Ok, no so simple, since energy is important for detectors. They are sensible only to some energy values.... If we detect none, it may just be because they are too much or too few energetic. However if some neutrino are detected that can eliminate many scenarios.
Maybe a bit complicated to make a joke. 2013/6/13 Edmund Storms <[email protected]> > > On Jun 12, 2013, at 4:13 PM, Edmund Storms wrote: > > Yes a neutrino would be produced. However, as I have said often, the >> electron is added after almost all the excess mass-energy has been emitted >> as weak photons. Therefore, the neutrino would have very little energy to >> carry away, thereby not reducing the observed energy by a significant >> amount. >> >> The electron is added as part of the fusion process, not in advance to >> make a free neutron as proposed by W-L and Brillouin. Consequently no >> energy has to be assembled. The energy resulting from the fusion process is >> more than enough to allow the neutron to form within the final nuclear >> product, not as a free neutron. The timing makes all the difference. >> >> Ed >> >> >> >> On Jun 12, 2013, at 3:53 PM, [email protected] wrote: >> >> In reply to Edmund Storms's message of Wed, 12 Jun 2013 10:41:33 -0600: >>> Hi, >>> [snip] >>> >>>> Alain, millions of scientists have worked over the last 200 years to >>>> define rules that are so well known they are called laws. These laws >>>> must not be violated without a very good reason. If you want to use >>>> the disco analogy, this disco has a very strong bouncer who will not >>>> tolerate certain kinds of behavior. Some of us have met this bouncer >>>> and show respect. If you do not know the bouncer, I suggest you stay >>>> out of the disco because otherwise you will get into serious trouble. >>>> >>>> W-L and Brillouin have proposed behavior that violates the rules >>>> (laws). As a result, they will be eventually thrown out of the disco. >>>> It's only a matter of time. >>>> >>>> Ed >>>> >>> >>> >>> Ed, need I point out that your own theory would also produce neutrinos? >>> >>> Regards, >>> >>> Robin van Spaandonk >>> >>> http://rvanspaa.freehostia.**com/project.html<http://rvanspaa.freehostia.com/project.html> >>> >>> >> >
