On 04/23/2011 06:13 PM, Mauro Lacy wrote: > On 04/23/2011 06:57 PM, Stephen A. Lawrence wrote: >> Perhaps you have overlooked a key point. How do you propose to >> synchronize clocks which are spatially separated? That's not a trivial >> question. >> > > ? You can synchronize them together, and separate them afterwards?
And how do you separate them? Please be specific. Motion affects clocks. > >> On 04/23/2011 04:35 PM, Mauro Lacy wrote: >> >>> On 04/23/2011 05:05 PM, Stephen A. Lawrence wrote: >>> >>> >> According to LET (or SR) (or any experiment carried out to date) you >> will not detect a transit time difference as a result of sending a beam >> of light in one direction or another. >> > > But that contradicts the Sagnac effect. No, it doesn't. The Sagnac effect takes place in an accelerated (rotating) frame. As far as I can tell from your messages you're talking only about inertial frames, and in an inertial frame transit time doesn't depend on which direction you're going. Furthermore, an observer on the disk in the Sagnac experiment would also measure an isotropic value for C; it's only when you go all the way around a closed path in a rotating frame that things get weird. >> None the less, in both theories, the speed of light in vacuum is >> constant and independent of the emitter's motion. >> > > But the transit times cannot be independent of the *receiver*'s > motion, Stephen. You should read about the Sagnac effect, You mean, like here? http://www.physicsinsights.org/sagnac_1.html Or like here? http://www.physicsinsights.org/classical_1_note.html

