On Sun, Sep 2, 2012 at 10:01 PM, David Roberson <[email protected]> wrote:

 It would be ideal if the pseudo neutron can be formed which would then
> penetrate the nucleus but I am afraid that the energy equations would not
> balance.  If there are two different paths to the same ultimate result,
> they should release the same net energy.
>

This is a good question.  I think you're saying that there are two ways to
get to proton capture in a nickel atom, for example, A and B.  Normally
Coulomb repulsion makes this difficult, perhaps on the order of keV (path
A).  I've been saying there's a path B in which it might not be all that
difficult because of shielding.  Where does the energy go that was needed
before and is not needed now -- I'm not sure.  I don't really know how to
balance the books in this instance.  Maybe the Rydberg state needed to
provide the kind of shielding implicit in the discussion up to now would go
well beyond the ionization potential of hydrogen, in which case you'd no
longer have a Rydberg atom.

Eric

Reply via email to