On Sat, May 5, 2018, 16:27 Corona <liliumalbum.ag...@gmail.com> wrote:
> Oh yeah, I didn't notice that was redundant. I'll make a revision once > everyone has had a chance to comment. > > As for (Full) Groups: Right now, (0,-1) and (0,-2), for example, form a > Group, as does any subset of the white Land Units on the "left" side of the > map. However, in Go, one considers a group of stones to include ALL stones > of the same color that are connected. > Thanks for the clarification. Terminology gripe: If in Go, "full groups" are just groups, would it not make sense to name "full groups" groups and "groups" something else? Here's some ideas: subgroup, partial group, subset, chunk, section, plot Hence the definition of Full Group. There are exactly 5 Full Groups right > now: > 1) all the black LUs > 2) all white LUs except (1,3) > 3) (1,3) > 4) the (gray) origin > 5) all the aether LUs > > I don't see how the Land Transfiguration happens at the beginning of the > second Eastman week? > I must be thinking about a previous revision of PAoaM then, since I know for a fact that's how it worked at one point in my proposal. In fact, now that I think of it, in the original rules from 2001-2004, they happened on the fifteenth day off the month. It may be nice for the sake of this proposal to reimplement that fixed point of time idea. Once during the second or third Eastman week of each Agoran Month, > the Cartographor CAN perform the following actions in sequence, > and report these changes: > > [...] > > The Cartographor SHALL do so in the second Eastman week of each Agoran > Month. > > This rule seems to plainly state that you CAN perform the actions at any > point in the second or third week, and SHALL do so at some point in the > second week, nothing more. > > ~Corona > > On Sat, May 5, 2018 at 11:37 PM, Reuben Staley <reuben.sta...@gmail.com> > wrote: > > > Comments inline > > > > On Sat, May 5, 2018, 02:09 Corona <liliumalbum.ag...@gmail.com> wrote: > > > > > Well, nobody plays Go on Arcadia, preferring ease of movement instead. > > > Boring! > > > > > > I create the proposal "go, Go!" with the following text; text enclosed > in > > > square brackets is not part of the proposal: > > > > > > [This proposal implements a 2 coin, 1 apple reward for each captured > > stone, > > > possibly livening up the board] > > > > > > Amend the rule 1998 "Land Topology" to read in full: > > > > > > Two Units of Land are Adjacent if they have the same Latitude, and > their > > > Longitudes differ by exactly one; or they have the same Longitude, and > > > their Latitudes differ by exactly one. > > > > > > Land Unit A is said to be connected to Land Unit B if it is possible to > > > reach B by moving only to adjacent Land Units of the same Land Type, > > > starting from A. > > > > > > [Here I changed color to Land Type, as color is not defined. So far, it > > > didn't break anything, as no LUs were to be changed into Aether] > > > > > > > Yay! Another thing I broke! > > > > A set Land Units is said to be a Group if all of these Land Units have > the > > > same Land Type are connected to each other and have the same Land Type. > > > > > > > Stop being redundant and repeating yourself. "Are connected to each > other" > > would suffice, no? If you want to stop keep that part anyway, please > delete > > one of them. > > > > A Group is said to be a Full Group if no set exists such that: > > > 1) Its elements are all Land Units of that Group and at least one Land > > Unit > > > not an element of that Group. > > > 2) It is a Group. > > > > > > > Can you clarify what you mean with this? I'm not sure if I understand > > fully. > > > > [Full Group = a group of stones in Go] > > > > > > Amend the rule 2022 "Land Transfiguration" so that the first item in > the > > > list reads, in full: > > > > > > 1. Every Land Unit, with a preservation switch of False that is not > > > directly connected to a unit of Aether, or is not connected by its own > > type > > > to a unit of Aether, shall be transformed to Aether. > > > > > > For every Land Unit that has its type changed to Aether by this > > procedure, > > > the player who most recently changed the Land Type of any Land Unit > such > > > that it is an element of the Full Group of the transformed Land Unit or > > > adjacent to any of the Land Units of the Full Group of the transformed > > Land > > > Unit, among the players who aren't Cartographor, receives 2 coins and 1 > > > apple. > > > > > > [Cartographor can time the transfiguration however e wants, it wouldn't > > be > > > fair for em to get a reward for capturing. Alternatively, we could make > > it > > > so that the transfiguration happens automatically and e just announces > > the > > > results] > > > > > > Actually, the way it's written, it takes place at the very beginning of > the > > second Eastman week so I can't rig it. I'm just supposed to report it. > > > > ~Corona > > > > > >
