On Mon, 25 Aug 2008, Geoffrey Spear wrote: > I do, however, still maintain that R101(i) makes every SHALL in the > ruleset completely ineffective, including this hypothetical one.
Well we've never really settled that "Rules are an agreement issue" but I have a meta-argument for choosing it... if we accept your argument, it's not possible to play Agora, so we might as well choose the interpretation that lets us play Agora. Yes, this is a "life exists in a universe with these physical constants because these physical constants are the ones that let us ask if life exists" kind of argument. -Goethe
