Re: [RBW] Re: The siren song of Atlantis

2025-03-01 Thread der_amerikanische_freund
I guess if that was a final build the owner probably needed a step-through but didn't like the look of it and opted for a more standard frame and managed to make it work. Fair enough. Going back to the sizing and initial question of this thread, Will's latest newsletter included a very relevant

Re: [RBW] Re: The siren song of Atlantis

2025-02-28 Thread Mike in BK
For sure, yes. I should have emphasized that more when I wrote "Probably this was just the Riv build before the owner dialed it in.." The picture was just a perfect illustration of my point about how an undersized frame starts looking. Thanks, Eric! On Thursday, February 27, 2025 at 1:56:26 PM

Re: [RBW] Re: The siren song of Atlantis

2025-02-26 Thread der_amerikanische_freund
It seems some of us worry about how much seat post is shown. I had an email exchange with Will last week regarding this and he pointed out that the old fist-full of post thing works on level top tube bikes, but that on six degree upsloping bikes it's good to show some seat post so I wouldn't wor

Re: [RBW] Re: The siren song of Atlantis

2025-02-26 Thread Feliks Ulvåen Isaksen
Just butting in here to say that I just had a back and forth with the lads at Riv regarding sizing. I'm 195 cm with a 96 pbh and really struggled with bikes for my whole riding life. I tried to ride on a 60 Hillborne now for a while, but this did not work out at all, so I got in touch with Riv f

Re: [RBW] Re: The siren song of Atlantis

2025-02-19 Thread Tyler Ryan
Alfonso, I am tempted by the Atlantis. Luckily for my bank account I am usually able to talk myself out of buying a given Riv by the time they actually go on presale and once they're sold out it is beyond my control :). On Tuesday, February 18, 2025 at 3:35:24 PM UTC-8 der_amerikanische_freund

Re: [RBW] Re: The siren song of Atlantis

2025-02-18 Thread Doug H.
Max, That is a beauty. Well-appointed too with Chris King hubs, XT Cranks and Paul brakes. I am tempted by the upcoming Atlantis but I'm tempted by most all Rivendell frame releases. I'm just not sure how it would differ substantially from my Clem L though. Doug On Tuesday, February 18, 2025 at

Re: [RBW] Re: The siren song of Atlantis

2025-02-18 Thread reynoldslugs
I have an older one, maybe 22 years old. Cleaned it up a few years back: https://www.flickr.com/gp/41563482@N06/5C6m89G3G7 They’re great, fun, pretty, and easy to ride. Get one and you won’t be sorry. Max Beach Santa Rosa CA On Tuesday, February 18, 2025 at 3:35:24 PM UTC-8 der_amerikanische

Re: [RBW] Re: The siren song of Atlantis

2025-02-18 Thread der_amerikanische_freund
*Tyler*, thanks for your clarification. I'm with you, standover is my main concern as I plan to ride my Atlantis off road and it's very likely I will have to dismount or touch the ground occasionally so I'd like to look after my pubic bone's health! Are you planning on purchasing an Atlantis thi

Re: [RBW] Re: The siren song of Atlantis

2025-02-18 Thread Tyler Ryan
A 55cm Atlantis has a slightly longer top tube and slightly shorter standover height compared to a 57cm Hillborne. That means either would work size wise except the Atlantis is much stouter and can accommodate much larger tires, as can the Appaloosa. On Tuesday, February 18, 2025 at 11:49:09 AM

Re: [RBW] Re: The siren song of Atlantis

2025-02-18 Thread Garth
Frame specs and fitting trumps the paint color every day of the week. The paint and all the parts can be changed, but not the frame itself. Lots of people have opted to get their stock Riv repainted at the time of ordering. In regards to the Atlantis, what it originally was in 1999 is long gone,

Re: [RBW] Re: The siren song of Atlantis

2025-02-18 Thread Karl Gee
It depends I was sized at Riv HQ with a 58cm Atlantis but with 26" wheels for sturdy loaded touring. (no clue about my PBH, but 5' 10" with a 29" inseam and a long torso), Love the size, but had it been 700 wheels, I would have been put down a size. Now that I getting older, I am looking for a

Re: [RBW] Re: The siren song of Atlantis

2025-02-18 Thread Tyler Ryan
Alfonso, Yes, I am 6'1" and 89 pbh. I should have been more clear. Upon doing some more double, triple checking- I do think the 55 Atlantis would be the right call. I am mostly concerned with standover height and top tube length. Tyler On Tuesday, February 18, 2025 at 9:08:20 AM UTC-8 der_amer

Re: [RBW] Re: The siren song of Atlantis

2025-02-18 Thread Alfonso Saco Díaz
Tyler, do you mean roughly the same size as me (88 PBH and 6’1) or the original poster? Double checking the geo chart, at 88 PBH I’d be completely outside the size 59 recommended ranges (starting at 89.5cm) so I guess I should stop worrying about it. However, as investing in a Riv is not small ta

[RBW] Re: The siren song of Atlantis

2025-02-18 Thread Tyler Ryan
I'm roughly the same size and I'm looking at the geometry chart and I don't know how I could go any bigger than the 55. My current biggest bike has a 60cm top tube which is great for using swept back bars(albatross) with a "normal" length stem, 10cm. This very nearly puts drop bars out of reach