Well, I am wondering if this really is a "common" need that should go into
the commons project. We already have "math".
If it doesn't fit in there it might well be better of to get it into labs
IMO - not commons.


I would say the same could apply to many commons or commons-sandbox components.

Well, I think most of the commons projects rather try to fill a gap in the java language APIs. This clearly is not the case for the suggested new sandbox arrival. If it really could go into Math that would be fine with me. But I don't see it as a candidate for an individual commons project.

It does not belong in labs because it is intended as a
community project.

The way I understand the purpose of Labs is to have sandbox that is under no particular top level project. ...and community being less of issue but people are more than welcome to join efforts there as well.And surely the goal is to get passed this and join a TLP if successful. But that's my interpretation of the Labs Bylaws.

If we are willing to accept it into Math potentially it would be of course much easier to start in our sandbox ...or a different branch in Math

*shrug*

cheers
--
Torsten

---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Reply via email to