If we know the bug, and we have a fix, there shouldn't be anything stopping us from making a release. If this patch break binary compat, then the only logical move forward is a 4.4 branch and release.
I think the question should really be: "why don't we want to give 4.x users this bugfix?" I can't think of any valid reasons not to do that. --Wez. On 5/30/05, Zeev Suraski <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > At 12:00 30/05/2005, Lukas Smith wrote: > >Derick Rethans wrote: > >>Hi Dmitry, > >>On Thu, 26 May 2005, Dmitry Stogov wrote: > >> > >>>This patch breaks binary compatibility. > >>>It cannot be broken in 4.3.x tree, and that doesn't make sense to release > >>>4.4 just for this patch. > >> > >>You mean that they think that it doesn't make sense to fix PHP in cases > >>where it's totally broken? I think that's totally irresponsible > >>behavior. Thousands of people still use PHP 4 for good reasons. If you > >>look correctly through the bug database you'll find atleast 10 bugs > >>related to strange segfaults and some have been confirmed to be related > >>to references that crash PHP. > >>I think we should definitely put this in a PHP release, although the > >>patch doesn't fix all segfaults yet. > >>(Patch is at: > >>http://files.derickrethans.nl/patches/ze1-return-reference-20050429.diff.txt) > > > >I also agree that these issues need to be fixed inside the 4.x tree. What > >would be the motivation no to release a 4.4 to fix these issues? Beating > >users with a stick towards PHP 5? > > In my opinion we should probably not fix this at all in the 4.x tree, > because the hassle involved in starting a new 4.4 branch - breaking module > compatibility for everyone, confusing people (imagine Apache 1.4 coming out > at this point), etc. > If it was an issue that everyone and their dog was bumping into, then I may > have thought differently - but it's an issue that is rare enough, and can > be worked around. And those that really need it to be fixed - can use the > patch. > > Does everyone else think that this issue warrants starting a new version > branch? > > Zeev > > -- > PHP Internals - PHP Runtime Development Mailing List > To unsubscribe, visit: http://www.php.net/unsub.php > > -- PHP Internals - PHP Runtime Development Mailing List To unsubscribe, visit: http://www.php.net/unsub.php
