projects (Hamilton and Burr) are in a healthy state. > > I can act as a mentor and help w

Re: Seeking a Champion for Hamilton and/or Burr to apply for the Apache Incubator Program

Hi Stefan, It looks like both projects (Hamilton and Burr) are in a healthy state. I can act as a mentor and help with championing if that suits. One item to decide on is if you want to create 2 separate podling committees or if you want to create 1 committee that manages 2 separate source repos

Re: Seeking a Champion for Hamilton and/or Burr to apply for the Apache Incubator Program

Hi Everyone, Happy New Year - just bumping this thread! Would love any and all feedback. Cheers, Stefan On Fri, Dec 27, 2024 at 1:14 PM Stefan Krawczyk wrote: > Dear Apache Incubator PMC, > > I hope this email finds you well. My name is Stefan Krawczyk >

Seeking a Champion for Hamilton and/or Burr to apply for the Apache Incubator Program

Dear Apache Incubator PMC, I hope this email finds you well. My name is Stefan Krawczyk , and I am reaching out to introduce two projects Hamilton , & Burr , that I would like to