Lars Schäfers wrote: > I would propose the GnuGO scoring as a referee. Perhaps it's possible > to ask the two bots which stones they think are dead or in seki. > If they don't agree GnuGO will decide who had won. This would perhaps > be an advantage for GnuGO playing on CGOS but show me a 9x9 game where > you wouldn't agree with the scoring, I think such cases are really > rare.
I am using GnuGo scoring in my tournaments. But GnuGo 3.7.10 mostly doesn´t score seki correctly, has this been revised for v3.7.11 ...?! So the reliability of GnuGo´s scoring depends on the programs playing stile because some programs tend to look for living in seki more often than others. A rough estimation for my 9x9 tournament: between 1% and 5% of the 9x9 games are not scored correctly by GnuGo 3.7.10 but the side to win is correct in 99,9% of the games. Stefan _______________________________________________ computer-go mailing list computer-go@computer-go.org http://www.computer-go.org/mailman/listinfo/computer-go/
