Re: Postfix "IPv6-only" - experience/recommendation question

2020-05-13 Thread Jaroslaw Rafa
Dnia 13.05.2020 o godz. 07:54:34 Tobi pisze: > My 5 cents: never rely on the reputation of a domain if you do not have > control over parent domain. So if others from eu.org zone sending spam > one should not wonder why the own subdomain of eu.org might be > listed/blocked/seen as spam. That's exa

Re: Postfix "IPv6-only" - experience/recommendation question

2020-05-13 Thread lst_hoe02
Zitat von "@lbutlr" : On 11 May 2020, at 04:24, Jaroslaw Rafa wrote: Someone told me… that Google is more likely to classify email from small senders as spam if they are sent via IPv6, and less likely if they are sent via IPv4. Short of Google publishing this information, I doubt that a

Re: Postfix "IPv6-only" - experience/recommendation question

2020-05-12 Thread Tobi
Hi Am 12.05.20 um 11:27 schrieb Jaroslaw Rafa: > If > somedomain.com sends spam, you won't automatically classify all other .com > domains as spam. So why do it for eu.org? because .com is a real TLD whereas eu.org is a pseudo TLD. You won't see user@com in mail but u...@eu.org My 5 cents: never

Re: Postfix "IPv6-only" - experience/recommendation question

2020-05-12 Thread Gerald Galster
> What is a valid rDNS? How is it set? when you open an address in your browser a (forward) dns lookup will be initiated to get the server's ip address. A reverse lookup (rDNS) is the opposite. You query an ip address and get a fully qualified domainname back. Mailservers must have a matching

Re: Postfix "IPv6-only" - experience/recommendation question

2020-05-12 Thread Ranjan Maitra
On Tue, 12 May 2020 08:14:21 -0600 "@lbutlr" wrote: > On 11 May 2020, at 04:24, Jaroslaw Rafa wrote: > > Someone told me… that Google is more likely to classify email from small > > senders as spam if they are sent via IPv6, and less likely if they are sent > > via IPv4. > > Short of Google pu

Re: Postfix "IPv6-only" - experience/recommendation question

2020-05-12 Thread @lbutlr
On 11 May 2020, at 04:24, Jaroslaw Rafa wrote: > Someone told me… that Google is more likely to classify email from small > senders as spam if they are sent via IPv6, and less likely if they are sent > via IPv4. Short of Google publishing this information, I doubt that anyone knows this, and s

Re: Postfix "IPv6-only" - experience/recommendation question

2020-05-12 Thread Jaroslaw Rafa
Dnia 11.05.2020 o godz. 15:36:47 Curtis Villamizar pisze: > > I've had no problem with google dropping my email as spam in years. > AOL and MSN (and friends, live, outlook, hotmail) sometimes, but > resolved. Helps to have rDNS on your IPv6 and SPF and DKIM signed and > all other things in place.

Re: Postfix "IPv6-only" - experience/recommendation question

2020-05-11 Thread Curtis Villamizar
In message "michae...@rocketmail.com" writes: > THANKS to a all who answered!!! > > A lot of shared experience, learned a lot, cool. It's always very > interesting how threads are meandering, somehow, adding new aspects to > unasked but also relevant questions. Crowd as it's best :-) Summarize

Re: Postfix "IPv6-only" - experience/recommendation question

2020-05-11 Thread Gregory Heytings
michae...@rocketmail.com: I've a generic question to all more experienced than me postfix users here: Is it nowadays (reasonable) possible to run postfix with IPv6 only? E.g "mail.example.com" and "smtp.example.com" with only ipv6 records in the DNS, no A / ipv4 anymore? In theory,

Re: Postfix "IPv6-only" - experience/recommendation question

2020-05-11 Thread michae...@rocketmail.com
THANKS to a all who answered!!! A lot of shared experience, learned a lot, cool. It's always very interesting how threads are meandering, somehow, adding new aspects to unasked but also relevant questions. Crowd as it's best :-) Summarized your valuable hints, I'll stay with my Postfix configur

Re: Postfix "IPv6-only" - experience/recommendation question

2020-05-11 Thread Jaroslaw Rafa
Dnia 8.05.2020 o godz. 23:26:06 Ralph Seichter pisze: > Google has so far not rejected mail sent by the dual stack servers I > maintain, no matter if IPv4 or IPv6 was used. Both DKIM and SPF are > configured on my end, which seems to be a major concern for Google, but > beyond that I have neither

Re: Postfix "IPv6-only" - experience/recommendation question

2020-05-11 Thread Jaroslaw Rafa
Dnia 8.05.2020 o godz. 14:33:16 Bill Cole pisze: > > Some have IPv6 connectivity and address space but no motivation to > make their mail systems use IPv6. There are reasons to avoid sending > over IPv6 and very few if any significant reasons to want to send or > receive over IPv6. If one has a w

Re: Postfix "IPv6-only" - experience/recommendation question

2020-05-08 Thread Allen Coates
On 08/05/2020 21:58, Wietse Venema wrote: > Bob Proulx: >> How are working and available IPv6 DNSBLs progressing? That's a >> critical component which I would love to hear is no longer a missing >> component. > > zen.spamhaus.org blocks some 15% of IPv6 spam for me. The other 85% > comes from

