>>> Jacob Keller <j-kell...@fsm.northwestern.edu> 10/13/10 2:50 PM >>>
Isn't the simplest answer that this is not really an Argand diagram with
real and imaginary axes, but simply a diagram showing the graphical addition
of the component phasors of the atom's scattering components? And aren't
real and imaginary relative terms anyway (in more ways than one, I guess!)?

Can we say:
scattering factors are relative to a non-anomalously scattered wave from the
center of the atom.
f' is horizontal, f" vertical

Structure factors are relative to a non-anomalously scattered wave from the
origin of
the (any) unit cell. so both f' and f" are shifted by the same amount, which
depends on the
component of the vector from the origin along the scattering vector.
They are still perpendicular, but no longer horizontal and vertical.

So when you set your detector distance, you need to make sure there is an
even number of
wavelengths between the origin of a unit cell and the center of detector, so
you get the phase
right (at least in the center). No wait, I guess the detector cant detect
phase. At this point. phase
is really relative, it just matters whether the waves scattered by the
different units of electron
density are in phase or out of phase with each other. Move the detector back
another half-angstrom
and you rotate the argand diagram 90*.  But we don't care since we can't
measure phase.
As we move back along the beam the relative phases of the different
scatterers remain 
the same, and it is convenient to pretend we are at a point in phase with
non-anomalously 
scattered wave from the origin of the unit cell in order to calculate the
intensity.

Reply via email to