On Mon, Nov 7, 2016 at 8:45 PM, John D. Ament <johndam...@apache.org> wrote: >...
> > As one of the member of the IPMC, I would very much like to see > > podlings set up *EXACTLY* like PMCs, albeit with oversight by mentors. > > That means non-IPMC members are NOT removed, and committers in the > > "incubator" group are NOT added, only mentors. > > > > I'm a bit iffy here. IMHO, we cannot leave existing accounts in place on > the organization, as we won't have ICLAs on file (except for a few who > already exist I bet). What I don't want to see is the PPMC, for non-IPMC > members, be given the ability to grant committer privileges to the repo > without having an ICLA on file. > Well, this is a bunch of technical bits that Infra will take care of, to ensure that we meet the needs defined by Legal Affairs, when operating under "GitHub as Master". I believe the IPMC *policy* point is more about community, rather than these considerations. I'm comfortable we can meet Legal's needs before/for graduation (tho I can't give a timeframe). The outstanding question is whether we're being *asked* to do so. If IPMC defines some additional requirements that we haven't foreseen (eg. every IPMC members gets commit on the podling), then we can figure out the feasibility. Cheers, -g
