On Sun, Sep 2, 2012 at 10:01 PM, David Roberson <[email protected]> wrote:

 It would be ideal if the pseudo neutron can be formed which would then
> penetrate the nucleus but I am afraid that the energy equations would not
> balance.  If there are two different paths to the same ultimate result,
> they should release the same net energy.
>
> What would be the proposed reactions so that we can look at these?
>

I just did a few calculations, and there are some promising reactions that
would take place if we were able to shield the proton and significantly
reduce the potential barrier to proton capture in nickel.

Apart from the Coulomb repulsion to be overcome, I think the important
thing here would be to have an exothermic mass balance at the end. I did a
little bit of rooting around, and it seems there are such reactions, even
with nickel, which is generally very stable.  I consulted the paper by
Hadjichristos et al. [1], and they mention seeing evidence of
transmutations to the following elements in their nickel gas phase system:
 Cu, Zn, Co, Fe, K, Ca, Li, Be and B.  The masses of some of these elements
are in the vicinity of nickel, and it's possible to get to a stable isotope
by way of a straightforward reaction.  The masses of some of the elements
are far smaller, and the pathway from nickel may either be by fission or
unlikely.

Here are some straightforward reactions:

Cu
  58Ni + p -> 59Cu + 2.9 MeV (beta+ decay to 59Co)
  60Ni + p -> 61Cu + 4.3 MeV
  62Ni + p -> 63Cu + 5.6 MeV
  64Ni + p -> 65Cu + 6.9 MeV

Zn
  58Ni + alpha -> 62Zn + 3.396 MeV
  58Ni + 6Li -> 62Zn + D + 1.895 MeV

Co
  See beta+ decay, above.

Fe
  59Ni + p -> 56Fe + 3.8 MeV (59Ni is has a half-life of 76,000 years and
exists only in trace amounts)

The Fe reaction above requires a trace isotope of nickel, and I was not
able to find a path to a stable isotope of iron from a stable isotope of
nickel.  This further calls into question iron being a significant product
of any purported reaction with nickel, although, obviously, the iron must
be coming from somewhere; contamination is a possibility, of course.

The elements Ca, Li and Be in the list above might result from fission, or
alternatively, by being built up somehow.  With regard to fission from
nickel, I have little sense of whether this would be possible.  EXFOR does
provide reactions from nickel to these elements, but it does not mention
the other end products, so I wasn't able to calculate a mass balance. In
these instances I've just listed the reaction as it appears in EXFOR.

Ca
  28-NI-58(P,X)20-CA-42

Li
  28-NI-64(P,X)3-LI-7

Be
  28-NI-60(P,X)4-BE-7
  28-NI-64(P,X)4-BE-7

EXFOR does not provide information on any kind of reaction from nickel to
stable isotopes of boron or potassium, the last two elements in the list
from the Hadjichristos paper.  So perhaps these elements would need to come
about via other pathways.

Since the new isotopes that are seen in previous cold fusion experiments
are generally stable, my method here has been to omit reactions that
proceed from very short-lived isotopes of nickel or that result in
short-lived isotopes, so a number of reactions have not been considered.
 In addition, there were many reactions in which neutrons are a product,
but I have not considered these since neutrons are not detected.  There is
a table at the end of a note by Jacques Dufour [2] which leads me to think
that in the case of nickel proton capture reactions there would be no
radioisotopes lying around after the reaction to give off gammas; please
vet this conclusion, though.

The alpha decay reactions that I looked at for nickel proton capture were
not energetically favorable.  This could potentially explain why helium has
not yet been detected in nickel gas phase systems.  More generally, this
exercise was very interesting to do; I suspect that people's expectations
that Coulomb repulsion rules out any kind of proton capture in the systems
we're looking at has left us with a lack of knowledge of what would happen
under the influence of a large flux of (shielded) protons.  A Monte Carlo
simulation could be very fruitful here.

Note that the lack of correlation between heat and transmutation products
is a tentative finding of prior research on palladium systems,
specifically.  I don't think there's been enough study of the Ni-H systems
to draw a similar conclusion.  More generally, I wonder how solid the lack
of correlation in the palladium case is in this instance; it may be fairly
difficult to do this calculation in an experimental setting.  I would not
be surprised if the helium in palladium systems comes from alpha decay, for
example.

Eric

[1]
http://newenergytimes.com/v2/conferences/2012/ICCF17/ICCF-17-Hadjichristos-Technical-Characteristics-Paper.pdf
[2]
http://newenergytimes.com/v2/library/2010/2010Dufour-NuclearSignatures.pdf

p.s. I'm not specifically /trying/ to quote sources from NET.

Reply via email to