on continuing to wait

2025-04-06 Thread Sean Whitton
Dear Joerg, In your message, you're asking Ian to accept that the work from the ftpmaster side will be completed, and so raising the threat of a GR is not appropriate. Please put yourself in our shoes, and consider whether this is a reasonable thing to ask Ian to accept, in these circumstances.

Re: Question to all candidates: how is Debian doing?

2025-04-06 Thread Gianfranco Costamagna
Hello, > >What is wrong with debuginfod.debian.net as explained in that wiki page >referenced above? It's paid with Debian funds and run by a DD. Or are >you implying that it should be run by DSA? In that case, what would be >the reasoning behind that? Nope, I was unsure about the status of an

Re: Q to all candidates: future of Debian finances

2025-04-06 Thread Paulo Henrique de Lima Santana
Hi, This is not related to the election, but I would like to propose to the next DPL we organize a "call for donations". First, we need to organize a "call for people interesting to organize a call for donations" to gather volunteers to discuss ideas for the campaign. It would be important

Re: Why Debian is dying (Was: Call for volunteers and GR draft: tag2upload key installation)

2025-04-06 Thread Ian Jackson
Simon Richter writes ("Re: Why Debian is dying (Was: Call for volunteers and GR draft: tag2upload key installation)"): > Git is not a packaging tool. There is no way to have a "native" > git-based packaging workflow. Certainly there is. We've built it. Theare are at least two really good ones

Re: Why Debian is dying (Was: Call for volunteers and GR draft: tag2upload key installation)

2025-04-06 Thread Ian Jackson
Joerg Jaspert writes ("Re: Why Debian is dying (Was: Call for volunteers and GR draft: tag2upload key installation)"): > > We are waiting because the DPL won't authorise an "NMU", despite > > - the team involved being well-known as dysfunctional for many years > > - the team's explicit position

Re: Why Debian is dying (Was: Call for volunteers and GR draft: tag2upload key installation)

2025-04-06 Thread Matthias Urlichs
On 06.04.25 13:01, Simon Richter wrote: I can explain the sequence … which mayyybe you might look at from the perspective of somebody-new-interested-in-contributing-to-Debian. 1. use 'apt source x' to get the source package Use dgit. You get a git repo along with it. Or simply "git clone", f

Re: Why Debian is dying (Was: Call for volunteers and GR draft: tag2upload key installation)

2025-04-06 Thread Matthias Urlichs
On 06.04.25 13:21, Joerg Jaspert wrote: Because you do not think it neccessary by force implies that everyone has to think so? Note that we can easily flip that statement. Because in effect, *just* because you think it's necessary everybody *does* have to think so, regardless of whether it's

Re: Why Debian is dying (Was: Call for volunteers and GR draft: tag2upload key installation)

2025-04-06 Thread Joerg Jaspert
On 17556 March 1977, Ian Jackson wrote: We aren't waiting because ftpmaster haven't done the work agreed in 2024, that only they want. That work is *not necessary*. Because you do not think it neccessary by force implies that everyone has to think so? You do not want it. The team that does

Re: Question to all candidates: the FTP Team

2025-04-06 Thread Nilesh Patra
On 06/04/25 3:30 pm, Ian Jackson wrote: > To renew this institution, we need to get rid of the toxicity first. > That means getting rid of the toxic people. > > Yes, that is disruptive and risky. But the alternative is to allow > the current situation to persist, as you have allowed it to persist

Re: Why Debian is dying (Was: Call for volunteers and GR draft: tag2upload key installation)

2025-04-06 Thread Simon Richter
Hi, On 4/5/25 19:41, Daniel Gröber wrote: I only joined Debian in 2024 and since then one thing has become abundantly clear to me: it's dying because potential contributors are put off by our archaic, fragmented and most importantly not natively git-based workflow(s!). Git is not a packaging

DebConf costs and locations, was: Re: Q to all candidates: future of Debian finances

2025-04-06 Thread Daniel Lange
Hi Nilesh, I remember hearing a pointer from a few folks that one of the reasons for higher cost of debconf 23 and 24 was it due to being in Asia while most of the DDs live in Europe. As a result, the travel costs bumped up the overall conference expense. That is true, but the biggest groups w

Re: Why Debian is dying (Was: Call for volunteers and GR draft: tag2upload key installation)

2025-04-06 Thread Ian Jackson
Gianfranco Costamagna writes ("Re: Why Debian is dying (Was: Call for volunteers and GR draft: tag2upload key installation)"): > I know after a lot of development, watching the result of the job > not being live due to missing work on somebody else hands is... > sad... It can be deployed, and we

Re: Why Debian is dying (Was: Call for volunteers and GR draft: tag2upload key installation)

2025-04-06 Thread Ian Jackson
Gianfranco Costamagna writes ("Re: Why Debian is dying (Was: Call for volunteers and GR draft: tag2upload key installation)"): > The months before a stable release pose a really high pressure on > ftpmasters workload, This is so frustrating! I have already explained why this is completely irrele

Re: Question to all candidates: the FTP Team

2025-04-06 Thread Ian Jackson
Andreas Tille writes ("Re: Question to all candidates: the FTP Team"): > Am Fri, Apr 04, 2025 at 06:19:14PM +0800 schrieb Sean Whitton: > > My basic question to you is: We agreed on almost everything that needed > > to be done. You had a team insider, me, available to ask for advice on > > how to

Re: Question to all candidates: how is Debian doing?

2025-04-06 Thread Jonathan Carter
Hi Gianfranco On 2025/04/06 09:10, Gianfranco Costamagna wrote: Also,https://wiki.debian.org/Debuginfod sounds nice, but the service is run outside Debian (on a .debian.net domain). Was it discussed making it part of Debian? As the DPL, what do you pushes people to maintain such services outside

Re: Why Debian is dying (Was: Call for volunteers and GR draft: tag2upload key installation)

2025-04-06 Thread Matthias Urlichs
On 05.04.25 23:37, Brian May wrote: An added complexity is that sometimes upstream will add non-DFSG compliant files to their source, and as such we have to repackage the upstream orig tar.gz file to remove these files. Maybe it's (finally?) time to re-think most-if-not-all of that. As in, in

Re: Question to all candidates: how is Debian doing?

2025-04-06 Thread Gianfranco Costamagna
Hello, >Also, https://wiki.debian.org/Debuginfod sounds nice, but the service is >run outside Debian (on a .debian.net domain). Was it discussed making it >part of Debian? As the DPL, what do you pushes people to maintain such >services outside Debian, and what would you do to improve on that? I

Re: Why Debian is dying (Was: Call for volunteers and GR draft: tag2upload key installation)

2025-04-06 Thread Gianfranco Costamagna
Hello, I don't want to participate in this thread right now, but I just want to propose a different view of the topic > We don't know what ftpmaster think should happen next since they > haven't said.  There is no indication that ftpmaster will start the > implementation work, nor that they are p