Re: [RBW] Re: So Torn, Cannot Decide

2011-10-11 Thread René Sterental
It's very clear Joe. Don't worry about it. René -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "RBW Owners Bunch" group. To post to this group, send email to rbw-owners-bunch@googlegroups.com. To unsubscribe from this group, send email to rbw-owners-bunch+unsubscr

[RBW] Re: So Torn, Cannot Decide

2011-10-11 Thread Joe Bernard
There have been several comments about "pressure" after I restated my original comment, which leads me to believe my clarification did not hold. To reiterate, Rivendell is the mellowest non-pressure phone experience you will ever have with a bike maker/seller. I was referring to my own *inter

[RBW] Re: So Torn, Cannot Decide

2011-10-10 Thread William
+1 on John's assertion that the if there's ever pressure from Riv, it's more likely to tell you what you don't need. I like having a bunch of bikes with slightly different 'personalities', and don't mind at all having bikes that overlap a lot in what they are good at. When I was thinking abo

Re: [RBW] Re: So Torn, Cannot Decide

2011-10-09 Thread cyclotourist
GREAT! The decision makes a lot of sense. Need pix! On Sun, Oct 9, 2011 at 8:24 PM, Jeff H wrote: > > I spent quite a bit of time deciding between models, the original > objective was a single bike to handle my varied style of riding, urban > to exploration. > Lots of research, looking at phot

[RBW] Re: So Torn, Cannot Decide

2011-10-09 Thread Jeff H
I spent quite a bit of time deciding between models, the original objective was a single bike to handle my varied style of riding, urban to exploration. Lots of research, looking at photos on the internet, 3 trips to RWBHQ, reading the discussions on line etc. I narrowed it down to Atlantis, Hillb

[RBW] Re: So Torn, Cannot Decide

2011-10-07 Thread islaysteve
Do you have frequent flyer miles? This is a lovely time of year to visit the San Francisco Bay Area! (not quite kidding!) -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "RBW Owners Bunch" group. To view this discussion on the web visit https://groups.google.com/

[RBW] Re: So Torn, Cannot Decide

2011-10-06 Thread Lisa
If you really want to go, and have the time, you can make your trip to Harris Cyclery car-free. Take Amtrak from NYC to Boston' s South Station. You can take the Acela or the Northeast Regional train. Then take the commuter rail (Worcester line) from South Station to West Newton station. Har

RE: [RBW] Re: So Torn, Cannot Decide

2011-10-06 Thread Joe Bernard
Boy do I wish I hadn't said THAT. Yes, I meant "internal pressure", and I'm probably projecting my own Aspergers-related struggles with phone calls. I shouldn't have mentioned it. Sorry. -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "RBW Owners Bunch" group. To v

RE: [RBW] Re: So Torn, Cannot Decide

2011-10-06 Thread Allingham II, Thomas J
bunch@googlegroups.com] On Behalf Of dougP Sent: Thursday, October 06, 2011 2:04 PM To: RBW Owners Bunch Subject: [RBW] Re: So Torn, Cannot Decide Here's another vote for "talk to the guys at Rivendell". There is zero pressure, and they ask a lot of questions about you & your riding

[RBW] Re: So Torn, Cannot Decide

2011-10-06 Thread dougP
Here's another vote for "talk to the guys at Rivendell". There is zero pressure, and they ask a lot of questions about you & your riding, etc., in order to get you onto the best bike for you. This also makes you really think about what you want and what you're going to do with the bike. If anyth

[RBW] Re: So Torn, Cannot Decide

2011-10-06 Thread Peter M
Oh I have called Riv a few times just to pester them with a million questions and never had anyone ask me to buy something or made me feel like I was wasting thier time. They are all really awesome guys. The issue is that in the NYC area it is hard to find anyone who owns a Rivendell to give it a

[RBW] Re: So Torn, Cannot Decide

2011-10-06 Thread John Bennett
Dear Joe, I figure you mean internal pressure, not from us. In my 11 years here, I've never heard anyone go even close to that on the phone or in person. In fact, sort of the opposite! Cheers, John @ RBW HQ On Oct 5, 3:26 pm, Joe Bernard wrote: > That's good advice, Kelly, but if Peter is anyt

[RBW] Re: So Torn, Cannot Decide

2011-10-06 Thread Mike
Hey Peter, folks have shared a lot of great insight and experience on this thread. I'll just be redundant and say, call up the folks at Riv, talk to them and trust them. I own two Rivs, a Quickbeam I picked up used and a Hilsen I've had for 3 years. I used to have a Rambouillet but just didn't need

