Well - you post, although true is a bit misleading in that it does not address the major problem.

Jed Rothwell wrote:

Could the instability of the effect be related to the heavy water from Aldrich?

One would not think so, since the impurity level must be miniscule.

That is not true. The impurity level in heavy water is often high, and it gets worse over time.

OK yes - it does get worse over time but that is not material to the comment of a low starting level, i.e. a low impurity level **when it comes from the supplier**. Until container is opened, if it says 99.9% DDO, then there should be NO bacteria and no significant leachants, and the stated amount of light water should be below the fractional percent.

However, my concern is the 18O content - before the bottle is even opened. If this is not specifically mentioned, then this ratio could vary - as stated in the previous posting from less than 1% to nearly 100% and yet no one would be the wiser.

This is a gigantic distinction - in that, yes - we can and should expect changes during the operation of a cell - but NO - we should not have to live with a situation of a hidden "surprise" in the 18O content.

Let me say up front now that AFAIK - Aldrich is a fine, respected supplier and probably states this detail clearly - so that it is not hidden. I should have researched that particular situation ahead of the previous posting - and let me apologize to Aldrich is they do make the oxygen isotopic content crystal clear.

Jones

Reply via email to