On Fri, 24 Oct 2008, Ed Murphy wrote: > Logical: "This statement is true." On the basis of logic alone, > either TRUE or FALSE is self-consistent. > > Legal: "Goethe was a player at <appropriate time c. December > 2006>". According to one legal interpretation, TRUE is consistent > and FALSE is not; according to another, FALSE is consistent and > TRUE is not.
The legal example depends on what theory of gamestate you subscribe to. One could equally say that there's two gamestates, and each gamestate has a different self-consistent answer. [If you don't like "gamestate" as it implies multiple universes, substitute "set of axioms"]. -Goethe
