- we can also maybe build on the Badgr project, is that what you would say is preferable?
- so ill out it on the incubator list? What about the infra list? Should I mentioned it there? On Tue, Apr 6, 2021 at 9:29 AM Rich Bowen <rbo...@rcbowen.com> wrote: > > > On 4/6/21 11:16 AM, Matthew Sacks wrote: > > 1) if rather build my own badge software from scratch for the ASF badge > > use specifically. > > > > It is indeed a software project, and yes you’ve fully misunderstood as > > you mentioned, WADR. > > > > Whether or not infra decides to use the software will be based on the > > usefulness of the Podling PoC for the new badge technology specifically > > for ASF badges. If someone wants to fork and resubmit or take it to > > GitHub whatever that’s fine, but the original purpose is for the ASF > > badge specifically. > > > > Should I cc them or present it on their list separately? > > > > New podling, new software, yes. > > > > Does this change your -1? > > I see. Well, then, I would have to say that this is the wrong place to > have this vote, and the wrong place to have this conversation. You need > to make a proposal over on the Incubator list. Having a vote on this > here will have no consequence, and will not be binding on anything. > > That said, reinventing something just so we can have our own is not > something I'm a fan of, but if that's interesting to you, I'm certainly > not going to say no, either. > > > On Tue, Apr 6, 2021 at 8:04 AM Rich Bowen <rbo...@rcbowen.com > > <mailto:rbo...@rcbowen.com>> wrote: > > > > > > > > On 4/6/21 10:57 AM, Matthew Sacks wrote: > > > I’m not sure wtf it doing but this GT relying on the elder > > buffers and more > > > experienced guidance (specifically Mark Thomas, JimJag’s input, > Brett > > > Porter) here goes: can we vote yes or no should this be turned > into a > > > proposal of some kind, incubator or other, depending on where it > > is most > > > appropriated. > > > > > > Calling a vote yes or no to create a formal application for > > project hosting > > > in the ASF for the PoC. > > > > > > PoC success criteria TBD. > > > > > > I’ve proposed one podling before, but I’m rusty on this process. > > > > > > Ready to dedicate resources to this project. > > > > -1 - this is not podling material. Podlings are for software project > to > > be hosted at the Foundation. This is not a software project. It is > > standing up a service with an existing externally-developed software > > project - unless I am completely misunderstanding what you're trying > to > > do here. > > > > What I understood from the entire thread is that you wish to run a > > badge > > service, using Badgr (or other similar existing software project). > > > > Have I completely misunderstood your intent? > > > > If you do, in fact, intend to start a *new* software project to > develop > > a badge solution, and make that an Apache project, this is not the > > place > > to have that conversation. That would be over on the Incubator > > mailing list. > > > > -- > > Rich Bowen - rbo...@rcbowen.com <mailto:rbo...@rcbowen.com> > > @rbowen > > > > -- > > Thank you, Matthew > > -- > Rich Bowen - rbo...@rcbowen.com > @rbowen > -- Thank you, Matthew
