Steve:
Wow. This is the most thorough and well-researched issues ever.
One detail is deserving of comment.
Of particular interest to me was the report on EarthTech, the MOAC, and
specifically the input from Dennis Letts. I was not aware of the
following (wrt the Letts/Cravens effect):
"I made and tested 59 cells between August 2003 and February 2007; all
of them failed. Most were tested in MOAC, but a few were tested in my
calorimeter.
I am not sure what changed after August 2003 [the initial positive
report and hoopla]. I haven't had time for thorough testing; however, it
may be the deuterium oxide that I used from Aldrich.
The positive effect returned in March 2007 with experiment #DGL 662; the
previous cell that had worked was during ICCF10, #DGL602.
The laser effect returned with only two known differences in the
configuration: (1) I loaded cell #662 without using magnets but added
them after the cathode was loaded. (2) For the first time ever, I bought
a 500 mL bottle of deuterium oxide which had a different batch number
from all of the previous 100 mL bottles used that did not work. So maybe
impurities in, or missing from, the deuterium oxide purchased 2003-07
are important."
END of Letts quote.
Previously, we knew there were problems with the replication of the L/C
effect, but many of us had thought (hoped) that the effect was much more
robust than it turns out from this comment.
Could the instability of the effect be related to the heavy water from
Aldrich?
One would not think so, since the impurity level must be miniscule.
However. Can you smell it? There is one huge 800 pound gorilla involved
with heavy water, which has been alluded to before, but on which the
level of "official" information is surprisingly sparce.
Unless it is made clear from the manufacturer (supplier), the percentage
of the heavy isotope of oxygen: 18O is that aforementioned "large
Simian" ... and let us hope that Aldrich is not somehow involved in am
intentional deception - in that in any batch of deuterium oxide, the
heavy oxygen component can conceivably range from less than 1%
enrichment to near 100% enrichment !! Was the content known?? We can
only hope that this is not a case of "don't ask. don't tell" and that
the heavy water did not come from China.
Over a year ago, in a post here - I made the comment:
"AND there is always the further possibility that O-18 is the
under-appreciated difference [sole or contributory active isotope] in
some types of LENR work" ... since it it can be present with an
unnoticed but substantially variable ratio"
IOW... whereas some deuterium is always in light water, 'heavy water'
from a supplier may or may not be intentional depleted or
unintentionally enriched in 18O. (The depleted 18O variety can be more
costly). Therefore, the ratio (O18/O16) can be enormously variable and
is seldom mentioned. Yet how many researchers know this?
Even in light water, the percentage is wildly variable depending on the
source of water, and will increase over time if an electrolyte is being
reused (i.e. in an LENR cell which does not employ recombination such as
Mizuno's, the electrolyte is recycled over and over again).
As posted a few months ago, the heavy isotope of oxygen is far more
ubiquitous in nature than many realize. It is 15 time more prevalent in
ocean water (percentage-wise) than is deuterium, for instance! but the
interesting part is that it is enriched naturally in biological life
(osmosis in plants will enrich).
One in every 6000 molecules of sea water is HDO instead of H2O. It
is erroneous to call this molecule "heavy water" however (which
technically is a double substituion, or DDO): and DDO is essentially
nonexistent in seawater for all practical purposes.
YET - Five in every one thousand molecules of sea water (.5 %) has an
18O oxygen isotope instead of 16O. That is rather extraordinary
considering how seldom it is mentioned. Surface water has less as the
lighter isotope evaporates first and is retained in any osmotic process.
The mass difference is substantial. The water in some fruits and plant
leaves is enriched, reportedly, to a full 1 percent 18O.
If you buy "heavy water" which is sold on the basis of registering 20
amu - it is possible to be getting NO deuterium at all - and all heavy
water which comes from distillation manufacturing processes should
register 22 instead of 20 since the 18O is selected faster than the D2.
Without clarification from the supplier, a variation in ratio of nearly
100% - from near zero to full is easily possible in any experiment !!
This is because many enrichment processes, which enrich in Deuterium,
also "silently" enrich in 18O and many suppliers are buying from China
(like everything else).
In "light water" the amount of natural 18O depends on the source of the
water but it is ALWAYS much higher than the natural percentage of
deuterium. Rainwater is low in 18O for the "flip side" of the reason
that it is enriched in the oceans.
To repeat: in desalted seawater, there are 5 atoms of 18O per 1000 atoms
of 16O, which is about 15 time higher than the expected percentage of
HDO to H2O... and this is much higher than most people realize, plus -
and in addition to the starting percentage being higher in ocean water,
it is much higher yet when the water source comes from hot springs or is
extracted from vegetation. And some (but not all) of those same
distillation or enrichment processes which enrich in D are even more
effective in enriching in 18O - so it is easily possible to get 100% 18O
ahead of getting a usable percentage of D.
Jones