On 04/23/2011 10:12 PM, [email protected] wrote:
On 4/24/2011 6:13 AM, Mauro Lacy wrote:
On 04/23/2011 06:57 PM, Stephen A. Lawrence wrote:
Perhaps you have overlooked a key point. How do you propose to
synchronize clocks which are spatially separated? That's not a trivial
question.
Indeed, as Stephen rightly points out, that is the very key to the problem!
? You can synchronize them together, and separate them afterwards?
This is generally called synchronization by "slow transport" of clocks
(try a search on it) ... and to illustrate the problem I might take one
of your other comments out of context:
On 4/24/2011 6:23 AM, Mauro Lacy wrote:
... there are no relative velocities of the two clocks involved.
Here is the exact problem - in order to separate the clocks there *must
be* some relative velocity involved. And if you integrate the effect of
this relative velocity according to either SR or LET (no matter how
*slowly* the clocks are separated), then the accumulated time difference
is exactly the right amount to ensure that no difference in light
velocity can be measured.
Very accurate experiments of this type have already been done and
reported extensively in the scientific literature. One fellow that
reported such an experiment this was a guy call Clifford Will and the
method they used (if I remember rightly) was to have two atomic clocks
separated by some kilometers but joined by an optical fiber so that
their ticking can be compared. And then wait for the earth to slowly
turn so that the aether through which the earth is speeding at one time
aids the light traveling between the clocks and at another time retards
it. Then by looking for varying phase between the ticking of the two
clocks, the effect of the aether aiding and retarding can be measured
very accurately. Since you now know the effect of "slow clock
transport" you can guess what their result was!
Now, that's what I'll call a good answer, plus references. Thank you.
And I suppose that the Sagnac effect, being on a closed path, is only
affected by rotations, right?
Your answer has a certain beauty. It lies in that it shows that
we cannot avoid or escape the relativities of the physical world by
physical means.
I'm sure you see what's hapenning, don't you? If we *could* transport a
clock without losing synchronization, or if we *could*
perfectly synchronize a clock remotely, or, even better, if we had
something like an absolute clock(the non-local clock, I would call it),
we would be able to measure absolute motion.
Absolute motion is happening. It's only that we cannot measure it.