On Fri, 2015-05-01 at 17:43 -0700, Tod Fitch wrote:

> ... I guess the page could be renamed to campground pitch 
No need ! Its the camp_site= part that is my problem.

> (I guess I should look into how one properly can rename a wiki page. . .)
Hmm, carefully I suggest.


> I guess there could be a issue on naming. The
> http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Proposed_features/Camp_Site page as
> I understand it would cover the entire area of the campground while I
> am trying to address the individual pitches within. What do you
> suggest?

Yep, thats my concern. A camp_site (in UK speak, not mine) might be a
larger area or possibly just a node marking, eg, the entrance where
larger area is unknown. The pitches, again nodes or areas may be within
the camp_site area or (yek!) near the camp_site node. 
> 

> I haven’t been in a RV/caravan only type campground ....

There are some like that, maybe a concrete or tarmac base so tent pages
a problem, maybe operator/owner just wants self contained campers.

I'd suggest for this purpose we treat them as the same, #define
caravan_site = camp_site. There are other tags to tell the difference.
> 
....
> Suggestions for this? Perhaps simply camp_pitch=yes to be used in both
> tourism=camp_site and tourism=caravan_site?
> 
Hmm, lets experiment ...

Node
tourism = camp_site
camp_site = standard
name = Happy Jacks

Node
tourism = camp_site
camp_pitch = yes
ref = 42
addr:unit = 42
camp_pitch:picnic_table=yes

Node
....

What I don't see here is how to associate the pitches with "Happy
Jacks". I guess the easy solution is to say only map pitches where they
will fall into an (tourism=camp_site) area ? Hard solution is a
relation ?

I think its sad we cannot put something more useful than "yes" after
camp_pitch= but I know someone saw a problem with my suggestion of
camp_pitch=42 ?

Starting to look like this is firming up anyway, good, we need these
solutions. I notice that user N76 says he did a good part of the
camp_site=pitch on record and is happy to rename them. We appreciate
such a helpful attitude ! (Voting on the camp_site= proposal page).

David




_______________________________________________
Tagging mailing list
Tagging@openstreetmap.org
https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging

Reply via email to