Re: Postfix "IPv6-only" - experience/recommendation question

2020-05-08 Thread Ralph Seichter
* Bill Cole: >> That's quite a sweeping statement, and I don't believe it to be true. > > Calling someone a liar is a very effective way to end a conversation. Don't know if Trump supporter or trolling... I am a scientist, and thus do not consider your claim to be true until you prove it. I have

Re: Postfix "IPv6-only" - experience/recommendation question

2020-05-08 Thread Bill Cole
On 8 May 2020, at 17:26, Ralph Seichter wrote: > * Bill Cole: > >> The boutique hosting/connectivity/services provider I work with [...] >> can provide native IPv6 to customers. None ever has ever asked for it. > > That's quite a sweeping statement, and I don't believe it to be true. Calling some

Re: Postfix "IPv6-only" - experience/recommendation question

2020-05-08 Thread Curtis Villamizar
In message <2eb09baa-5327-b615-47a9-0c1402385...@rocketmail.com> "michae...@rocketmail.com" writes: > > Hi all, > > I've a generic question to all more experienced than me postfix users > here: Is it nowadays (reasonable) possible to run postfix with IPv6 > only? E.g "mail.example.com" and "smtp

Re: Postfix "IPv6-only" - experience/recommendation question

2020-05-08 Thread Ralph Seichter
* Bill Cole: > The boutique hosting/connectivity/services provider I work with [...] > can provide native IPv6 to customers. None ever has ever asked for it. That's quite a sweeping statement, and I don't believe it to be true. For years I have asked every provider I have worked with if they offe

Re: Postfix "IPv6-only" - experience/recommendation question

2020-05-08 Thread Wietse Venema
Bob Proulx: > How are working and available IPv6 DNSBLs progressing? That's a > critical component which I would love to hear is no longer a missing > component. zen.spamhaus.org blocks some 15% of IPv6 spam for me. The other 85% comes from large providers (outlook.com, gmail.com, etc) that aren'

Re: Postfix "IPv6-only" - experience/recommendation question

2020-05-08 Thread Bill Cole
On 8 May 2020, at 15:06, Ralph Seichter wrote: * Bill Cole: Some have IPv6 connectivity and address space but no motivation to make their mail systems use IPv6. A case of what we call Public Servant Mikado (whoever moves first has lost). ;-) Yes. Seriously, I think that if one can suppor

Re: Postfix "IPv6-only" - experience/recommendation question

2020-05-08 Thread Bob Proulx
Bill Cole wrote: > michaelof wrote: > > I've a generic question to all more experienced than me postfix users > > here: Is it nowadays (reasonable) possible to run postfix with IPv6 > > only? E.g "mail.example.com" and "smtp.example.com" with only ipv6 > > records in the DNS, no A / ipv4 anym

Re: Postfix "IPv6-only" - experience/recommendation question

2020-05-08 Thread Viktor Dukhovni
On Fri, May 08, 2020 at 06:38:32PM +0200, michae...@rocketmail.com wrote: > I've a generic question to all more experienced than me postfix users > here: Is it nowadays (reasonable) possible to run postfix with IPv6 > only? E.g "mail.example.com" and "smtp.example.com" with only ipv6 > recor

Re: Postfix "IPv6-only" - experience/recommendation question

2020-05-08 Thread Ralph Seichter
* Bill Cole: > Some have IPv6 connectivity and address space but no motivation to > make their mail systems use IPv6. A case of what we call Public Servant Mikado (whoever moves first has lost). ;-) Seriously, I think that if one can support IPv6, one should do it. Good hosting services and ISPs

Re: Postfix "IPv6-only" - experience/recommendation question

2020-05-08 Thread Bill Cole
On 8 May 2020, at 12:38, michae...@rocketmail.com wrote: Hi all, I've a generic question to all more experienced than me postfix users here: Is it nowadays (reasonable) possible to run postfix with IPv6 only? E.g "mail.example.com" and "smtp.example.com" with only ipv6 records in the

Re: Postfix "IPv6-only" - experience/recommendation question

2020-05-08 Thread Sean Greenslade
On Fri, May 08, 2020 at 06:38:32PM +0200, michae...@rocketmail.com wrote: > Hi all, > > > I've a generic question to all more experienced than me postfix users here: > Is it nowadays (reasonable) possible to run postfix with IPv6 only? E.g > "mail.example.com" and "smtp.example.com" with only

Re: Postfix "IPv6-only" - experience/recommendation question

2020-05-08 Thread Allen Coates
On 08/05/2020 17:38, michae...@rocketmail.com wrote: > Hi all, > > > I've a generic question to all more experienced than me postfix users here: > Is it nowadays (reasonable) possible to run postfix with IPv6 only? E.g > "mail.example.com" and "smtp.example.com" with only ipv6 records i

Re: Postfix "IPv6-only" - experience/recommendation question

2020-05-08 Thread Gerald Galster
Hi, > I've a generic question to all more experienced than me postfix users here: > Is it nowadays (reasonable) possible to run postfix with IPv6 only? E.g > "mail.example.com" and "smtp.example.com" with only ipv6 records in the > DNS, no A / ipv4 anymore? I would not yet advise to run

Postfix "IPv6-only" - experience/recommendation question

2020-05-08 Thread michae...@rocketmail.com
Hi all, I've a generic question to all more experienced than me postfix users here: Is it nowadays (reasonable) possible to run postfix with IPv6 only? E.g "mail.example.com" and "smtp.example.com" with only ipv6 records in the DNS, no A / ipv4 anymore? Michael - EOM for impatien