Re: [computer-go] Re: Scaling monte carlo up to 19x19

2007-01-31 Thread Jacques BasaldĂșa
Nick Apperson wrote: > There are certain times when this technique is highly useful. ... > imagine a board with two walls down the middle bordering on each other I agree. We have to divide the board to create strong programs! But division is a very complicated subject. In the isolated areas UCT

Re: [computer-go] Re: Scaling monte carlo up to 19x19

2007-01-31 Thread Don Dailey
On Wed, 2007-01-31 at 04:00 -0800, Dave Dyer wrote: > > > >Of course, everything depends on how you can deal with the boarders - how > >about some monte-carlo-simulations over the possible boarder-configurations? > > My thought is that one thing you could easily get from the rollouts > is a good

[computer-go] Re: Scaling monte carlo up to 19x19

2007-01-31 Thread Dave Dyer
> >Of course, everything depends on how you can deal with the boarders - how >about some monte-carlo-simulations over the possible boarder-configurations? My thought is that one thing you could easily get from the rollouts is a good estimate of the status of each string of stones currently on th

Re: [computer-go] Re: Scaling monte carlo up to 19x19

2007-01-31 Thread Benjamin Teuber
Funny thing, I also just thought about this as a friend of mine had an idea similiar to Dave's. I guess it might be a good idea to make your zone-partitioning (or zone-merging, when you start from 1x1-boards) dependant of the current board configuration. That is, some clever algorithm (probably

Re: [computer-go] Re: Scaling monte carlo up to 19x19

2007-01-31 Thread Daniel Burgos
I'm working now in a similar idea. As yours, it will play only in one zone using MC. It will start on 7x7 sub-boards but they will grow once they become full of stones. I will normalize the sub-board results using its area. It will help me to compare the different sub-boards. Once all the sub-b

Re: [computer-go] Re: Scaling monte carlo up to 19x19

2007-01-30 Thread Nick Apperson
I believe this to be a good idea, but I couldn't get around some minor problems. Essentially, because the local searches are coupled to one another, it ends up exploding as you consider this coupling (scaling to larger regions). You then have to trade accuracy or have more computing power than I

Re: [computer-go] Re: Scaling monte carlo up to 19x19

2007-01-30 Thread steve uurtamo
> The idea isn't more than lightly toasted (less than half baked), but > the kernal is turn the full board search into set of searches on > much smaller boards, using the overlapping strips as boundary > conditions, then do some unifying final step to pick the move. how would it handle the followi

Re: [computer-go] Re: Scaling monte carlo up to 19x19

2007-01-30 Thread Weston Markham
I have an idea in the back of my mind that is an extreme version of this: Divide the board into 361 separate local searches, then use information from these to guide a global search. The local searches would be done on the full board, but would only search for strategies that will capture or def

[computer-go] Re: Scaling monte carlo up to 19x19

2007-01-30 Thread Dave Dyer
At 02:59 PM 1/30/2007, [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: > I'm having difficulty picturing this, so I'll start with the most basic > questions. > >Do you mean Monte Carlo by itself or Monte Carlo combined with tree search >(e.g. UCT)? > The idea isn't more than lightly toasted (less than half baked),

Re: [computer-go] Re: Scaling monte carlo up to 19x19

2007-01-30 Thread dhillismail
ext) or in some other sense? - Dave Hillis -Original Message- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: computer-go@computer-go.org; computer-go@computer-go.org Sent: Tue, 30 Jan 2007 3:00 PM Subject: [computer-go] Re: Scaling monte carlo up to 19x19 Here's an idea for scaling up, which should

[computer-go] Re: Scaling monte carlo up to 19x19

2007-01-30 Thread Dave Dyer
Here's an idea for scaling up, which should result in "only" factor of 10 slower speed. To scale from 9x9 to 19x19, subdivide the board into four, overlapping 10x10 boards. Run a standard 9x9 monte carlo up to the 90% full stage on each of the four boards, then run a full board monte on the wh