On Wed, 25 Oct 2017 at 21:30 Nic Evans <nich...@gmail.com> wrote:

>    If Agora would own shinies, they are instead destroyed.
>
Restrict ownership to not include Agora?

General note: s/Secretary/Treasuror/

Amend 2496 'Rewards' to read, in full:
>
>    A Reward is a specified amount of shinies associated with a Reward
>    Condition. For each time a player meets a Reward Condition, e CAN
>    and MAY claim the specified award, by announcement, exactly once
>    within 24 hours of meeting the Reward Condition.
>
While we're here, can we extend this? 24 hours is unreasonable and causes
players to miss rewards from assessments?

[NOTE: I removed the Pend Reward.]
>
Thank you.

Amend 2516 to read, in full:
>
>    As part of eir monthly duties, the Secretary SHALL, for every player,
>    create in eir possession 50 shinies.
>
>    As part of eir weekly duties, the Secretary SHALL, for every player
>    that registered in the last week, create in eir possession 50
>    shinies.
>

This could result in double-payment of new players, if they register before
the monthly award. Additionally, the Treasuror can delay the award to the
end of the month and do it back-to-pack; this award is the sort of thing
that could safely happen platonically.

Amend 2445 'How to Pend a Proposal' by replacing the paragraphs
> starting with 'a)' and 'b)' with:
>
>    a) by spending 1 Pending Ticket, OR
>
How does one get a Pend Ticket?

>    b) by paying eir Action Cost in shinies. Eir Action Cost is then
>       flipped to the next highest triangular number.
>
That's too expensive. That's only 5 per month.

>
> Amend 991 'Calls for Judgement' by replacing the paragraphs starting
> with 'a)' and 'b)' with:
>
>    a) by spending 1 CFJ Ticket, OR
>
>    b) by paying eir Action Cost in shinies. Eir Action Cost is then
>       flipped to the next highest triangular number.
>
Ditto on above comments.

Overall, it seems quite weak in my opinion. It doesn't support
specialization and has costs that are too high.

Reply via email to