RE: COLO space in EU

2024-12-11 Thread Tony Wicks
20kW is not an insignificant power requirement, I’m not surprised your requirement is pricy. From: NANOG On Behalf Of harbor235 Sent: Thursday, 12 December 2024 7:46 am To: NANOG list Subject: COLO space in EU Hi all, Looking for colo space in Amsterdam, is it common to have to

COLO space in EU

2024-12-11 Thread harbor235
Hi all, Looking for colo space in Amsterdam, is it common to have to pay for phase3 power busbar and busbar, power supply, and tap off? Total costs for adding 3 phase plus testing etc . 136.000 Euros for NRCs and the following MRC: The Service Fee for a 20kW deployment would be €350/kW/month

Re: COLO space in EU

2024-12-11 Thread Aaron Wendel
So they have a charge just to have the capacity present of 7000 euros/month and then .278 euros per KWh on top of that? I wish I could get away with charging that. Aaron -- Original Message -- From "harbor235" To "NANOG list" Date 12/11/2024 12:45:52 PM Subject COLO space in EU

Need Centurylink contact for serious ongoing issue

2024-12-11 Thread John Neiberger
I apologize for using NANOG for this, but I need to get some traction on a telephone outage affecting a large number of homes in a small town that Centurylink seems to be unaware of. The affected customers have had no phone service for days and none of them know what's going on. Centurylink custome

Re: COLO space in EU

2024-12-11 Thread nanog
Is there a reason why AMS (presumably the IXs)? You may find other NL DCs cheaper but still close enough to AMS for your needs. For example, in Rotterdam there has been more investment in the port's industrial grid infra, which may get you a cheaper rate for power. In any case, the rate you hav

Re: Re[2]: COLO space in EU

2024-12-11 Thread Riley O via NANOG
Where are you seeing that kind of pricing? The utility cost would have to be sub $0.15/kWh to even pay the bill with 20kW, ignoring any cooling. Thanks, Riley C. O'Connor m...@m32.io // m32.io [Tel&Signal] 307.438.9253  [Social]     LinkedIn | Twitter | GitHub [PGP]        E017 B967 AC29

Re: Route optimization using GPUs?

2024-12-11 Thread Tom Beecher
> > Sure, alright but given what you just said doesn’t it seem odd that there > is still a static BGP tiebreaker in 2024? No. Also not sure what your point is here. On Wed, Dec 11, 2024 at 8:55 AM Drew Weaver wrote: > Sure, alright but given what you just said doesn’t it seem odd that there

Re[4]: COLO space in EU

2024-12-11 Thread Aaron Wendel
I don't understand how people stay in business paying $0.15/kWh. That's crazy. -- Original Message -- From "Riley O" To "Aaron Wendel" Cc "Tony Wicks" ; "NANOG list" Date 12/11/2024 3:22:27 PM Subject Re: Re[2]: COLO space in EU Where are you seeing that kind of pricing? The uti

Re[2]: COLO space in EU

2024-12-11 Thread Aaron Wendel
Considering a full cabinet with 20kW in the US costs under $2k total I would say so. Aaron -- Original Message -- From "Tony Wicks" To "'Aaron Wendel'" Cc "'harbor235'" ; "'NANOG list'" Date 12/11/2024 1:08:37 PM Subject RE: COLO space in EU Yea, looks like whoever did that quot

RE: COLO space in EU

2024-12-11 Thread Tony Wicks
Yea, looks like whoever did that quote does not really want the business and is pricing it as such From: NANOG On Behalf Of Aaron Wendel Sent: Thursday, 12 December 2024 8:05 am To: harbor235 ; NANOG list Subject: Re: COLO space in EU So they have a charge just to have the capacity prese

RE: Route optimization using GPUs?

2024-12-11 Thread Drew Weaver
Sure, alright but given what you just said doesn’t it seem odd that there is still a static BGP tiebreaker in 2024? From: Tom Beecher Sent: Thursday, December 5, 2024 12:12 PM To: Jason Bothe Cc: Drew Weaver ; nanog@nanog.org Subject: Re: Route optimization using GPUs? It's not even that. GPU

RE: Route optimization using GPUs?

2024-12-11 Thread Drew Weaver
Yes, it really doesn’t have anything to do with one ASN’s particular outbound routing policy. It only matters if that routing policy gets outside of that one ASN. From: Mike Hammett Sent: Thursday, December 5, 2024 2:19 PM To: Jason Bothe Cc: nanog@nanog.org; Drew Weaver Subject: Re: Route op

RE: Route optimization using GPUs?

2024-12-11 Thread Drew Weaver
Yeah, that is kind of why I said "Whatever Noction is doing" in the original post. I'm not really calling to resurrect Noction. I'm saying that BGP path selection could be better and it's kind of silly that it's 2024 and things are still being handled by a static tie breaker. Thanks, -Drew -

RE: Route optimization using GPUs?

2024-12-11 Thread Drew Weaver
To be fair it’s a technology and how it’s implemented does make a difference. Wouldn’t you agree? From: NANOG On Behalf Of Tom Beecher Sent: Thursday, December 5, 2024 3:40 PM To: Mike Hammett Cc: nanog@nanog.org Subject: Re: Route optimization using GPUs? I think most of the hatred towards t

RE: Route optimization using GPUs?

2024-12-11 Thread Drew Weaver
Yes, some level of shared responsibility has been present on the Internet throughout it’s entire existence. From: NANOG On Behalf Of Ryan Hamel Sent: Thursday, December 5, 2024 5:35 PM To: Warren Kumari ; Mike Hammett Cc: nanog@nanog.org Subject: Re: Route optimization using GPUs? Warren,

RE: Route optimization using GPUs?

2024-12-11 Thread Drew Weaver
All the solution I was talking about does is select the “best” path egress from a multihomed ASN. It just inserts a smaller prefix into the local routing table. If people outside of your ASN are seeing that then you’ve already lost the game. From: NANOG On Behalf Of Tom Beecher Sent: Thursday

RE: Route optimization using GPUs?

2024-12-11 Thread Drew Weaver
The ones I've used have simply injected more specific routes into my own local routing table to determine what path traffic takes to reach a specific destination. That's pretty much all it does. The same way I use communities to do this based upon geography, or 500 other things [avoiding 1299

RE: Route optimization using GPUs?

2024-12-11 Thread Drew Weaver
Anyway I just wanted to clarify that during my use of route optimization all the devices did was inject a more specific route to a prefix that my network would then use to reach that prefix. Those more specific routes weren't ever advertised to external BGP peers and if they were they shouldn't

Re: COLO space in EU

2024-12-11 Thread Riley O via NANOG
Yea, 0.15-30EUR is definitely higher than the US average, much higher than what we pay. Out here, colo spaces tend to charge ~1.5-2x the utility rate in the quote. Mainly to factor in cooling, depending on their PUE. Based on cost of power in the EU, the monthly seems fine, but the install co

Re: Need Centurylink contact for serious ongoing issue

2024-12-11 Thread John Neiberger
Yep. I finally found some contacts at Lumen who ran it up the chain. I also did report it to the Colorado PUC. I'm still confused about how so many homes and businesses could be without service and Centurylink wouldn't know about it. It's a small town, and I'm starting to think everyone thought tha