>On Wed, Jul 12, 2017 at 11:27 AM, Byron Jones <g...@mozilla.com> wrote: > >> But indeed having also the patches in bugzilla would be good. >>> >> no, it would be bad for patches to be duplicated into bugzilla. we're >> moving from bugzilla/mozreview to phabricator for code review, duplicating >> phabricate reviews back into the old systems seems like a step backwards >> (and i'm not even sure what the value is of doing so). > >I find this a strange argument. We don't know how successful phrabricator >is going to be. The last attempt to switch review tools seems to be >getting killed. I think its somewhat reasonable to be skeptical of further >review tool changes.
I quite agree... And I hate the idea of having the data spread across systems (which I also disliked in MozReview, which I tried and it ended up being really bad for some aspects of my ability to land patches). >Also, I have to say the whole phabricator thing has been kind of presented >as a fait accompli. As someone who continues to use splinter on a daily >basis I'm 1) skeptical and 2) kind of unhappy. > >Maybe phabricator will be great, but I'll believe it when I see it. Please >don't force future data and workflow into an as-yet unproven tool. This while sequence strikes me as "Let's launch our new boat, and oh by the way we're going to sink the old boat(s) so no one is tempted to not move to the new boat. And, BTW, we're leaving behind some important things, and we'll think about how we can deal with those sometime, maybe before we launch, maybe later, maybe never." While this may force people onto the new boat, I'm seriously unconvinced this will be better in the short term, or that it won't end up slowing down N*100 developers, either for a while or permanently. And the lack of transparency in developing this plan is also very concerning. IMO -- Randell Jesup, Mozilla Corp remove "news" for personal email _______________________________________________ dev-platform mailing list dev-platform@lists.mozilla.org https://lists.mozilla.org/listinfo/dev-platform