G. wrote: > On Wed, 22 Jul 2009, Roger Hicks wrote: >> No, really. The grid in this case would just be for visual >> representation, and wouldn't really need to be a grid at all (forget >> any previous poor execution of a grid in other not-to-be-named nomics >> - B) > > Agora has had three grids since 2001 (two rules; one contest) and at least > one "location-based" set of rules before that (before my time). Here's one: > http://www.agoranomic.org/cgi-bin/mailman/private/agora-official/2002-November > Not all were pure "grids", some were "positional" where the position gave > you powers, like your proto. > > None were particularly compelling. Like Notes, the overhead of choosing > one's location etc. was just More Trouble Than It Was Worth. It's not > that your proto is bad, it's just that it's similar and for some reason, > the past ones just didn't work particularly well.
How were Notes any more troublesome than the AAA? (I suppose that raises the question of whether the AAA has also run its course.)
