Raphaël Luta wrote: > > What specific concerns do you have with this community and this codebase? > - the mentor for this project is salaried by the project sponsor !
To date, we have said that an ASF Member is an individual, not an employeee. Mind you, we're also discussing that a project SHOULD have multiple Mentors. > - I can trace no public attempt to meet other possible user apache > communities (myfaces, portals, cocoon, etc...) even after first > proposal rejection I see interaction with MyFaces, and one of them already added as a Committer. You are here. Is Portal going to give it a whirl? > - I see negative technical feedback on the proposal from ASF > people I trust left unanswered Actually, everyone is waiting for Martin to provide technical details, and there *have* been answers to those few that people could parse out. > - some ties with a possible "downstream" community, possibly > adding some of their committers in the initial committer pool A MyFaces Committer was already added to the list. How about you for Portal? If not you, who? --- Noel --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]