[marxmail] Search on new site MM

2020-08-22 Thread hari kumar
Hi Les or Louis: how are search functions changed now? Thx Hari Kumar -=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=- Groups.io Links: You receive all messages sent to this group. View/Reply Online (#704): https://groups.io/g/marxmail/message/704 Mute This Topic: https://groups.io/mt/76355057/21656 -=-=- POSTING RULES

[marxmail] Yet again on the social determinants of health

2024-01-24 Thread hari kumar
https://www.theguardian.com/education/2024/jan/23/every-year-spent-in-school-or-university-improves-life-expectancy-study-says -=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=- Groups.io Links: You receive all messages sent to this group. View/Reply Online (#28618): https://groups.io/g/marxmail/message/28618 Mute This Top

Re: [marxmail] Yet again on the social determinants of health

2024-01-26 Thread hari kumar
Indeed Mark - if everyone could afford a heavily state-sponsored education at higher levels might be a good thing.. No?! I was a beneficiary of the Glory days of the so-called UK 'Welfare State' - before Mrs Thatcher killed it. The state paid me a 'full grant' including living expenses/rent... A

Re: [marxmail] Black Women in the U.S. Murdered Six Times More Often Than White Women Over Last 20 Years | Columbia University Mailman School of Public Health

2024-02-15 Thread hari kumar
I'm not quite sure what Charlie is driving at honestly. In any case two points to make. (1) Methodology: As to 'correlation proves nothing' - to some extent I agree. As I had pointed out recently to Mark B on this list, 'association is not casual'. (Jan 26 #28630) I am a great proponent of rando

[marxmail] Green areas and Health - Any linkage? (Differing strand - Was previously - Feb 13 #28882)

2024-02-15 Thread hari kumar
On the MM list - It was deemed unacceptable that 'green spaces' had any health utility and this was simply "a pathetic liberal "anti-racism." (Charlie Feb 14   #28897). While no single measure short of revolutionary change will fundamentally alter what are called the 'social determinants of hea

Re: [marxmail] Black Women in the U.S. Murdered Six Times More Often Than White Women Over Last 20 Years | Columbia University Mailman School of Public Health

2024-02-15 Thread hari kumar
Sorry - minor correction: Not sure what happened, but "cigarette something" should obviously have been 'cigarette smoking'. -=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=- Groups.io Links: You receive all messages sent to this group. View/Reply Online (#28916): https://groups.io/g/marxmail/message/28916 Mute This Topic

[marxmail] Startling (well to me anyway) thoughts from Ilan Pappe

2024-02-16 Thread hari kumar
This was in 'The Bullet, and is entitled: "It Is Dark Before the Dawn, But Israeli Settler Colonialism Is At an End", at https://socialistproject.ca/2024/02/dark-before-dawn-israeli-settler-colonialism-end/#more";. It comes from the Canadian 'Socialist Project' and was reprinted from the 'Islamic

[marxmail] Anyone looking for full texts on-line for M&E - And it seems others

2024-02-16 Thread hari kumar
After MIA was forced to drop the CW pieces it had put up, it was a little thinner on M&E. The full works were availabe in German, but they were not easily navigable. Today by chance while looking for a specific reference, I found there was another on-line source -> https://wikirouge.net/texts/en/

Re: [marxmail] With Navalny’s death, Russia’s opposition loses its last leader - CSMonitor.com

2024-02-17 Thread hari kumar
Marv: Thks for Fred Weir's report. Navalny was in the same bucket as prior supporters of Western imperialism: "For Navalny is the second wave of Western capitalists’ attempted break into Russia. Of Navalny, Khodorkovsky is on record as saying “We are allies“. [13] at "https://www.theleftberlin.co

Re: [marxmail] Anyone looking for full texts on-line for M&E - And it seems others

2024-02-17 Thread hari kumar
Charlie: I had great respect for David Romagnalo - (unsure of spelling). (Do you know if he is still alive? His old email addresses have not elicited any reply for about 10 years). In any case, the problem with the site right now as regards Marx - is that it is far from complete. It is organised

Re: [marxmail] Anyone looking for full texts on-line for M&E - And it seems others

2024-02-17 Thread hari kumar
Ah - Many thanks Jim. I did not appreciate that at all. Very helpful. H -=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=- Groups.io Links: You receive all messages sent to this group. View/Reply Online (#28969): https://groups.io/g/marxmail/message/28969 Mute This Topic: https://groups.io/mt/104406312/21656 -=-=- POSTING

Re: [marxmail] Anyone looking for full texts on-line for M&E - And it seems others

2024-02-17 Thread hari kumar
Thx David. I think David R did a great service for the movement. As did another David - a Walters by name. H -=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=- Groups.io Links: You receive all messages sent to this group. View/Reply Online (#28970): https://groups.io/g/marxmail/message/28970 Mute This Topic: https://group

Re: [marxmail] Alexi Navalny Killed in Prison - Russian Socialist Movement

2024-02-19 Thread hari kumar
One further view on Navalny's death. Not too different form what has already been expressed in some prior. Notes Navalny was a racist, and a likely pawn of Western capital - but that he had established an anti-Putin opposition (reasonably large given the circumstances) movement. His death was no

[marxmail] At what stage do United Frontists vs Trump pull the plug on Biden?

2024-02-20 Thread hari kumar
https://jacobin.com/2024/02/biden-administration-gaza-israel-war See above. Not that this is a new debate, anywhere in fact - but including this list. However the extraordinary contortions of the Biden Govt on the genocide taking place - right now - are amazing and alarming, and sad etc etc.

Re: [marxmail] At what stage do United Frontists vs Trump pull the plug on Biden?

2024-02-20 Thread hari kumar
Thx Marv. Of course you are right, I did miss that. However -does not the substantive question remain? H -=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=- Groups.io Links: You receive all messages sent to this group. View/Reply Online (#29020): https://groups.io/g/marxmail/message/29020 Mute This Topic: https://groups.io/

Re: [marxmail] At what stage do United Frontists vs Trump pull the plug on Biden?

2024-02-21 Thread hari kumar
Hello Marv: While there is truth in what you say, it is only a half -isn't it? I was "mis-educated" (!) to search for : i) The objective factor(s), and (ii) The subjective factors. (Which certainly for my part, I accept the version of Lenin as seen in a party). Surely - you would accept that both

Re: [marxmail] Harlan County, USA

2024-02-21 Thread hari kumar
As I understand it, the great Miner's Strike - is I think, a perfect example of where John Reimann is quite right in his laying huge responsibility on corrupt TU bureaucracies. The so-called Triple Alliance leaders of the Transport workers and Rail workers never came through - and left the Miner

Re: [marxmail] At what stage do United Frontists vs Trump pull the plug on Biden?

2024-02-22 Thread hari kumar
You know - depending on what day or time or whatever other condition - Louis was pretty capricious about this "banning". Even I was so ruled if I recall right. It was not exactly a mark of an 'honoured' select Club. -=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=- Groups.io Links: You receive all messages sent to this

Re: [marxmail] At what stage do United Frontists vs Trump pull the plug on Biden?

2024-02-23 Thread hari kumar
Marv wrote: "3. It's at its lowest ebb not because we don't follow the advice you and others freely dispense about how to resurrect it but because of the effects of automation, globalization, atomization, and the fragmentation of work in a service economy which has sharply reduced the size, conf

Re: [marxmail] At what stage do United Frontists vs Trump pull the plug on Biden?

2024-02-24 Thread hari kumar
Marv: Thanks for your these remarks. You rightly put the question right back - "What in your view accounts for Western capitalism’s resilience? Why hasn’t it exhausted its historic capacity for growth and produced immiseration of such depth and breadth that the masses would of necessity have to

Re: [marxmail] At what stage do United Frontists vs Trump pull the plug on Biden?

2024-02-24 Thread hari kumar
Charlie: Do you think that Marx would simply say - "Well, you'd better just read my "Volume 2 of Capital" to respond to honest different interpretations of similar data? -=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=- Groups.io Links: You receive all messages sent to this group. View/Reply Online (#29120): https://gro

[marxmail] Back to Square one, well - at least 2022: 'Negotiations' on Ukraine-Russia Talks

2024-02-29 Thread hari kumar
I thought this was an interesting reflection on 'We've been there, done that'...  but...  we'll have to do it all over again. Negotiations in 2022, sabotaged by (i) Zelensky idiocy and Ukrainian nationalist fervour (ii) Western goading (including that joke Boris Johnson). All in tune with an init

Re: [marxmail] US postwar labor strike data

2024-02-29 Thread hari kumar
Hello David: I am puzzled as to what the distinction between 'local' struggles and 'national campaign' was about. Can you help me please? And the "red union" - the RWDA - how did this start? Was it a de nouveau organisation? Was it a split from an existing bureaucratic type of TU - what was it

Re: [marxmail] Kyiv Post: Navalny died of natural causes

2024-02-29 Thread hari kumar
Marv: Maybe he was not hit on the head... (I wonder who has really seen the post-mortem data and who ultimately performed the autopsy) Yes, maybe there was a clot in the head. But - that does not come from nowhere either. He had been systematically slow-tortured for years. Cold, isolation, tiny

Re: [marxmail] Kyiv Post: Navalny died of natural causes

2024-02-29 Thread hari kumar
I think I get it - You really, really, ... I mean really... hate Marv. Evidenced by your constant Marv-bashing. Whether I am tired or not - this of course is of no concern to you, I fully get that also. But perhaps others here share my wanting discussion to move beyond your one-note positions.

Re: [marxmail] ‘They don’t represent us’: British Labor loses seat over the Gaza War

2024-03-02 Thread hari kumar
Thank you Steven. Also at the Guardian is a short clip of George Galloway's victory speech  - ('This is for Gaza' - at Rochdale (see video link at below link https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2024/mar/01/george-galloway-wins-rochdale-byelection). A wee measure of what Starmer might be up agai

Re: [marxmail] ‘They don’t represent us’: British Labor loses seat over the Gaza War

2024-03-02 Thread hari kumar
Hah! I should have waited till I had digested the Martin Rowson cartoon. I mean it is a good one. https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/picture/2024/mar/01/martin-rowson-rochdale-byelection-result-cartoon H -=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=- Groups.io Links: You receive all messages sent to this group

Re: [marxmail] ‘They don’t represent us’: British Labor loses seat over the Gaza War

2024-03-02 Thread hari kumar
Charlie - Thanks, I did not know that. The mention of 'deputy' status came up on the wiki page prior referenced. H -=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=- Groups.io Links: You receive all messages sent to this group. View/Reply Online (#29222): https://groups.io/g/marxmail/message/29222 Mute This Topic: https://

[marxmail] Biology and society and gender variation

2024-03-03 Thread hari kumar
In my reading, there were two diametrically opposed views: i) That there was no biological substratum for gender variation; ii) That there was only biological substratum for gender - that the rest was 'identity choice'. Roughly the first position has often been put by some activists. The second p

Re: [marxmail] Biology and society and gender variation

2024-03-04 Thread hari kumar
Dear David: You do make an excellent point - as (almost!) always. Or at least - if one can for now reject the term 'religious'. I do agree that sects are a major problem on the organised left-in-parties-right-now. As far as I can tell, my behaviour since I was 20 or so has not been sect-like and

[marxmail] Why did the Supreme Court - unanimously - enable Trump to stand?

2024-03-04 Thread hari kumar
Why do people here think that a unanimous vote at the Supreme Court dismissed claims that despite apparently being an 'insurrectionist' Trump is able to stand? Well they set aside completely the matter of whether or not he was so. FWIW Robert Reich's article does not help me (see below). https://

Re: [marxmail] Why did the Supreme Court - unanimously - enable Trump to stand?

2024-03-04 Thread hari kumar
Whoops - Mark B kindly advised me that the right link to the Robert Reich was here: https://robertreich.substack.com/p/the-most-troubling-aspect-of-todays?utm_source=post-email-title&publication_id=365422&post_id=142298742&utm_campaign=email-post-title&isFreemail=true&r=17xgfq&triedRedirect=true&u

[marxmail] More on George Galloway - who throws more than his hat into the ring

2024-03-04 Thread hari kumar
As noted before, he has built a base. I had quibbled about whether it was a 'mass' base or not. He may be on his way. https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2024/mar/04/george-galloway-workers-party-far-left-challenges-to-labour The huge reservoir of discontent with the Tories in the UK, coupled wi

Re: [marxmail] Biology and society and gender variation

2024-03-05 Thread hari kumar
Hello Charlie: Indeed, very difficult - should one say likely impossible (?)- questions to answer. Engels talks a little about in 'Origins of the F,PP & S". But gives no data. H -=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=- Groups.io Links: You receive all messages sent to this group. View/Reply Online (#29279): htt

Re: [marxmail] Biology and Society and gender variation

2024-03-06 Thread hari kumar
Hello Bidai: Re: "you wrote " for those who believe there was a socialist state in the ussr up until 1953" Do you mean the maoists? In 1953 Stalin died and Beria drew the short straw. Everyone else  shed some tears and went back to work. That's about it, or did I miss something?" Reply: So not

Re: [marxmail] Biology and society and gender variation

2024-03-06 Thread hari kumar
I want to thank all commentators - each had interesting points. I'll pick and choose what I reply to - for lack of being able to do justice to all. Mark: (i) Thank you. You rightly point out the birth-sec order of siblings. I had left this out - but you are right, it is an important piece in any

Re: [marxmail] Biology and society and gender variation

2024-03-06 Thread hari kumar
DA: Your comments are very kind but over-generous. Your story of a woman holding onto her self/being/self-image etc - despite ravages of dementia is very moving and tells a story. Thanks. H -=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=- Groups.io Links: You receive all messages sent to this group. View/Reply Online (

Re: [marxmail] Biology and society and gender variation

2024-03-06 Thread hari kumar
Thank you David. Not sure who might want to publish it. But I will think on't. Will need a sharp knife, ie severe pruning. Be Well, H -=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=- Groups.io Links: You receive all messages sent to this group. View/Reply Online (#29292): https://groups.io/g/marxmail/message/29292 Mute T

Re: [marxmail] Biology and society and gender variation_> LIKELY SHOULD BE re-labeled - perhaps as "Games of Khrushchev and the boys"?

2024-03-06 Thread hari kumar
Sorry Les et al: Can't quite see how to re-label this strand, but we are a long way from biology here. Duen Filan writes: "Russia's state owned assets were sold off after the USSR dissolved." Response: Well 'formally' that is correct... bringing that date up to the Gorbachov era. So if I see yo

Re: [marxmail] What Is Left?

2024-03-06 Thread hari kumar
I felt like Saman - FWIW. H -=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=- Groups.io Links: You receive all messages sent to this group. View/Reply Online (#29300): https://groups.io/g/marxmail/message/29300 Mute This Topic: https://groups.io/mt/104750353/21656 -=-=- POSTING RULES & NOTES #1 YOU MUST clip all extraneou

[marxmail] National Union Miners (NUM) - was nobbled by MI5 - it's official..

2024-03-07 Thread hari kumar
Well as if we did not know. But the detail of how the Mrs Thatcher broke the assets of the NUM was not clear at the time. Anyway, don't under-estimate the lengths that *they* will go to. https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2024/mar/07/mi5-miners-strike-national-archives-security-service-gove

Re: [marxmail] Biology and society and gender variation

2024-03-07 Thread hari kumar
Thanks Mark. This all fits truly into the pattern of the Adrenal-Hypothamalmic pituitary (brain) axis (so-called). Chronic stress - literally 'moulds' the brain. Lots of data about childhood outcomes, the nYT article highlights even longer term outcomes. Be well, H -=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=- Group

Re: [marxmail] "Games of Khrushchev and the boys"

2024-03-07 Thread hari kumar
Hi Marv. I have not yet gone over your Piketty reference, and I intend to do that, and likely at the same time - digest Chris Slee's points. It may take me some time. But it does seem to me that the sell-off of the rural Machine Tractor Stations - is a clear indicator of a major change of course,

Re: [marxmail] Biology and society and gender variation

2024-03-07 Thread hari kumar
Thanks Jay. Your comment got me to go back to a fascinating book that I oncwe devoured (and promptly forgot obviously!) - but now dip into from time to time -  S.S.Prawer's "Karl Marx & World Literature" (Oxford, 1978). Prawer there makes the same point that you made to use. Although in a more so

[marxmail] How racists twisted language of 'affirmative action; to disembowel it.

2024-03-13 Thread hari kumar
This is long, but it very articulately outlines how 'affirmative action' has been disembowelled for those whom it was originally intended for, into 'diversity'. A very good history by Nikole Hannah-Jones - who led the 1619 project. She gives an excellent short summary in the *first* link below -

Re: [marxmail] "Games of Khrushchev and the boys"

2024-03-13 Thread hari kumar
Hello Marv: I have been looking over what I believe are some of the relevant data to this discussion. I did not want any appearance left, that I am in agreement with where the discussion drifted to, after the initial comments. I have not finished, in especial I should add - I have not gone over

Re: [marxmail] Oppenheimer< victory at the Academy Awards - World Socialist Web Site

2024-03-13 Thread hari kumar
Marv: Mussolini did *not* have a militant movement to crush - the Turin workers movement was already crushed. The other two fascists are in a different category in regards to that. Of course it is more likely that a rising working class movement will induce such a right-wing fascist turn, but i

Re: [marxmail] Oppenheimer< victory at the Academy Awards - World Socialist Web Site

2024-03-14 Thread hari kumar
Good am Marv: I am not saying Mussolini was a 'good guy' - there may be a misunderstanding. I think (maybe wrong and misunderstanding you here) that you were saying fascism is brought in by the bourgeoisie at a time that its' bourgeois 'normal' channel rule of bourgeois democracy is threatened i

Re: [marxmail] Oppenheimer< victory at the Academy Awards - World Socialist Web Site

2024-03-15 Thread hari kumar
Good a.m. David: So on the (admittedly rather long) quotation from 'The Communist League' I gave to discuss with Marv my take on Italian fascism. I always will have time for Clara/Klara Zetkin - and I will look her comments out, in the text by Ridell you suggest. Thank you. I have found Zetkin's

Re: [marxmail] The economic systems of Fascism and Communism, including the present-day People's Republic of China

2024-03-17 Thread hari kumar
Forgive me, this is rather late in the strand. But for Michael M & Stephen C - you have what I feel are rather similar objections to the general discourse in this strand at the least. Michael asks: "Can you define what you mean by this question "Are workers even partially in CONTROL?" but Steven

Re: [marxmail] The economic systems of Fascism and Communism, including the present-day People's Republic of China

2024-03-17 Thread hari kumar
But isn't a refutation... is surely required with such a blunt comment? Of course the original source I think was not given by Charlie. Charlie...? Hari -=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=- Groups.io Links: You receive all messages sent to this group. View/Reply Online (#29494): https://groups.io/g/marxmail

Re: [marxmail] The economic systems of Fascism and Communism, including the present-day People's Republic of China

2024-03-17 Thread hari kumar
I mean I realise we are not in the British Houses of Parliament (thank god!), where the use of such a word leads the wielder of that tongue to be 'banished'. But even so, even amongst us Marxists - the accusation of a 'lie' is serious Vladimiro.. No? You will say I am ridiculously old-fashioned.

Re: [marxmail] Death rates in Russia

2024-03-18 Thread hari kumar
Hi Chris: Yes thank you. The serious decline in health year expectancy from the 1970s onwards through to about 2000 was indisputable and many epidemiologists noted it. I think we are completely in agreement there. Your data here indicates a decline from about 1960 which I had not been previously

Re: [marxmail] Death rates in Russia

2024-03-18 Thread hari kumar
Oh - and alcoholism. It has been a particular problem antedating the Soviet era. In the years after 1980 a biography by Tracey Kidder on Dr. Paul Farmer detailed his years working on AIDS in the former USSR. There the interrelation between alcoholism and addictions and HIV is discussed. I will h

Re: [marxmail] Claims of Mass Rape by Hamas Unravel Upon Investigation

2024-03-18 Thread hari kumar
Surely - the Israeli government are using this rape charge to justify to the external world their "mission" to kill/starve/force into dispossessed exile all Palestinians - known to the Israeli cabinet as 'animals'? And - to 'motivate' their own population with an even greater blood-lust. To poin

[marxmail] TITLE CHANGE TO TOO EARLY or not? Re: The economic systems of Fascism and Communism, including the present-day People's Republic of China

2024-03-19 Thread hari kumar
Hi Marv: So you are waiting to see if convinced Leninists of 'either tendency" will admit there was a "historically premature mistake". But - for my part I (at least I think that I did) have already had conversation with you on this list - about 1-2 months ago, where I raised that this was a p

Re: [marxmail] The economic systems of Fascism and Communism, including the present-day People's Republic of China

2024-03-20 Thread hari kumar
Thank you Steven. I had looked for that quote earlier in this strand but had failed to find it. More quotes from Lenin on 'municipalisation' against the Mensheviks and Plekhanov are also relevant, although less so. H -=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=- Groups.io Links: You receive all messages sent to this

Re: [marxmail] Title Change: Too early or not?

2024-03-20 Thread hari kumar
Good a.m. First off - I must and do apologise for any possible intemperance in my language yesterday. If there was any - it would have been to both Marv and Michael. I will confess I was irritated! But thankfully I seemed on review of my own message, to be just asking questions - albeit in an u

Re: [marxmail] The economic systems of Fascism and Communism, including the present-day People's Republic of China

2024-03-20 Thread hari kumar
And also, relevant through this whole discussion, I found a useful volume from the 1990s past lurking in my shelf. "Why Market Socialism?" Voices from Dissent. Frank Roosevelt, & David Belkin Eds.Armonk, NY; 1994. It contains very interesting essays by such as the like of Michael Harrington but

Re: [marxmail] Title Change: Too early or not?

2024-03-20 Thread hari kumar
Hi Michael: Over the years I have - but certainly not all of his oeuvre. And I need to re-read what i had done years ago in Soc One Cntry etc. In fact I am working thru' his works as I can get them, from about half way thru'. Of course they are out of print, and un-blessedly expensive now. His wo

Re: [marxmail] changed title: Too early or not?

2024-03-20 Thread hari kumar
Dear Marv: I gauged that this was the central question you wanted me to address. You will naturally, correct me - and re-direct me - if i have so mis-identified. This will of necessity be an inadequate response, but a full response with references and sub-themes, will take too long. Such a work i

Re: [marxmail] Are Hamas and Israel “Equally Reactionary”?

2024-03-22 Thread hari kumar
Hi John: 1. There are to me, some problems of your counsel that those supporting Palestine should simply keep quiet on these questions. Obviously it is the Palestinians who will at some stage pass their own judgment on the Hamas. And that will trump others. But even before the October assault ca

Re: [marxmail] changed title: Too early or not?

2024-03-22 Thread hari kumar
Hello Marv: I am not surprised at your overall response of course, and no doubt you were not by my own. I am however surprised  at this: "whatever our present differences -say, over Ukraine - if we worked at it we could hope to narrow them." So I confess I had not appreciated any such divergenc

Re: [marxmail] Peter Beinart,The Great Rupture in American Jewish Life (NY Times)

2024-03-22 Thread hari kumar
Thank you for posting this Jim. Do you - or does anyone know - What is defined as 'anti-semitic' when its use is as follows "The spike in antisemitism since Oct. 7 follows a pattern. Five years ago, a study by the political scientist Ayal Feinberg using data from 2001 and 2014 found that repor

Re: [marxmail] TITLE CHANGE TO TOO EARLY or not? Re: The economic systems of Fascism and Communism, including the present-day People's Republic of China

2024-03-22 Thread hari kumar
Hello Michael: I am sorry for having been delayed, I genuinely had some matters that needed urgently dealing with. Partly for length, and partly for time - This will be a 2 part reply to two specific issues you note (in Michael Meeropol Mar 19   #29557). This the first part, and the second par

Re: [marxmail] Peter Beinart,The Great Rupture in American Jewish Life (NY Times)

2024-03-22 Thread hari kumar
Thanks again. I see the paper is after the IHR promulgated definitions. Its' author acknowledges the bias in the data from the anti-Defamation League. But also the broader inclusion of acts, moving into expressed opinions. Likely that has escalated even more by now, as your original citation to

Re: [marxmail] TITLE CHANGE TO TOO EARLY or not? Re: The economic systems of Fascism and Communism, including the present-day People's Republic of China

2024-03-23 Thread hari kumar
You are correct: Here is a NYT free link. https://www.nytimes.com/2010/04/08/world/europe/08putin.html?ugrp=u&unlocked_article_code=1.e00.VEBV.nGg0W1E-68n4&smid=url-share But I would say what you wouls expect me to Michael: Namely that no less than Khrushchev, Putin is not a reliable historical s

Re: [marxmail] Latest poll of Palestinian opinion

2024-03-23 Thread hari kumar
Thx Marv. I found on a (to) quick read that it is somewhat tricky to interpret. Unequivocally it seems that: "The continued and consistent support for Hamas’ offensive despite significant changes in public attitudes during the past three months, including a significant decline in Hamas’ populari

Re: [marxmail] TITLE CHANGE TO TOO EARLY or not? Re: The economic systems of Fascism and Communism, including the present-day People's Republic of China

2024-03-24 Thread hari kumar
Good morning Michael: So I suppose there is never a perfect time, with all going on. I did not quite have enough time to completely re-do a full literature search. But - if not now, it won't happen - so I will plop down what I have come to in my mind. So on Tukhachevsky (in some sources Tukhache

Re: [marxmail] ML-ist Greg Godels on the contradictory nature of the People's Republic of China

2024-03-26 Thread hari kumar
Thanks Steve: I was going to ask something, which is very similar to the lines of Esteban as well. I have been for some time, been dealing with the Asian Mode of Production in relation to particular states. I have been very struck by this remark from Marx: "“In all forms of society there is one

Re: [marxmail] ML-ist Greg Godels on the contradictory nature of the People's Republic of China

2024-03-26 Thread hari kumar
Marv: Sorry but I am confused. You write:  "In an age of finance capitalism, what significance to attach to the fact that China’s financial system is state-owned and controlled?" Surely that statement re-framed can be inverted, to apply to the USA - making the distinction you pose (between 'state

Re: [marxmail] ML-ist Greg Godels on the contradictory nature of the People's Republic of China

2024-03-26 Thread hari kumar
Thx Marv. Still trying to understand your position. It seems that you do not accept that the Sate is the executive body of the ruling class - which in the USA - represents the leading top fraction of private owners of society. Or what am I missing? H -=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=- Groups.io Links: You

Re: [marxmail] Once Again, Germany Defines Who Is a Jew

2024-03-26 Thread hari kumar
As Charles points out the German state's approach to all this has been very problematic. A fascinating insight from A dam Tooze - cites much data on the *nodal* point of Merkel's government: "The speech is important to the current moment, because in it Merkel declared that Israel’s security was

Re: [marxmail] ML-ist Greg Godels on the contradictory nature of the People's Republic of China

2024-03-27 Thread hari kumar
Hi Marv. I am sure you have all this in mind already. But maybe worth a short moment to put down. Perhaps there are certainly reasons why they may be directly helpful to the working class - short of what most of us would consider a true socialism. But there are also at least three reasons, why

Re: [marxmail] ML-ist Greg Godels on the contradictory nature of the People's Republic of China

2024-03-27 Thread hari kumar
Hey Marv: I have not quite hit those spots that you note here. I do have some thoughts on this particular comment.  But I am right now cooking supper and I cannot do more tonight! Am tired I fear, so will strategically retreat - Ars long Vitae brevis perhaps, or a day-to-day version of the phras

[marxmail] Part 2 response to focused remarks Re: ML-ist Greg Godels on the contradictory nature of the People's Republic of China

2024-03-28 Thread hari kumar
1. The anti-Japanese United Front In January 1935, at an enlarged meeting of the Political Bureau of the Communist Party of China held during the famous 'Long March' at Tsunyi in Kweichow Province, "A new Central Committee headed by Comrade Mao Tse-tung." (Note to: Mao Tse-tung: 'Selected Works',

Re: [marxmail] ML-ist Greg Godels on the contradictory nature of the People's Republic of China

2024-03-28 Thread hari kumar
Good a.m. Marv. There are several aspects you have focused upon to aid my reply. I will first of all say that some of the ground here was - as you have noted also - been covered in a series of correspondences in Marxmail earlier (messages starting I thikn with Richard Fidler at 09/06/21 #11159   

Re: [marxmail] ML-ist Greg Godels on the contradictory nature of the People's Republic of China

2024-03-28 Thread hari kumar
Marv asks: "The answer I'm looking for more relates to the PRC where, as you know, I believe there to still be some continuity through the CPC with the 1949 revolution which overthrew capitalism. I believe you, Charlie, and perhaps Dan and others see the PRC as "state capitalist" in the same way

Re: [marxmail] ML-ist Greg Godels on the contradictory nature of the People's Republic of China

2024-03-28 Thread hari kumar
Hello Marv: These are picking up several points you have made. I have not particularly systematised my responses except in order of your mentioning them. First - You have asked us to consider whether recent history "call(s) into question why many of us spent a lifetime organizing and agitating f

Re: [marxmail] Accounting's is capitalism's main flaw

2024-03-28 Thread hari kumar
How do we do that and when Barry? Immediately after the revolution? Is there a transition period? What happens in the transition period? How does exchange of goods-commodites (?what do you call them now in this new state?) take place? How does everyone not end up making hammocks or beer? Can the

Re: [marxmail] Airliners Fall Apart in the Sky - What Is a Communist Solution?

2024-03-30 Thread hari kumar
Charlie: See https://prospect.org/infrastructure/transportation/2024-03-28-suicide-mission-boeing/?utm_source=substack&utm_medium=email On a worker whose diligence was hounded. "Suicide Mission - What Boeing did to all the guys who remember how to build a plane BY MAUREEN TKACIK  MARCH 28, 2024".

Re: [marxmail] Road to Famine: Israel’s History of Weaponizing Food Access in Gaza

2024-04-05 Thread hari kumar
All of these links to what is happening are very informative. I found these two that linked to Neve Gordon, particularly stark. The concept of a population level of calorie intake just above "minimal" needed, that is then choked off if the population gets uppity, was especially chilling. Thank y

[marxmail] Iran attack on Israel: A Hypothesis

2024-04-14 Thread hari kumar
As I frame this as a hypothesis - it is clearly thus far speculative. However: The signs look to me as if the Israeli government has tried to provoke the Iranian government into a fully fledged war. Israel took the step to illegally (by international law) attack and kill the Iranian members of di

[marxmail] Further on the Iranian Drones - bit later than I had hoped.

2024-04-19 Thread hari kumar
https://mlrg.online/articles/ -> https://mlrg.online/world/israels-provocation/ By the way Michael Karadjidis: Thanks very much for the references on the Haifa port. Updating it - it maybe that China has in fact interrupted their support for China. Their investment was as you had said quite major

[marxmail] Ken Loach

2024-04-19 Thread hari kumar
Seems a retrospective under way in NYC at least. A short review. Misses out a couple of his more overtly political ones. https://www.nytimes.com/2024/04/19/movies/ken-loach-movies.html?ugrp=u&unlocked_article_code=1.lk0.Lwnh.ywLeFn63GVkm&smid=url-share -=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=- Groups.io Links: Yo

Re: [marxmail] Here are the U.S. congressional districts benefiting from Ukraine aid: Washington Post

2024-04-19 Thread hari kumar
I believe that in general that was the argument of the I.S. (UK)_Michael Kidron - something like 'the Permanant Arms Economy". H -=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=- Groups.io Links: You receive all messages sent to this group. View/Reply Online (#29992): https://groups.io/g/marxmail/message/29992 Mute This

Re: [marxmail] Two charts: China's economic ties with Israel and Iran are approximately equal

2024-04-19 Thread hari kumar
Thx Charlie. H -=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=- Groups.io Links: You receive all messages sent to this group. View/Reply Online (#29997): https://groups.io/g/marxmail/message/29997 Mute This Topic: https://groups.io/mt/105624148/21656 -=-=- POSTING RULES & NOTES #1 YOU MUST clip all extraneous text when r

[marxmail] False photos of markets in Gaza shown to German Foreign Minister Baerbock

2024-04-19 Thread hari kumar
A tense contrary position between Netanyahu and Baerbock in Jerusalem. https://www.spiegel.de/politik/deutschland/israel-annalena-baerbock-und-benjamin-netanjahu-geraten-heftig-aneinander-a-90e5c7cf-7eb3-4f49-8ef5-0cf0d2854d1b Baerbock was arguing for more aid into Gaza, and Netanyahu was arguing

Re: [marxmail] Frederick Rzewski: "The People Will Never be Defeated"

2024-04-20 Thread hari kumar
Wow - Lucky you! As was Marv to hear Inti-Illimani. The Rome concert must have been very powerful. The 'People's Composer' he was called. I think taking over from Aaron Copeland - at least in the USA. We've had a few 'People's Composers' - including Ludwig Beethoven and Amadeus Mozart. Be well.

