Aaaaand ... the issues begin, too. NOT ANY CFJs: I want to see if
we can resolve these with discussion without mucking up the competition.
1. From R2431: "During the Agoran Week following the initiation of a
Proposal Competition"...
Does "the Agoran week following the initiation" mean this week, next
week, or 7 days from initiation? Given that (from R1023):
Agoran weeks begin at midnight UTC on Monday.
BUT (also from R1023):
These definitions do not apply to relative durations (e.g.
"within <number> days after <event>").
If it just said "week", it would clearly be the relative duration one,
but Agoran Week? "Agoran week following" seems like an internal
contradiction referring to both parts of R1023.
2. "any player CAN specify that a Proposal e submits is
a Competition Proposal for that Competition."
Does the Proposal itself need not be submitted during the competition
time... Can a player specify an old proposal?
3. "The Promotor SHALL distribute all Competition Proposals for a
given Competition in the same message."
These still need to pay pend fees, right? If not, the Promotor will be
breaking R1607 (which overrules the above). The way it reads, if
there are a mix of pending and not-pending proposals in the competition,
the Promotor has to hold onto all of them (e SHALL NOT distribute the
not-pending ones due to R1607, but e SHALL NOT distribute the pending
ones because they have to be distributed with the non-pending ones).
Which means e's stuck every which way, because if e doesn't distribute
the pending ones in a timely manner, e's broken R1607.
4. Is there any benefit to "winning" a proposal competition? What
is "winning" a proposal competition? Or is this just to distribute
a bunch of proposals without cost (that doesn't work, due to #3, above.