[RBW] Re: So Torn, Cannot Decide

2011-10-05 Thread charlie
Get the 54cm Hunk.it has thicker tubing and can fender the largest tires. You'll have no problem getting the Albatross bar high enough on that size frame, at your height, with those bars. If you are traditional minded, want more of a road machine, get the Atlantis especially if you don't mind r

[RBW] Re: So Torn, Cannot Decide

2011-10-05 Thread Joe Bernard
I didn't mean to imply that Rivendell pressures..they most certainly do not. I simply meant that talking directly on the phone is a step closer (in my mind) to making a decision. But I hate talking on the phone, so that highly subjective view may be mine alone. -- You received this message bec

[RBW] Re: So Torn, Cannot Decide

2011-10-05 Thread Kelly Sleeper
My statement was based on experience with Rivendell. From suggestions on build to fit to final product. There has never been pressure to buy or make a decision today. I trust Rivendell more so than forum. Not to mention this as other forums is all over the map on every subject from tire widt

[RBW] Re: So Torn, Cannot Decide

2011-10-05 Thread Kelly Sleeper
My statement was based on experience with Rivendell. From suggestions on build to fit to final product. There has never been pressure to buy or make a decision today. I trust Rivendell more so than forum. Not to mention this as other forums is all over the map on every subject from tire widt

[RBW] Re: So Torn, Cannot Decide

2011-10-05 Thread Joe Bernard
That's good advice, Kelly, but if Peter is anything like me, he'd rather get some "outside" impressions on a forum before getting into a direct phone call. There's a certain "pressure" that comes with taking that next step which some of us find a little intimidating. Or maybe it's just me.. --

[RBW] Re: So Torn, Cannot Decide

2011-10-05 Thread Kelly Sleeper
It's all great discussion.. Call Rivendell for fit and talk about the bike and needs with them. It works very well that way. Just saying. :) Kelly -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "RBW Owners Bunch" group. To view this discussion on the web visit

[RBW] Re: So Torn, Cannot Decide

2011-10-05 Thread Joe Bernard
Yeah, I wouldn't be too concerned about headtube height on a Hunqapillar. It's designed with Grant's newfound interest in steeply sloped-up toptubes. The Atlantis has a more traditional design, with a tall headtube. -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "R

[RBW] Re: So Torn, Cannot Decide

2011-10-05 Thread Thomas Lynn Skean
On Wednesday, October 5, 2011 9:07:31 AM UTC-5, Peter M wrote: All great advice guys, I was leaning towards the Hunq for a while because it doese look beautiful but from the pics the headtube looks really small on the 54 (the one I would fit on) so I was worried it would be flexy in the cock

[RBW] Re: So Torn, Cannot Decide

2011-10-05 Thread Jay
The last RR had a page with pictures and profiles of all the current models. Probably doesn't add any new information but it might be helpful to look at. Jay On Oct 5, 6:40 am, René Sterental wrote: > Forth utmost versatility, today I'd tell you to go for the Hinqapillar. You > cannot go wrong w

[RBW] Re: So Torn, Cannot Decide

2011-10-05 Thread Peter M
All great advice guys, I was leaning towards the Hunq for a while because it doese look beautiful but from the pics the headtube looks really small on the 54 (the one I would fit on) so I was worried it would be flexy in the cockpit area if I had too much stem exposed, even if it is a nitto stem a

[RBW] Re: So Torn, Cannot Decide

2011-10-05 Thread William
The Atlantis has those dreamy chainstays, too. -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "RBW Owners Bunch" group. To view this discussion on the web visit https://groups.google.com/d/msg/rbw-owners-bunch/-/UOdSHmxpXb4J. To post to this group, send email to

[RBW] Re: So Torn, Cannot Decide

2011-10-05 Thread Liesl
 I ride  35's (actual) when I will be on dirt > roads most of the time and really like the combination of comfort, grip, and >  responsiveness.  I don't think you necessarily need anything bigger than > that, but there are times, like winter, when having the ability to put a big > studded tire on

RE: [RBW] Re: So Torn, Cannot Decide

2011-10-05 Thread Larry Powers
o: rbw-owners-bunch@googlegroups.com > Subject: Re: [RBW] Re: So Torn, Cannot Decide > > Recheck size though. My wife is 5' 10" and has a 61 Atlantis.. Rides great > ..looks great...but then they all do. > > Kelly > > -- > You received this message because you

