Edmund Storms wrote:

By doing nothing, they could count on claiming that they did not believe the letter or did not read it. I imagine the person getting the letter would discuss the implication with his immediate boss. The advice would be to ignore the letter, whereupon the letter would disappear.

Since the letter did disappear, something like this must have happened.

I agree this is a likely scenario, but I add to it one more factor: a person claiming he did not believe the letter is probably telling the truth! Heck, I wouldn't believe it. Who would? However, they should have done some fact-checking even if they did not believe it. They should have suspended disbelief for a few hours. That is their job.

The same applies to cold fusion. We cannot expect a busy professional scientist who gets a short letter will suddenly be convinced that cold fusion is real. A scientist in some unrelated field has no obligation to stop and think about it. Life is too short to evaluate every claim that is made. But an energy policymaker who learns of this subject should suspended disbelief and spend a few hours looking at papers and thinking. This is his or her job.

I think it is highly unlikely that a high official read this letter, suspected it might be true, and then dismissed it. They must have thought: "This can't be true." Not: "So what? $50 billion is a minor violation of the security laws, and no one will blame me Madoff is caught." That would be insane.

It reminds me a little of the US military officers' behavior at Pearl Harbor on the morning of December 7, 1941, as evidence mounted that an attack was coming in. They had gotten warning after warning from Washington; they saw radar images of aircraft approaching; and they bombed and sank a Japanese submarine just outside the harbor . . . yet still they did not believe it! They did not even bother to sound general quarters. They could not bring themselves to believe the data, or act upon it. They were numbed. These officers were not traitors, and they were not stupid. Most of them continued to serve at headquarters for the rest of the war and did excellent jobs. I get a sense they did not believe an attack was coming because it seemed so astounding.

Along the same lines, I find it difficult to believe that Al Gore, the editors of Sci. Am., Robert Park and others who have trashed cold fusion actually believe it might be a viable source of energy. They must be thinking it is an experimental error or a diversion or an unimportant anomaly. I can't imagine they are actually trying to suppress what they consider a potentially important source of energy! They aren't that destructive, or evil. As far as I can tell they are merely stupid.

Other people strike me as evil. It would not surprise me to learn that someone in an oil company or the Japanese Min. of Education actually did think cold fusion is a viable source of energy and suppressed it for that reason.

- Jed

Reply via email to