Can quantum entanglement be used for syncronizing?
2011/4/24 Mauro Lacy <[email protected]>:
> On 04/23/2011 10:12 PM, [email protected] wrote:
>
> On 4/24/2011 6:13 AM, Mauro Lacy wrote:
>
>
> On 04/23/2011 06:57 PM, Stephen A. Lawrence wrote:
>
>
> Perhaps you have overlooked a key point. How do you propose to
> synchronize clocks which are spatially separated? That's not a trivial
> question.
>
>
> Indeed, as Stephen rightly points out, that is the very key to the problem!
>
>
> ? You can synchronize them together, and separate them afterwards?
>
>
> This is generally called synchronization by "slow transport" of clocks
> (try a search on it) ... and to illustrate the problem I might take one
> of your other comments out of context:
>
> On 4/24/2011 6:23 AM, Mauro Lacy wrote:
>
>
> ... there are no relative velocities of the two clocks involved.
>
>
> Here is the exact problem - in order to separate the clocks there *must
> be* some relative velocity involved. And if you integrate the effect of
> this relative velocity according to either SR or LET (no matter how
> *slowly* the clocks are separated), then the accumulated time difference
> is exactly the right amount to ensure that no difference in light
> velocity can be measured.
>
> Very accurate experiments of this type have already been done and
> reported extensively in the scientific literature. One fellow that
> reported such an experiment this was a guy call Clifford Will and the
> method they used (if I remember rightly) was to have two atomic clocks
> separated by some kilometers but joined by an optical fiber so that
> their ticking can be compared. And then wait for the earth to slowly
> turn so that the aether through which the earth is speeding at one time
> aids the light traveling between the clocks and at another time retards
> it. Then by looking for varying phase between the ticking of the two
> clocks, the effect of the aether aiding and retarding can be measured
> very accurately. Since you now know the effect of "slow clock
> transport" you can guess what their result was!
>
>
> Now, that's what I'll call a good answer, plus references. Thank you.
>
> And I suppose that the Sagnac effect, being on a closed path, is only
> affected by rotations, right?
>
> Your answer has a certain beauty. It lies in that it shows that
> we cannot avoid or escape the relativities of the physical world by physical
> means.
>
> I'm sure you see what's hapenning, don't you? If we could transport a clock
> without losing synchronization, or if we could
> perfectly synchronize a clock remotely, or, even better, if we had something
> like an absolute clock(the non-local clock, I would call it),
> we would be able to measure absolute motion.
> Absolute motion is happening. It's only that we cannot measure it.
>