On Thu, 15 Aug 2019 at 19:02, Martin Koppenhoefer <dieterdre...@gmail.com> wrote:
> > > On 15. Aug 2019, at 16:59, Paul Allen <pla16...@gmail.com> wrote: > > > > A craft=painter (current meaning) is where paperwork is done and perhaps > > where equipment is stored, but it is not where the actual craft of > decorating takes place. > > a painter is somehow special in this, but not the only craft where it is > the case, many places where craftsmen have their office is also where their > workshop is, e.g. woodworkers like carpenters, window construction, stone > masons, metal workshops like iron forging or steel work, car repairs (ok > those are usually in the amenity space in OpenStreetMap), bakers, etc. and > also some other craftmen which work mostly on site Ummm, you seem to contradict yourself there. Painters/decorators work at their craft wherever their craft is needed, not in their office/storage space. Carpenters are the same. Stone masons, it depends: those repairing buildings may do preparatory work in their "office" and other work on site; stone makers who carve gravestones rarely do anything except minor repairs in a graveyard. Window construction these days is usually in a workshop rather than on site. Going in the other direction, wood turners (who use a lathe to produce bowls, vases, etc.) are craftspeople with a workshop (which may also double as storage space and as an office for paperwork). I've mapped one who had a home workshop and let people visit by appointment to see his wares and is in the process of moving to a dedicated building which will house his workshop and also be a shop for his own wares and other handicraft such as jewellery produced by others. I'll map that as a shop, and maybe fit his workshop in if there's room without a renderer collision wiping out the shop. > will have much more extensive storage requirements than painters do (e.g. > scaffolding or concrete workers/formwork). > A dedicated storage area is not a shop, or an office, or a workshop. Going by the other values, craft=* is for workshops/studios and not shops or offices. Places where the craft is actually performed, not where the results are sold, the raw materials are stored or the paperwork is done. -- Paul
_______________________________________________ Tagging mailing list Tagging@openstreetmap.org https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging
