Re: [DISCUSS] Enable the discussion tab for iceberg github repos

A reminder. GitHub Discussion has been enabled on iceberg-rust and there are already interesting ideas open for discussion . Please weigh in. On Mon, Jul 15, 2024 at 9:39 PM Renjie Liu wrote: > Hi: > > >> But one minor concern

Re: [DISCUSS] Enable the discussion tab for iceberg github repos

Hi: > But one minor concern, since this has to be enabled at the repo level(go, > rust, core), wondering if this can lead to limited participation as against > when discussed in a mailing list. This is a good point, but as we discussed, github discussions are usually used for user related quest

Re: [DISCUSS] Enable the discussion tab for iceberg github repos

+1 for enabling it on iceberg-rust first. IMO, this can benefit many code-related discussions. GitHub provides a convenient way for users to point out specific parts of the source code by pasting the permalink, which GitHub automatically renders. Looking forward to seeing how this progresses in ic

Re: [DISCUSS] Enable the discussion tab for iceberg github repos

+1 to having things on Github. But one minor concern, since this has to be enabled at the repo level(go, rust, core), wondering if this can lead to limited participation as against when discussed in a mailing list. Thanks Karuppayya

Re: [DISCUSS] Enable the discussion tab for iceberg github repos

+1, looking forward to see it in action, would 3 months be a good evaluation window for rest of the iceberg repo? Thanks, Steve Zhang > On Jul 11, 2024, at 9:52 AM, Yufei Gu wrote: > > +1. It is a no-brainer to me given it is more search-engine friendly compared > to slack and email. It won

Re: [DISCUSS] Enable the discussion tab for iceberg github repos

+1. It is a no-brainer to me given it is more search-engine friendly compared to slack and email. It won't have the retention issue from Slack as well. I'd like to see it on other Iceberg repos as well. Yufei On Wed, Jul 10, 2024 at 3:01 PM Jack Ye wrote: > +1 for enabling it on iceberg-rust f

Re: [DISCUSS] Enable the discussion tab for iceberg github repos

It sounds reasonable to me. We are using GH Discussions on some ASF projects and it works pretty well. Regards JB On Wed, Jul 10, 2024 at 11:39 AM Fokko Driesprong wrote: > > Thanks for raising this. I would also prefer discussions over a user > mailing-list since it has a lower barrier. We co

Re: [DISCUSS] Enable the discussion tab for iceberg github repos

+1 for enabling it on iceberg-rust first. I am curious how search-engine friendly this is, that will be a huge plus if people can find these discussion contents. For people who have used it more like Piotr, do you know about this? I search Trino things quite a lot on Google, but rarely did I find

Re: [DISCUSS] Enable the discussion tab for iceberg github repos

I'm a fan of having more things on github if possible. I haven't used this feature but it sounds like it could be useful. On Wed, Jul 10, 2024 at 6:15 AM Renjie Liu wrote: > I’m fine with enabling it in iceberg-rust first and see how it goes. > > On Wed, Jul 10, 2024 at 17:39 Fokko Driesprong w

Re: [DISCUSS] Enable the discussion tab for iceberg github repos

I’m fine with enabling it in iceberg-rust first and see how it goes. On Wed, Jul 10, 2024 at 17:39 Fokko Driesprong wrote: > Thanks for raising this. I would also prefer discussions over a user > mailing-list since it has a lower barrier. We could also first enable this > on Iceberg-rust and eva

Re: [DISCUSS] Enable the discussion tab for iceberg github repos

Thanks for raising this. I would also prefer discussions over a user mailing-list since it has a lower barrier. We could also first enable this on Iceberg-rust and evaluate it after a while to see the added value and then decide for Python and Java? WDYT? Kind regards, Fokko Op wo 10 jul 2024 om

Re: [DISCUSS] Enable the discussion tab for iceberg github repos

Yes and no :) It's a beta feature. My point is that we can enabled GitHub Discussion easily, and depending of the timing, asf.yaml support will be added. Regards JB On Tue, Jul 9, 2024 at 7:49 AM Xuanwo wrote: > > Hi, > > > Regarding the discussion tab, it sounds good to me. It's pretty > strai

