On Jun 25, 2015 3:01 AM, "Emmanuel Lécharny" <elecha...@gmail.com> wrote: > > Le 25/06/15 09:21, Jochen Theodorou a écrit : > > Am 24.06.2015 22:32, schrieb Emmanuel Lécharny: > >> Le 24/06/15 22:28, David Nalley a écrit : > > [...] > >>> More generally to the underlying issue that prompted this discussion: > >>> With the concrete example of Geode's DockerHub presence, I don't think > >>> it's acceptable: > >>> https://registry.hub.docker.com/u/apachegeode/geode/ > >>> > >>> Specifically, it's promoting folks consume a nightly build. > >>> There's no warning that this hasn't met the ASF standards for > >>> software, or that this project hasn't even pushed out a release yet. > >>> Then there's the fact that the dockerfile isn't even coming from the > >>> ASF it's coming from: https://github.com/markito/geode-docker > >> > >> That is a clear breach of The ASF release policy, I agree. > > > > Just to clarify this... as far as I can see, both pages are not under > > the control of apache. The github page is not a mirror page from the > > apache organization as well. Why does the apache policy extend to > > non-apache pages? > > Good question ! My perception is that it is an ASF policy breach, > assuming the team providing such a package is a member of the Apache > community. > > If it's not the case, then, there is no problem, or nothing we can do. > > However, when you look at the link [1], the page says : " If you have > any problems with or questions about this image, please contact us using > d...@geode.incubator.org <mailto:d...@geode.incubator.org> or join our > HipChat <http://s.apache.org/geodechat> channel.". Although the mail is > wrong (it should be d...@geode.incubator.apache.org), the hipchat channel > link referes to http://s.apache.org/geodechat, clearly an Apache resource. > > > [1] https://registry.hub.docker.com/u/apachegeode/geode/
My understanding is that the Docker Hub page is under the control of the Geode PMC. (Roman please correct me if this is wrong.) The Geode PMC also points downstream users to the Docker Hub page from other resources it controls (e.g. their twitter account and ASF blog) If the Docker Hub page wasn't under the control of the Geode PMC, then I'd say it was a marks violation and they'd have to seek out control of it or removal. -- Sean
