Jones Beene wrote:

The one thing you will not find in heavy water is contamination from Candu fission reactors. Contrary to Hoffman's book, they do NOT sell used moderator water!

Not directly - but it is way too valuable to dispose of. It is possible that they sell it to China or Russia in bulk for reprocessing, and that this reprocessed DDO is coming back in the form of small batches sold to chemical supply houses.

I faxed some pages from Hoffman's book to the director of heavy water production at Ontario Hydro. He was upset, to say the least. He told me the book is "pure nonsense." He said the level of contamination in used moderator water is ~10^7 too high to be "cleaned up" by any method that would make the stuff suitable for laboratory use, and it would cost far more to decontaminate it than it costs to make virgin heavy water. He wrote:

"Used moderator water can often be re-sold, but only to other reactor operators. . . . Ontario Hydro dominates the world's nuclear market for heavy water and the world's non-nuclear wholesale market, and we have never attempted to use diluted, cleaned-up old moderator water for our non-nuclear markets. . . ."

The letter points out that some of Hoffman's other speculation about heavy water is also wrong:

"Theoretically, deuterium gas produced by electrolysis has lower D/T ratio than the source D2O. However, in practice, there is no difference, as the separation factor is so small, and the operation is done in a single stage process. . . . [Hoffman's] suggestion that commercial D2 gas suppliers must start with heavy water that is higher in tritium activity than any commercially available product any is also pure nonsense. Ontario Hydro is one of the world's major deuterium gas suppliers and we provide heavy water to one of the world's other major suppliers. The heavy water starting material is our normal virgin product. . ."

I wrote about this in my review of Hoffman's book, published in Infinite Energy.

- Jed

Reply via email to