[RBW] Re: So Torn, Cannot Decide

2011-10-05 Thread Minh
I think that these two models 'ride' similiar enough that you can make the decision based on the details. * Atlantis has nicer paint, fancier lugs * Atlantis is US built (unless you need the larger size Hillborne) * Atlantis will take a bigger tire (fendered or unfendered) * side-pulls vs cantis *

[RBW] Re: So Torn, Cannot Decide

2011-10-05 Thread Garth
Peter, Getting a wider tired bike is never overkill! Like others have said do consider the Hunqapillar. Personally, though I have a Bombadil only. ... I would only consider a Hunq because the ability to ride higher bars than the Atlantis, and the extra tube does add stiffness to the front

[RBW] Re: So Torn, Cannot Decide

2011-10-05 Thread Ginz
The max tire on the Hillborne with fenders, 38-40mm, would not satisfy me on a gravel road. I would go Atlantis for that reason. But, I like my big tires -- 26 x 1.75" minimum! If you were going after the sidepull/centerpull Hillborne, that might make the decision more difficult. But, I don't s

[RBW] Re: So Torn, Cannot Decide

2011-10-05 Thread Michael Hechmer
Peter, I live in a town in VT with virtually no paved roads so a lot of my riding is on dirt roads and nearly all of them, at the least, begin and end with a couple of miles of dirt roads. Tire size capacity is certainly a big variable in choosing a frame. I ride 35's (actual) when I will be

[RBW] Re: So Torn, Cannot Decide

2011-10-05 Thread Forrest
dougP wrote: "I'm 5'11" with a PBH of 85 cm, and a seat height of 77 cm, and ride a 58 cm Atlantis . . ." Same for me, Peter. If you have the budget, I'd go Atlantis, just for larger tire options/versatility -- and because you might regret it if you don't get it when you have the chance. T

Re: [RBW] Re: So Torn, Cannot Decide

2011-10-04 Thread Kelly Sleeper
Recheck size though. My wife is 5' 10" and has a 61 Atlantis.. Rides great ..looks great...but then they all do. Kelly -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "RBW Owners Bunch" group. To view this discussion on the web visit https://groups.google.com/d/

Re: [RBW] Re: So Torn, Cannot Decide

2011-10-04 Thread Tim McNamara
Make it simple. I'd say make the choice based on tires. What are the widest tires you are likely to use? If it's 2" tires, go with an Atlantis or a Hunq. If it's 45 mm you can go with any of them except maybe the Hunq. Then consider purpose. If you're going to load up and go on tour, probab

Re: [RBW] Re: So Torn, Cannot Decide

2011-10-04 Thread René Sterental
Forth utmost versatility, today I'd tell you to go for the Hinqapillar. You cannot go wrong with the Atlantis either, but for higher bars, greater loads and do it all, I just love my Hunqapillar a tiny bit more than I love my Atlantis... Especially with Bullmoose bars... I'm 5'11" and ride a 61 At

[RBW] Re: So Torn, Cannot Decide

2011-10-04 Thread dougP
Peter: That's a pleasant problem to have: which Rivendell? I'll encourage the Atlantis idea, since I have over 8 years & well over 30,000 miles experience with mine. I'm 5'11" with a PBH of 85 cm, and a seat height of 77 cm, and ride a 58 cm Atlantis with 10 cm stem. It's the most comfortable

[RBW] Re: So Torn, Cannot Decide

2011-10-04 Thread Joe Bernard
Leslie makes some excellent points. You also may want to talk to Grant/Mark/John, et al, about weight limits for each bike. I know the Atlantis is built a little stouter than the Sam, but I doubt you exceed the limits of either. Other than that and Leslie's advice about tire preference, I say,

[RBW] Re: So Torn, Cannot Decide

2011-10-04 Thread Leslie
Okay, thinkin' a little more, scratch the Bombadil off your list if you're wanting to stick w/ 700c wheels, as it'd be getting a bit tall. But for your PBH, the others would work. I suppose, maybe the quote off the bottom of the models page might summarize it: "*All of our bikes ride the sam

[RBW] Re: So Torn, Cannot Decide

2011-10-04 Thread Leslie
A) Cyclofiend's site makes a great backup when looking for sizes, etc.: http://www.cyclofiend.com/rbw/atlantis/index.html B) The Hunq is a Riv, you'll be able to get the bars high w/ an Albatross, too, I'd expect; no worries there, I don't think. C) You can't go wrong w/ an Atlantis. D) Eith