Re: [marxmail] Further on the Iranian Drones - bit later than I had hoped.

2024-04-22 Thread hari kumar
Today's NYT article amounts to a deconstruction of the posturing of all relevant State players - a bit more clearly than the main media has been to date. https://www.nytimes.com/2024/04/22/world/middleeast/israel-iran-war-strike.html?unlocked_article_code=1.mU0.TWkn.14Y2mE3RIxr1&smid=url-share H

Re: [marxmail] The Two-State Solution Is an Unjust, Impossible Fantasy

2024-04-23 Thread hari kumar
Michael M: Honestly, I was hesitant about wading into the national question matter that you raised. Because it is an incredibly complex matter which starts from the definition of 'what is a nation?". This postulate as expressed here, will inevitably spark differences. None will be easily resolva

[marxmail] An accessible picture into modern warfare

2024-04-23 Thread hari kumar
In Ukraine, big companies, the Pentagon - are refining new methods to kill - NYT https://www.nytimes.com/2024/04/23/us/politics/ukraine-new-american-technology.html?unlocked_article_code=1.mk0.-SXC.iWNKNkXwqYjp&smid=url-share -=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=- Groups.io Links: You receive all messages sent

[marxmail] Major aspects of political economy at Columbia University

2024-04-26 Thread hari kumar
As laid out by Adam Tooze. Includes a great simple chart from Columbia University Apartheid Divest. https://adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-279-columbia-universitys?utm_source=post-email-title&publication_id=192845&post_id=144036886&utm_campaign=email-post-title&isFreemail=true&r=17xgfq&triedRe

Re: [marxmail] Major aspects of political economy at Columbia University

2024-04-26 Thread hari kumar
Hello Alan: I agree incredibly detailed. The last flow chart is an ancestor of the one Tooze showed. Also clear that it must have been a lot of work to put that together. Even today doing that (with the net ie.) is not straightforward. I think you might consider sending that pamphlet to Tooze. Be

Re: [marxmail] Famous English spinner crickiter standing at next general election for Golloway's Workers Party at Ealing Souhall!

2024-04-30 Thread hari kumar
Sorry cannot get that link to work for some reason. Same topic at 'Guardian' today: https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2024/apr/30/george-galloway-workers-party-election-candidates-monty-panesar ( https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2024/apr/30/george-galloway-workers-party-election-candidat

Re: [marxmail] Biden can lose this thing - and if so, watch the Dems blame the Left

2024-04-30 Thread hari kumar
As we see Colombian protesters about to be "cleared" by the riot police, it is difficult to be optimsitc about the chances for Biden. But long way to go. In meantime one aspect of Juan Cole's piece that struck me was this on the contrast between what Israel does in Gaza - and their proven abilit

[marxmail] Excellent essay on links - police brutality and obtaining 'adherence' in everyday life

2024-05-01 Thread hari kumar
Adam Tooze witnessed the events in NYC, and puts it into a broad framework. Thus far I have only been on his free e-list. I think I might actually subscribe. Some short clips : "there in front of us on the street was the state manifesting in a primitive battle for control of space. Burly officer

[marxmail] Views From Inside of Israel of pro-Gazan demonstrations

2024-05-03 Thread hari kumar
Very revealing in my view. It certainly reinforces how difficult it will be to get to a "one state" solution in the short term. We have had some discussion about this here, but it has been somewhat superficial I think, upon reflection. As some indications are that a 'joint' supervision of areas

Re: [marxmail] On Tuesday, Biden demonized the protesters as hate groups.

2024-05-03 Thread hari kumar
Hello John: Can you tell me again - excuse my thickness, but what are the exact benefits not voting for Biden? Other of course than massaging one's own self-righteousness? Hari -=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=- Groups.io Links: You receive all messages sent to this group. View/Reply Online (#30200): http

Re: [marxmail] We need "Outside Agitators"!

2024-05-07 Thread hari kumar
Mark: I agree with the basic sentiment that you raise: A worry about agent provocateurs. However, in the situation that developed you can likely understand how happy the encampments were to get the support. And how difficult it was perhaps to 'ask for credentials'. But - I had the same reactio

  1   2   3   4   >