Jones Beene wrote:

>He said the level of contamination in used moderator water is ~10^7 too high to be "cleaned up" by any method that

Is that 10^-7 ? That does not seem all that high.

No, 100 million. The letter is from Robert Machacek, Business Development Engineer, July 18, 1995. It says, in part:

"The Girdler-Sulphide process has accounted for approximately 90% of all heavy water cumulatively produced in the world. This is the method used by Ontario Hydro where more than half the world's total production has taken place. During the process of enriching the deuterium concentration of heavy water, the concentration of tritium is also enriched. At Ontario Hydro's Bruce heavy water plant, the tritium concentration is enriched by approximately three orders of magnitude. The specific activity of tritium in the final heavy water product can vary from 0.05 to 0.17 micro-Ci/kg.

Our internal specification for 'virgin' heavy water is 2 micro-Ci/kg, above which the heavy water is considered radioactive. In order to handle heavy water containing greater than 2 micro-Ci/kg, personnel must be trained and radiation protection procedures, and use appropriate protective clothing, equipment and/or procedures.

Heavy water that is used as a neutron moderator in a nuclear reactor will contain massive amounts of tritium compared to virgin heavy water. In operational Candu power reactors worldwide, the average specific activity of tritium in the moderator systems is 10^7 micro-Ci/kg, or about 100 million times greater than virgin or 'natural' heavy water. The typical specific tritium concentration in research reactors is 10^6 micro-Ci/kg. . . ."


would make the stuff suitable for laboratory use, and it would cost far more to decontaminate it than it costs to make virgin heavy water.

In Canada maybe. The lab worker there make twenty times more per hour (at least) than in Asia.

The labor cost would be a tiny fraction of the total. The equipment, power and other expenses would make it thousands or possibly millions of times more expensive per kilogram. Actually, it would be impossible with today's technology. I recall that is what Machacek told me.


In China, where many corners can be cut, in addition to low wages- the story is FAR different.

It is ridiculous to suggest they would pay $1 million per kilogram to decontaminate used heavy water when they can manufacture virgin heavy water for a ~$300/kg. Why would they do that? And if they did not de-contaminate it by a factor of at least 10 million, it would trigger radiation alarms everywhere, and kill their customers.


He wrote: "Used moderator water can often be re-sold, but only to other reactor operators. . . .

Yes. Now we are getting somewhere. It not only can be, all of IT IS BEING SOLD!

Yes, as reactor moderator water. If you sold a kilogram for use in a laboratory, you would kill everyone including the UPS driver who delivered the bottle.


Of course the Chinese are buying up all the used Candu water they can, and reprocessing it - possibly using slave labor.

All the slave labor in the world could not make the stuff useful for anything other than moderating neutrons.

The Chinese and Indians are using more modern production techniques, and producing cheaper, better quality heavy water. Mitsubishi is thinking about getting into the business. I do not know anything about the specific techniques, but I am sure that it is cheaper to concentrate heavy water by a factor of 6000 than it is reduce radioactive garbage by a factor of 100 million!

- Jed

Reply via email to