From: Jed Rothwell 

 

Jones Beene wrote:



I find it closer to delusional than conclusive. These two Swedes are acting
more like cheer-leaders than top scientists. Kullander is 'emeritus' and
could be approaching senility . . .


> JR: In my opinion, such ad hominem comments are inappropriate for this
forum. There is no evidence for any this. 

Of course there is ample evidence ! Try reading the post, instead jumping to
the defense of the indefensible - with off-the-wall comments that really
have no place anywhere that "factuality" intends to prevail over voodoo
science. 

Kullander and Essen clearly stated that the copper they found was a natural
ratio, but was nevertheless "indicative of fusion". 

In fact the opposite is true.

Their statement is either senile or idiotic, take your pick. Copper
migration is well known, and no lucid physicist misses this point. Kullander
misses it. Is he senile or stupid?

In my opinion such defense of obvious bogosity - coming from someone who
should know better, is in appropriate for this forum.

If Kullander can offer a lucid defense of those remarks - then let him. It
is not appropriate for Rothwell to try to invent a phony defense for such
BS.

Jones

Reply via email to