You certainly are asking the correct questions if you assume that I am 
proposing a real example.

Of course it is not possible to actually perform the experiment as described.  
The thought process and experiment was mainly intended to demonstrate that 
shielding of charges might actually result in a reduction of the coulomb 
barrier in a LENR environment.  I was looking for proof that the energy needed 
to overcome the barrier could be borrowed from the system and then replenished 
after the reaction is completed.  It is evident that one can not get the energy 
needed to penetrate that barrier for free and I wanted to have a simple mind 
experiment that would demonstrate that principle.

The clue that I was not trying to explain real life processes should have been 
evident when I modified the shape of an electron to make it perform my function.

I think that this experiment clearly demonstrated that electron shielding would 
reduce the coulomb barrier significantly if a portion of the negative charge 
appears between the protons.  Also, it shows how the energy needed to achieve 
low temperature LENR can be borrowed from the ambient under some circumstances 
and that the borrowed energy can be replaced after the fusion begins.

I have found mental experiments similar to this one to be effective in showing 
possible reactions without having to actually spend an enormous amount of time 
and effort chasing the math associated with the actual process.

In the real world, I am not sure what the electrons in the vicinity of free 
protons will do.  There has been discussion of Rydberg atoms in DGT's 
documentation and earlier on vortex where the electron is assumed to come very 
close to the proton which tends to make the two appear as a neutron, thus 
avoiding the coulomb barrier.   And of course Mills has a theory that allows 
the electron to get much closer to the nucleus than normal with his f/h model.

So, if LENR is real, there must be some physics that allows it to occur at low 
temperatures.  In this exercise I am merely investigating electron shielding as 
a possibility.

Dave 


-----Original Message-----
From: Jeff Berkowitz <[email protected]>
To: vortex-l <[email protected]>
Sent: Mon, Sep 3, 2012 8:28 pm
Subject: Re: [Vo]:Fusion Demon Finds Easy Path


Aside from the issue of getting an electron be "modified" as you describe, the 
electron would tend to be taken up into the s1 orbital by one of the protons, 
forming a stable 1H atom, would it not? In other words, you're describing a 
metastable state, like the proverbial dog who starves to death because he's 
equidistant from two easily-accessible bowls of food.


Jeff
Playing physicist on the internets tonight.


On Mon, Sep 3, 2012 at 11:46 AM, David Roberson <[email protected]> wrote:

I was visualizing electron screened fusion between two protons and came up with 
an interesting thought experiment.  In an earlier post on vortex I captured a 
demon and put it to work in an effort to understand fusion from a slow point of 
view.  I was searching for an answer to some of my questions and now I find 
that the little critter might have additional information to share.
 
Lets start with a relatively large three dimensional region in space which 
contains three components along with one or maybe two demons that I will 
describe.  Two of the components are protons that are bare and far apart from 
each other.  The third component is a modified electron.  I have taken a tiny 
single point electron and flattened it into a disk with a tiny hole at the 
center.  The charge is evenly distributed around the washer shaped ring and the 
new component can be expanded at will in a radial direction as the hole within 
the center is enlarged.  The reason for the unusual electron is to keep all of 
the electrostatic forces along a single dimension.  The balanced shape 
eliminates any force out of alignment.
 
Now, we can carefully place the electron at the center of the region with its 
flat surface along the y-z plane.  The axis of the washer shape is made to be 
parallel and along the x axis.  Next, place each proton an exactly equal 
distance along the x axis from the electron with one on either side.  Since we 
start with a large region, the amount of energy required to perform the initial 
alignment is essentially nil.
 
The first demon has a femtometer and a gauge that accurately measures the 
distance between the protons as well as the force between them.  It also has 
the ability to resist movement of the protons so that the distance can be 
metered out accurately and acceleration kept to a very low value.  Knowing the 
force and distance moved allows us to calculate the work performed by the 
motion of the protons.
 
The experiment begins by noting that there is a net attraction between the 
protons due to the location and charge of the electron.  Each proton is subject 
to two electric forces in this model.  An attraction is caused by the electron 
in the center of the system and a repulsion is generated due to the opposite 
proton.  The force due to an electric charge is proportional to the inverse 
square of the distance.  The electron is always kept at a distance of exactly 
1/2 that of the opposite proton so there is a net attraction of each proton 
toward the center and thus each other.
 
We allow the protons to slowly approach the electron as energy is taken out of 
the combination and absorbed by our demon.  This process is continued right up 
until the distance between the protons reaches a point where the strong force 
balances the electric force.  Our demon has now absorbed an amount of energy 
equal to the coulomb barrier and we have not needed to supply any outside 
energy.
 
It is time to connect the second demon to the test setup.  This one has an 
accurate set of gauges just as the last, but it is attached to opposite sides 
of the electron so that it can stretch it outward evenly.  We begin to adjust 
the second demon as we also adjust the first one.  The ideal goal is to keep 
the force of attraction between the protons to be very nearly zero as the 
second demon expands the electron field.  Now, we find that it requires energy 
to expand the special electron and we keep the process moving forward until it 
is completely removed from the region.  I am confident that the net work 
performed by the second demon upon expanding the electron is equal to the 
energy of the coulomb barrier.  Perhaps someone is inclined to perform that 
calculation for verification, but COE would suggest that it is not worth the 
effort.
 
Now, if we go back to the first demon, it can slowly allow the protons to come 
together and fuse.  The force between the protons ramps up as they get closer 
and energy is continued to be imparted upon the demon.  If we wait a while, a 
beta plus decay will occur that converts one of the protons into a neutron 
while a neutrino is emitted along with a positron and energy.  This decay will 
happen because there is less mass contained within the nucleus of a deuteron 
atom than a helium 2 atom and only one of these can be stable.
 
When I realize that the above process was always energy positive until fusion 
occurs, I suspect that it would be possible at low temperatures.  The main 
question is how well can an electron or a group of them act as a real life 
shield.  What quantum mechanical processes attempt to break up the procedure?  
Perhaps the discussion of Rydberg hydrogen atoms is appropriate if in fact the 
electron can approach the proton very closely achieving more or less what my 
demons accomplish.
 
Does this type of analysis help to shed light upon the process suggested by Dr. 
Storms?  He discusses a structure that consists of alternate protons and 
electrons in a similar fashion.
 
Dave
 



 

Reply via email to