Re: [DISCUSS] Enable the discussion tab for iceberg github repos

Hi: I am not familiar with the GitHub discussion feature, but could we start > with GitHub Issue tags + templates to distinguish between actual issues vs > this kind of questions? Why is that not sufficient? It's one possible solution, but as I have mentioned, it mixes with bug/issue tracking in

Re: [DISCUSS] Enable the discussion tab for iceberg github repos

Thanks for sharing that context, Piotr! If we think that github discussions will be a place primarily for user list discussions, then I think I'd support that over creating a separate user mailing list. I think most people prefer Slack or Github to mailing lists for this kind of thing. Personally,

Re: [DISCUSS] Enable the discussion tab for iceberg github repos

I am not familiar with the GitHub discussion feature and do not have an opinion about using it. I do think though that it would be useful to have a user list as well as a dev list for Apache Iceberg. Many Apache projects have both. Discussions about project work should continue to happen on the dev

Re: [DISCUSS] Enable the discussion tab for iceberg github repos

Hi, I totally hear Ryan's concerns about further dividing the discussion. I had the same feeling when we opened discussions in Trino. The reality was more positive though. Discussions predominantly serve as a way to ask questions rather than drive decision-making in the project. Thinking from user

Re: [DISCUSS] Enable the discussion tab for iceberg github repos

I am not familiar with the GitHub discussion feature, but could we start with GitHub Issue tags + templates to distinguish between actual issues vs this kind of questions? Why is that not sufficient? Also, if there are a lot of questions about the roadmap, I think we should discuss and make good m

Re: [DISCUSS] Enable the discussion tab for iceberg github repos

My only concern about using this tool is that we may be further separating where discussion happens and not everyone will see what's happening. Usually, the dev list is the canonical place for discussions. Is that not a good solution? What differentiates what we would use github discussions for vs

Re: [DISCUSS] Enable the discussion tab for iceberg github repos

I think GH discussions would be great to have on the Iceberg repo(s), so +1 from my side on this. Eduard On Tue, Jul 9, 2024 at 8:14 AM Renjie Liu wrote: > Hi: > > It's also possible to create a user mailing list if it helps. > > > I'm neutral to this option. Seems we are actually missing the u

Re: [DISCUSS] Enable the discussion tab for iceberg github repos

Hi: It's also possible to create a user mailing list if it helps. I'm neutral to this option. Seems we are actually missing the user mail list. On Tue, Jul 9, 2024 at 1:50 PM Xuanwo wrote: > Hi, > > > Regarding the discussion tab, it sounds good to me. It's pretty > straight forward to do by

Re: [DISCUSS] Enable the discussion tab for iceberg github repos

Hi, > Regarding the discussion tab, it sounds good to me. It's pretty straight forward to do by editing .asf.yaml. I tried this before. But the asf.yaml doesn't support controling discussion yet. We need the help from infra team. https://cwiki.apache.org/confluence/pages/viewpage.action?spaceKey

Re: [DISCUSS] Enable the discussion tab for iceberg github repos

Hi It's also possible to create a user mailing list if it helps. Regarding the discussion tab, it sounds good to me. It's pretty straight forward to do by editing .asf.yaml. Regards JB On Tue, Jul 9, 2024 at 5:18 AM Renjie Liu wrote: > > Hi: > > Recently we have observed more and more user int

Re: [DISCUSS] Enable the discussion tab for iceberg github repos

I think dev list is mostly about developer discussion, such as design, proposal. Github issues are mostly about issue/bug tracking. Github discussion is about user questions, announcements, etc. But I agree that we could start with iceberg-rust repo first, as it's relatively new and we have more

Re: [DISCUSS] Enable the discussion tab for iceberg github repos

Thank Renjie to start this thread. I considered suggesting enabling GitHub discussions for iceberg-rust, but I hesitated because Iceberg itself doesn't use this feature and almost all discussions take place on the mailing list. Although I enjoy using GitHub discussions, I'm also satisfied with

[DISCUSS] Enable the discussion tab for iceberg github repos

Hi: Recently we have observed more and more user interested in iceberg-rust, and they have many questions about it, for example the status, relationship with others such pyiceberg. Slack is a great place to discussion, but is not friendly for long discussion and not easy to comment. We can also en