The only conflict is the mention of a period of time during which the electron is in the near position. If we assume that there is merely a probability that it is near the proton, then the shielding is not very good since that probability must be low compared to all the other possible locations. I think we need for the actual electron to be located in real time near the proton for the trick neutron to be effective. Only by actually being local to the proton will the coulomb barrier be significantly reduced.
If Heisenberg maintains that we can not observe the electron in its orbital, but that it actually does follow some path in time then we are good. It has always been my understanding that one can not define the electron orbit in time with QM. Am I wrong here? Dave -----Original Message----- From: ChemE Stewart <[email protected]> To: vortex-l <[email protected]> Sent: Sun, Sep 2, 2012 9:54 pm Subject: Re: [Vo]:RSH in Electric Fields In chemistry, Schrödinger, Pauling, Mulliken and others noted that the consequence of Heisenberg's relation was that the electron, as a wave packet, could not be considered to have an exact location in its orbital. Max Born suggested that the electron's position needed to be described by a probability distribution which was connected with finding the electron at some point in the wave-function which described its associated wave packet. The new quantum mechanics did not give exact results, but only the probabilities for the occurrence of a variety of possible such results. Heisenberg held that the path of a moving particle has no meaning if we cannot observe it, as we cannot with electrons in an atom. Terry is just saying the probability that the electron will be closer to the neucleus is higher. I do not see a conflict On Sunday, September 2, 2012, David Roberson wrote: Not a problem. If a classical orbit is true for any length of time, quantum mechanics has some explaining to do. Again, is this evidence for a hole in that theory? Dave -----Original Message----- From: Terry Blanton <[email protected]> To: vortex-l <[email protected]> Sent: Sun, Sep 2, 2012 9:44 pm Subject: Re: [Vo]:RSH in Electric Fields On Sun, Sep 2, 2012 at 9:24 PM, Terry Blanton <[email protected]> wrote: > Granted that the Bohr model is simplistic; but, for a few hundreths of > a nanosecond, the Rydberg atom of hydrogen is essentially a neutron. I think my time scale is off. We might be looking at hundreds of femtoseconds. In the words of my granddaughter, "Whatever." (word) T

