On 04/23/2011 06:57 PM, Stephen A. Lawrence wrote:
Perhaps you have overlooked a key point.  How do you propose to
synchronize clocks which are spatially separated?  That's not a trivial
question.

? You can synchronize them together, and separate them afterwards?


On 04/23/2011 04:35 PM, Mauro Lacy wrote:
On 04/23/2011 05:05 PM, Stephen A. Lawrence wrote:

What you may not be aware of is that the final (most mature?) version of
Lorentz's aether theory included physical contraction of objects which
were in motion relative to the aether along the line of motion, and
included a time dilation effect on objects which were in motion relative
to the aether.  The result was a set of transformation equations which
were, in fact, identical to the ones used by Einstein (the "Lorentz"
transforms, please note, not the "Einstein" transforms).  Consequently,
in the final version of LET ("Lorentz Ether Theory"), motion relative to
the aether is *not* detectable, despite the fact that the aether is not
being "dragged" by bodies moving through it.  (Aether drag always seemed
to me to be a rather dicey way to explain anything, for a number of
reasons.)

I couldn't care less, Stephen.
Then you apparently missed the point, and apparently don't understand
either SR or LET.

I'm not talking about any of them, but about an experiment I devised to detect absolute motion.

In the proposed experiment, we have two synchronized clocks, and a ray
of light. I don't need to *calculate* anything using Lorentz or
Einstein transforms.
The *calculation* is what leads to the theory's prediction, of course,
and if you want to know what result is predicted, you *do* need to
calculate something.  The *measurement* is what either confirms or
refutes the prediction.

The measurement actually says that a time difference is detected.


Well, according to the experiment I'm proposing, movement relative to
the ether must be detected, or the velocity of light cannot be thought
of as constant, or the ether is entrained by physical objects.
Wrong; the experiment does not lead inevitably to such a conclusion.
According to your *assumptions* one of those must be true.  The
experimental result is not bound by your assumptions.  And in fact both
SR and LET provide models in which the experiment produces a null result
*and* both of your alternative conclusions are false.



Again, and first and foremost: what's the expected outcome of the
experiment I'm proposing?
According to LET (or SR) (or any experiment carried out to date) you
will not detect a transit time difference as a result of sending a beam
of light in one direction or another.

But that contradicts the Sagnac effect.
None the less, in both theories, the speed of light in vacuum is
constant and independent of the emitter's motion.

But the transit times cannot be independent of the *receiver*'s motion, Stephen. You should read about the Sagnac effect, and afterwards, apply that to the experiment I'm proposing.

Reply via email to