https://bugs.kde.org/show_bug.cgi?id=399375
--- Comment #33 from Martin Flöser <mgraess...@kde.org> --- (In reply to Tyson Tan from comment #32) > We did not ask you to remove Window Action Key. I was only arguing its > usefulness, and it wasn't even the point of that comment. You are focusing > on the wrong place. > > Let me rephrase what we really asked you to consider: > > 1) Change Window Action Key default to Super/Meta; >From comment 21: So why are I against just changing the default and living in the Windows future? Because it doesn't fix the problem. It doesn't make Krita work with any window manager using this shortcut. It even doesn't fix it for Plasma. It would mean two years till this gets to users (Ubuntu 20.04) and would only affect new installations. Existing users would not be migrated anyway - we never do that. And even then for any user re-enabling the feature and any distribution re-enabling the feature (especially for such hardcore X11 features that does happen) it would still be broken in Krita. > > 2) Cleanup Window Action Key settings so people can actually find it easily; There is an ongoing project to rework all of systemsettings. I'm not involved in that project. Please provide the feedback there. > > 3) Add a "None" option, so the Meta app and Alt app can co-exist under > Plasma; exists already. > > 4) Never ask the applications to change, they are following the 99%; I haven't done so. I only suggested that we work together to improve the situation. And that requires both Krita and KWin to add code. > > 5) Listen to different voices outside of your echo-chamber; says the one talking about industry standards ;-) I'm not living in an echo-chamber, I'm too smart for that. I give you one feedback to think about: one of the most often requested features in KWin is the lack of mouse actions. Especially the features Compiz supported was extremely popular and we got many complaints about us lacking it. Due to that it was one of the first new features I implemented on Wayland. In opposite this is the first time in 10 years that someone complains about the only existing mouse shortcut we have. Something to think about especially when claiming we would live in an echo chamber. Something else to think about: I no zero Krita users outside of KDE community, I know dozens of KWin users outside of KDE community and not just coders. They all know that feature... > > 6) Make it clear: who the target users are for Plasma. see: https://community.kde.org/Plasma/Workspace_Sprint/Personas though I don't know whether these personas were ever officially adopted. -- You are receiving this mail because: You are watching all bug changes.
