[email protected] wrote:
Actually that depends on whether the flow rate was measured with the device
attached or not.
Sure. I have seen that often enough with pond pumps.
The thing is, I suppose any scientist would know that. As I said before,
I am assuming these people are not stupid. But they could be! I guess I
have met a few professors who were dumb enough to measure the flow rate
the wrong way, such that it changes by a factor of 10 and they don't notice.
I will grant, there is not enough information in this report to rule
this sort of thing out, but I do not get the impression they are stupid
or senile. On the other hand, Jones Beene does get that impression, and
he might be right.
It is even possible they are crooks, in cahoots with Rossi. As I said,
this is why we need more replications.
- Jed
