Jan Coffey wrote:

 
> > > Then move back to India, or act like a guest while you are here. 
> You 
> > > don't get to come here and have citizenship and still be loyal to 
> > > India. Well, actually, you do, but that doesn't make it right.
> > 
> > I live in India. I was born here and have lived here ever since. 
> > I am curious - what made you assume otherwise?
> 
> 
> Quite honestly, you talke as if you are here, and have a right to 
> have an opinion about ~parts~ of this topic I feel now that you do 
> not. 

I talk as if I am there in the US? What does that mean?
And do you accept a similar restriction on your opinions - that is, you
do not have the right to hold one on India or Indians since you don't
live here? Can't say I have noticed that in this thread.

> > Do we have problems? Sure. But we are still the same people we were 
> 4-5
> > years ago...
> 
> 4 or 5 years ago it was your problem not ours. Now it is our problem 
> too.

Why? I thought you told Jon:

"I'm sorry, but someone from, somewhere else really doesn't have a 
right to comment on how we should act, if they want to be a citizen 
of this country, and pledge aligence to it, then they are welcome, 
but until then, their opinion is not worth squat on that topic...."

Mind you, I find the idea of limiting one's knowledge and opinions to a
particular geographical region rather silly but I thought you might want
to be consistent in your beliefs... :)

Ritu


_______________________________________________
http://www.mccmedia.com/mailman/listinfo/brin-l

Reply via email to