Jones Beene wrote:
Their statement is either senile or idiotic, take your pick. Copper migration is well known, and no lucid physicist misses this point. Kullander misses it. Is he senile or stupid?
I do not think that this much copper can migrate through stainless steel, so I doubt that can explain the presence of the copper.
As far as I know, E&K are merely entertaining the hypothesis. That is to say, they are taking it seriously long enough to see if it fits the facts better than, say, experimental error, macroscopic amounts of copper migrating through steel, or a chemical source of heat. I am quite sure they realize that the copper should have shifted isotopes if it was transmuted from nickel.
I think they agree the copper is puzzling and there is no clear explanation for it.
They are scientists, so they entertain all hypothesis with an open mind, rather than dismissing them out of hand. Every scientist over 60 I know does this. They also all implicitly believe definitive experiments when they see them. They tend to be empiricists.
I repeat, your intemperate ad hominem attacks against these people, and others (including me) are out of line and inappropriate this forum. You should apologize and desist. Even if you believe Kullander may be senile, it does not enhance your argument to say so, and I -- for one -- do not think you are qualified to diagnose senility in person you have not met on the basis of this report. I see no evidence for senility whatsoever in this report. On the contrary, this kind of open-minded willingness to look at all the facts and entertain all hypotheses is a sign of a young and nimble mind.
- Jed

