I Finally got time to make the image files of the exemples I gave. there they go. I think these cover the most situations of dynamics together with cross-staff knee beam. The webern exemple, the only I didn't talk about, is from the second piece of variations op. 27.
I believe it's clear that the clash should be avoided anyway. 2011/12/11 m...@apollinemike.com <m...@apollinemike.com> > Le Dec 10, 2011 à 12:12 AM, Xavier Scheuer a écrit : > > > On 9 December 2011 23:40, m...@apollinemike.com <m...@apollinemike.com> > wrote: > >> > >> Thanks for bringing this to my attention. > >> This is one of those situations that falls into the "uncertain > >> desired output" category. > >> Shifting the dynamic to the left or right dissociates it from the > >> note, and whiting it out covers up a good portion of the stem. > > > > Mmh, this is the same "uncertain desired output" that is preventing an > > automated solution in the case of DynamicText colliding with SpanBar? > > > > > >> It'd be not-very-hard to drum up an automated solution, but what > >> we're really missing are examples from the literature. If you have > >> time to peruse scores from reputable editors and send us examples, > >> we can work from that. > > > > Maybe if there is no "standard best solution", LilyPond could at least > > emit a Warning: collision when it occurs, isn't it? > > I submitted a patch that does some collision avoidance in these cases - > I'll keep you posted. > > Cheers, > MS
<<attachment: berio-01.png>>
<<attachment: berio-02.png>>
<<attachment: stockhausen-01.png>>
<<attachment: stockhausen-02.png>>
<<attachment: webern-01.png>>
_______________________________________________ lilypond-user mailing list lilypond-user@gnu.org https://lists.gnu.org/mailman/listinfo/lilypond-user
