On Mon, 2006-01-23 at 13:38 +0100, Raphaël Luta wrote: > > Seeing Zimbra current OSS efforts with this toolkit (even with an ASF member > in their team), I have a hard time believing this proposal is anything but a > branding exercise to help this toolkit stand out in the crowd of Ajax > toolkits. > > My "admission bar" for such proposals is set much higher than usual.
With all due respect Raphael, I find this unreasonable. You can't make random "admission bars" for projects based on personal prejudices. What I suggest is that you join the project as a mentor and make sure push them hard to make sure they come out clean as whistle or hold them in incubation until its killed. That way you convince yourself that the project is good *from the ASF points of view* (community, meritocracy etc.) but not from things like visibility point of view which by no means are a requirement. What's the status of the vote? I'm confused by calls to repeal the vote and modifications to the vote and all that. I thought we were spsed to be a simple bunch of, um, people but it sure doesn't look like it! ;-) Am I spsed to vote my choice at this time or is there no vote going on? So confused. Must be the freezing weather in Sri Lanka these days. Its been like 65F in Colombo at nite. Brrrrrr. Sanjiva. --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
