> I don't get the argumentations here. Everyone was happy that plan9 was
> relicensed as MIT last year. If no one is allowed to make closed source
> distributions of plan9 based systems than why were all unhappy with the
> prior licenses.


You're confusing the license and expressed wishes.
Personally I will always use MIT license whenever I can. Regardless I
think it's good manners to include the source, and more true to the
original intent why it's MIT licensed.
If you don't do as I please, I'll continue expressing my disagreement,
nothing more than that. You're as usual free to ignore it.
License is coercion. I don't like that.

> Years ago plan9 was licensed as GPL. 9front kept licensing
> with MIT. If you expect everybody to make their products and systems fully
> open sourced than you should have sticked with the GPL license.

GPL has never done anything for me, why should I do anything for them?

> I admired
> the determination of 9front taking this step for years. Now I'm really
> surprised about some remarks in this thread. BSD or MIT licensed software
> encourages the use of such software in closed source products. GPL restricts
> this.

Hahaha. Everything I say here is just my personal opinion, not some
fucking official 9front foundation official political theater. And you
misunderstood it completely. I guess you really like legalese, and you
thus never managed to think for even one second about the philosophy
and intent behind the license.

> I'm also willing to support those projects with code I thing will be of
> value for others and giving them also the right to use this code open
> sourced or closed source as they prefer and allowed by applying the mit
> licence for my parts.

I never doubted your intent either. Given that you're trying to use
this for education already gave you max. points for first impression.
Doesn't mean I won't technically disagree. Make with it what you will.

------------------------------------------
9fans: 9fans
Permalink: 
https://9fans.topicbox.com/groups/9fans/T3e07bfdf263a83c8-M8319ff8d345f54aaaf0ef2cb
Delivery options: https://9fans.topicbox.com/groups/9fans/subscription

Reply via email to