On Sat, 9 Jan 2016 11:11:27 -0700 Daniel Melameth <dan...@melameth.com> wrote:
> >> You NEED to set a max on your ROOT queues. > > I came to this conclusion as well. But not only on root queues. For > > example, when max is set on root queue but only bandwidth on child > > queues, no shaping takes place... > > This works for me. Thank you for "small bandwidth issue" information. Can someone give more precise measurement of "small bandwidth"? What is the smallest bandwidth of a queue which is known to work reliably? Did I understand correctly there is resolution to this issue, and if so, which is it? Where do I start looking why this works for Daniel but doesn't for me? > > Or, to cut the long story short, if someone can paste queue > > definition which accomplishes 'give both queues max bandwidth, but > > throttle traffic from first queue when traffic from the second one > > arrives', I will be more than happy to quit bothering misc@ list > > readers with my rants and observations. > > I would expect this to be possible with prio alone, but I've never > been able to get it to work. Perhaps I'm misunderstanding how prio > works. I would expect this as well, and I've been able to get it to work on old ALTQ queueing system but not on current queueing system. Either I'm misunderstanding how prio works as well, or we are coming to the point where multiple users aren't able to get it to work. Either way I hope some authoritative person from OpenBSD who knows how prio works will give us the possibility to understand it by means of direct advice, correct documentation, or confirm it doesn't work. Some of us poor illiterates don't understand pf code and depend on manpages. -- Before enlightenment - chop wood, draw water. After enlightenment - chop wood, draw water. Marko Cupać https://www.mimar.rs/
